I actually really like it. I could, but I won't be critical about it. I've tried a variety of other BYU podcasts, and this is the one I keep coming back to.
Locked On is not frequent enough for me, but it also has far too many ads. Also, Jake is often more cryptic than I want him to be. (IF you can't talk about a topic, just don't bring it up, stop playing the "I know something you don't know" game).
I listen to pieces of Criddle's show too. His is definitely guilty of being repetitive. I think even he would admit to that. He's still fun to listen to though. I would probably like his show more with fewer ads. He also spends quite a bit of time on topics that I have zero interest in (because he's got 3 hours to fill).
Give Em Hell was good too, but I didn't like weekly updates, I'm more looking for something daily. I also found it to be more relaxed than I want when I am running. Those guys don't get excited about much, at least on the episodes I've listened to.
BYUSN is not perfect, but it's the one I enjoy the most and by quite a good margin.