For me there's no in between with Shepherd's Pie

May 18, 2022
12:21:10pm

RockyBalboa All-American

Either it's pretty dang good and that's because whoever made it nailed it.

Or it's super bad.

There's no in between for me.

I love a well made, delicious shepherd's pie.

Report problem with this ad

RockyBalboa

Previous username: MesaCougar
Bio page: RockyBalboa
Joined: Apr 24, 2002
Last login: May 8, 2024
Total posts: 48,335 (1,436 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Grossly underrated food: Shepherd's Pie

Revolution

5/18/22 12:07pm

Agreed. Now please convince my wife.

Y_Mountain_Magic

5/18/22 12:08pm

Why convince her? Just make it yourself and she can have some if she wants.

Revolution

5/18/22 12:10pm

If you live along the Wasatch Front, pick one or two up at June Pies in Heber. Good quality. Call in advance.

Brisco

5/18/22 12:17pm

Depends on the green beans. If they're mushy it is garbage.

shimmy

5/18/22 12:09pm

When I make it I skip the beans, or leave them as a side. Root veg only with

joelvandyne

5/18/22 12:13pm

Peas > green beans

Coop

5/18/22 12:19pm

RE: Peas > green beans

shimmy

5/18/22 12:20pm

RE: Peas > green beans

Coop

5/18/22 12:20pm

I have only had it with organ meat, so no Kidneys or liver for me.

Ycrazy

5/18/22 12:10pm

I recommend using normal ground beef (or ground pork)

Revolution

5/18/22 12:11pm

It's not shepherds pie if there isn't Lamb in it. Hence the name

Hotlanta

5/18/22 12:18pm

Should have shepherd meat in it.

cougfanblue

5/18/22 12:28pm

I appreciate the correction. I'll start referring to it as Shepherd's Pie*

Revolution

5/18/22 12:32pm

We need not conform to the rules of British "cuisine", nor should we.

cougfanblue

5/18/22 12:46pm

Gross is absolutely the correct term.

BYUtka

5/18/22 12:10pm

I get it. Including veggies in recipes probably disgusts you.

Revolution

5/18/22 12:17pm

Huh??? What do you mean?

BYUtka

5/18/22 1:16pm

I once ordered it at a restaurant with my coworkers and they poo-pooed it like a

txblue

5/18/22 12:11pm

Yuck

cougfanblue

5/18/22 12:11pm

I love Shepherds pie...

Coug

5/18/22 12:12pm

I've never had it with crust. I don't think I would enjoy that as much.

Revolution

5/18/22 12:14pm

It's ok... I would rather have it without the crust

Coug

5/18/22 12:15pm

I used to get pies from this place frequently when I was living in NZ.

barnacle

5/18/22 12:14pm

Do they use US dollars in NZ, or is there an NZ dollar?

Revolution

5/18/22 12:16pm

NZ dollar.

barnacle

5/18/22 12:17pm

New Zealand isn’t a U.S. territory!

Brisco

5/18/22 12:20pm

As the young kids say these days - hard pass!

Texas Hammer

5/18/22 12:18pm

Not a huge fan of cheese on it, but love it a lot

Coop

5/18/22 12:18pm

That sounds similar to the chicken dumpling recipe that I make. Good stuff.

Revolution

5/18/22 12:21pm

For me there's no in between with Shepherd's Pie

RockyBalboa

5/18/22 12:21pm

I love all those things separately, but absolutely hate them put together in Shepherd's Pie.

byujag

5/18/22 12:22pm

As long as there are no onions in it.

rebelCoug

5/18/22 12:23pm

for fast food option, substitute tater tots for mashed potatoes. I make it

PhilPete

5/18/22 12:26pm

Wow. This might be the first time I've received good advice on CB.

Revolution

5/18/22 12:29pm

Funny - I read this 5 minutes after my sons requested I make it. My mods-

dryflyelk

5/18/22 12:29pm

That's basically what I do. I use cream of chicken or cream of mushroom soup.

Revolution

5/18/22 12:31pm

First time I had it was on my mission. My ZL invited me and my comp over for

Posting on CougarBoard