I guess it depends on what each of us means when we say “top” play

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jun 23, 2022
8:41:32pm

Yllage Vidiot Humbly Awesome

I guess it depends on what each of us means when we say “top” play

Report problem with this ad

Yllage Vidiot

Previous username: kerichar
Bio page: Yllage Vidiot
Joined: Oct 4, 2011
Last login: Apr 18, 2024
Total posts: 10,209 (211 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Where does everyone rank the Tyler Allgeier punch-out in BYU’s all time top plays? I place it 5th.

Yllage Vidiot Humbly Awesome

6/23/22 7:45pm

Somewhere in 30 to 40 range

6/23/22 7:47pm

And I would put Kyle Morrell's leap over the line as #2 all time

6/23/22 7:52pm

<< Deleted >>

6/23/22 7:56pm

How is Mangum Miracle even top ten?

fulano

6/23/22 8:03pm

We beat Nebraska at their place on a true Hail Mary. Freshman QB just back from his mission thrown into game d/t injury

6/23/22 8:09pm

You can count on one hand the number of actual hail mary last play of the game

Y05

6/23/22 8:25pm

It would be interesting to come up with an actual list of true “Hail Mary’s”, ie last sec long (> 30 yds?) game winners

6/23/22 8:35pm

You dropped Bosco to Smith for the National Championship????

Tare

6/23/22 8:03pm

Yep. Good play but not top 10 IMO. I went for wow factor of the play itself I guess.

6/23/22 8:06pm

I like for "wow factor" to get greater emphasis on a top plays list.

Y05

6/23/22 8:22pm

Significance of situation has to play into it. For example, if we kicked a routine 30 yard fg as time expired to win a

thewaterboy

6/23/22 8:31pm

I guess it depends on what each of us means when we say “top” play

6/23/22 8:41pm

You are talking “most significant”/“historically impactful”, not “best individual effort” top plays, I think.

6/23/22 9:18pm

No way. Then we should just go down the list of most important games and cite final plays of consequence regardless of

mvtoro

6/23/22 9:29pm

That would be a dumb list. Good thing that's not what I said.

thewaterboy

6/24/22 5:08am

Any list that is topped by, as you said, a “routine field goal” as the all-time top play, is a dumb list.

mvtoro

6/24/22 1:18pm

Answer: About #50. Maybe. It was cool but overall impact was low compared to

BleedCougarBlue2

6/24/22 12:11am

Agree to disagree. Most impactful play I’ve seen in a long time. How was the “overall impact low”? I don’t understand.

6/24/22 4:26am

Kyle Morrell's play is #2 - not just because it was an incredible play, but

Emmett Fitz-Hume

6/24/22 4:45am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad