Or Willie Mays. I think of Mantle and Mays as contemporaries so I'm good with either. Mays may be the GOAT so sure.

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

May 5, 2022
9:28:04am

shimmy uva uvam vivendo varia fit

Or Willie Mays. I think of Mantle and Mays as contemporaries so I'm good with either. Mays may be the GOAT so sure.

Report problem with this ad

shimmy

Previous username: AFCoug83
Bio page: shimmy
Joined: Jan 15, 2008
Last login: May 2, 2024
Total posts: 117,253 (37,029 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Excluding MJ, when was the last time you saw an outfielder as good as Trout?

ochobeeguy

5/5/22 9:08am

Griffey Jr.

5/5/22 9:10am

Sir, you seem to have answered the wrong prompt.

TCuz

5/5/22 9:11am

Are you talking hitting or defense? Because if you are talking defense, Trout is

Jdoc

5/5/22 9:13am

Hitting alone does not an outfielder make. Same as point guard.

ochobeeguy

5/5/22 9:14am

Trout is an amazing regular season hitter and a solid defensive outfielder.

Jdoc

5/5/22 9:17am

Trout isn't the best defensive outfielder on his own team, but is the best center fielder since at least Mickey Mantle.

shimmy

5/5/22 9:16am

Uh, Willie Mays?

Jdoc

5/5/22 9:18am

Or Willie Mays. I think of Mantle and Mays as contemporaries so I'm good with either. Mays may be the GOAT so sure.

shimmy

5/5/22 9:28am

I never 'saw' Mantle or Mays play, which is why I went with Griffey. Also

5/5/22 10:33am

People out here acting like Griffey Jr. never existed

sidsie716

5/5/22 9:27am

Trout is much better than Griffey.

shimmy

5/5/22 9:29am

I would say it’s debatable. Griffey was amazing for the first 10 years of his

Jdoc

5/5/22 9:31am

Trout already has more WAR than Griffey compiled in Seattle. You could argue either way right now, but not for much

shimmy

5/5/22 9:35am

It’s closer than I thought but Trout still has him beat by a decent margin.

TCuz

5/5/22 9:35am

Some interesting stats to compare the two

JDBlue

5/5/22 10:39am

Let me know when you post the interesting stats

TCuz

5/5/22 10:46am

Hank Aaron??

5/5/22 9:27am

I believe he played right field for most of his career.

Jdoc

5/5/22 9:29am

Yeah Brain fart on my part

5/5/22 10:44am

Center fielder?

shimmy

5/5/22 9:29am

Yeah he played right field. Played left field his rookie year. I’m not sure

5/5/22 10:44am

Omar Vizquel

5/5/22 9:17am

Von Miller

scall

5/5/22 9:26am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad