He said he talked to coaches, players and watched film etc to come up with his list.
5. Matthew Stafford
4. Justin Herbert
3. Aaron Rodgers
2. Patrick Mahomes
1. Josh Allen
Other names that he said came up with coaches were (still) Tom Brady and Zach Wilson. One of the other hosts of the show said Dak Prescott should be considered as well.
Who else do you think should be considered? Burrow, Carr?
I'd rank it 1. Allen 2. Herbert 3. Mahomes