No he's not. They would find a good replacement. Remember when Detmer was OC

Dec 2, 2021
2:41:42pm

pinolero All-American

And BYU was 4-9. Or Doman who squandered one of the best defenses BYU ever had in 2012?

BYU needs very good QB play, they've gotten by with so-so CBs and coaches.

The difference in 2020 and 2021 for BYU football hasn't been cornerbacks.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Dec 2, 2021 at 2:41:42pm

Message modified by pinolero on Dec 2, 2021 at 2:42:59pm

Report problem with this ad

pinolero

Bio page: pinolero
Joined: Mar 16, 2008
Last login: Apr 30, 2024
Total posts: 5,718 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Gurney with a hint to potential D shakeups

P-Boy Squad All-American

12/2/21 10:47am

Gifford would be a big loss.

DieHarder

12/2/21 10:48am

Yeah but I am sure he doesn't want to be a position coach for forever and strike while the iron is hot.

P-Boy Squad

12/2/21 10:51am

I'd throw Unga in there.

SpecialT

12/2/21 11:02am

And Unga

hardcorecoug

12/2/21 11:06am

Dibs

SpecialT

12/2/21 11:15am

Just agreeing to make your dibs stronger 🙂

hardcorecoug

12/2/21 11:23am

Gifford is old but not THAT old. I mean we have 20 years before we lose him yes?

Reasonable1

12/2/21 12:21pm

Please hire Tuiaki as head coach. We want to keep Lamb and Gilford

BYU '80

12/2/21 10:48am

Please CSU, take Lamb off our hands!

molodyets

12/2/21 10:58am

What's your beef with Lamb?

Tricky

12/2/21 11:05am

Lamb is not as good as most think

Rat

12/2/21 11:24am

And underappreciated by those that say he's overvalued. His recruiting philosophy has helped BYU tremendously.

Turnpike Lane

12/2/21 12:15pm

His recruiting philosophy is actually one of the reasons that hurts his case

Rat

12/2/21 12:44pm

Maybe moving the to B12, but not from 2016 til now.

Turnpike Lane

12/2/21 12:50pm

How so?

Reasonable1

12/2/21 1:00pm

Do you have any objectivity to your opinions?

Pretorian

12/2/21 1:58pm

His “recruiting philosophy” is like circa-2000 GEICO

Coop

12/2/21 1:08pm

He lost more games than he won at SUU. His overall record was 45 - 47.

Bullrider

12/3/21 8:49am

If you take away the FBS games which are a higher division his record is 44-41. Also won 2 conference championships.

SolidBlue

12/3/21 9:33am

Also put multiple players into the NFL from SUU

Reasonable1

12/3/21 5:21pm

I Dont agree. I had the most amazing Lamb at an Italian Restaurant in St. George

Ode to Hoy

12/2/21 2:58pm

"Fair catch the kick off or else" never uttered by lamb cost us every time

CarolinaCoug

12/2/21 5:46pm

Gilford, yes. Lamb, no.

Rise Against

12/2/21 11:05am

No lamb needs to go

arizonacougarfan

12/2/21 11:06am

The Lamb "hate" is a reflection of

sandiegocgrfan

12/2/21 1:56pm

It's kind of a Heaps/Nelson deal. "insider's" opinions of Lamb depend wholly on who from the program has your ear.

kccougar

12/2/21 1:58pm

RE: It's kind of a Heaps/Nelson deal. "insider's" opinions of Lamb depend

sandiegocgrfan

12/2/21 2:31pm

It’s not whether he is a good coach. It’s how he gets along with players.

Thrill

12/2/21 5:19pm

Lamb is awful. Every time he leaves a position group it becomes better.

byubyu

12/2/21 5:46pm

Weird how that has worked out ,huh?

CarolinaCoug

12/2/21 5:52pm

Only an idiot st coach purposely loses yards on returns=lamb. No rxcuse.NONE

CarolinaCoug

12/2/21 5:51pm

He coached ST they were a joke, he coached safeties, they were a joke back to ST

Big12Yfan

10/29/22 1:40pm

Why would we wonder about CSU job openings when they don't even have a coach?

mokelembembe

12/2/21 10:52am

Because maybe their HC target is currently a staff member in Provo?

molodyets

12/2/21 10:58am

Doubt that, but I think Grimes could be so maybe that's the thinking. Makes sense.

mokelembembe

12/2/21 11:01am

Vic So'oto may be available. Would be a good hire.

MarkWatney

12/2/21 10:56am

Why? It seems the d-line there was mediocre

HoustonCougar

12/2/21 11:07am

He's pretty well respected. USC completely revamped their defensive scheme last year and went to a 3-4. They didn't

MarkWatney

12/2/21 11:28am

H3 has more defensive experience 5han Tuiaki had. His dlines were and are better

CarolinaCoug

12/3/21 1:54am

Who wants coach a D-line that gets no help because we drop 8

Count Cougar

12/2/21 12:18pm

Would be a great hire

Tuskaloosa Cougar

12/2/21 4:32pm

Great... we're going to lose people like Gilford and have to keep Tuiaki

letthewookieewin

12/2/21 11:01am

Hadley is one I might expect. Then Lamb if he can become a DC or HC. Tuiaki if he gets the SUU job.

Turnpike Lane

12/2/21 12:17pm

Agree. I'm all in for replacing Hadley and Lamb. Gilford must be retained.

Twitch Chatter

12/2/21 1:28pm

After Kalani, Gilford is the 2nd most important person on the staff.

molodyets

12/2/21 1:36pm

No it's A-Rod. As BYU's QBs go so goes BYU. We've gotten by with so-so DBs a lot

pinolero

12/2/21 1:44pm

We have a potential replacement for A-Rod in Fesi. Gilford as a black, non-LDS alumni with good exp is irreplaceable.

molodyets

12/2/21 1:57pm

No he's not. They would find a good replacement. Remember when Detmer was OC

pinolero

12/2/21 2:41pm

This is correct

thegoodmeister

12/2/21 6:52pm

Has he applied for that SUU job?

AntiSNOT

12/2/21 11:37pm

Lamb is our Assistant HC why would he aspire to be a DC?

ManicBlue

12/2/21 11:40pm

Just ran through some CSU desired coaching lists. Not a peep of anybody remotely related to BYU. Not Grimes, not anyone.

mokelembembe

12/2/21 3:00pm

Maybe Bronco could come back as DC. 🙂

ManicBlue

12/2/21 3:29pm

Would not go well at all with KS. Too close for Bronco, and styles

BYUHgrad

12/2/21 4:12pm

I don't agree.

ManicBlue

12/2/21 4:21pm

Bronco called defenses (sans Howell) are awesome. Totally agree.

BYUHgrad

12/2/21 4:32pm

RE: Bronco called defenses (sans Howell) are awesome. Totally agree.

ManicBlue

12/2/21 4:34pm

For sure. I could dream that, too!!

BYUHgrad

12/2/21 5:52pm

Well..i doubt its the one we need to leave.

Posting on CougarBoard