"I've posted this in football because most of the Cougar Club members support football. And this is about cougar club and football fans. And that's great that you are." Cougar Club, and thus its members, support all BYU athletics. In fact, Legacy members get free admission to Olympic Sports, including.., wait for it..... Women's Soccer.
"It sold out in one minute." How long was the Cougar Club-only period? Was it longer than one minute? I think it was. Again, you could have had a longer window, but you don't want to pay the price of admission.
"I'm not a cougar club member because of the brawl 5 years ago." If you mean the Memphis game, that was in 2014. It's currently 2021, so that was 7 years ago, not 5. Is anyone still on the team from back then?
Look, you like Women's Soccer and support the team. Great, but you stated yourself that you won't take the next step and support them by joining the Cougar Club because of the brawl: "Even if it goes to all sports I don't care. Not happening ever."
In closing, suck it up, buttercup. You made your choice, now you get to live with it, ALL of it.