Young, Detmer, McMahon, Wilson (Zach), LaVell
First man off is probably Chad Lewis.
I lean towards those with unique honors (Heisman, HOF), notable NFL careers and likelihood to impress recruits.
Others that deserve to be there under this criteria but not as attractive to recruits due to lack of recency or position:
Bart Oates
Gordon Hudson
Todd Christensen
Taysom Hill
John Tait
Brett Keisel
Via Sikahema
Jason Buck
Austin Collie
Warner
KVN