Yes, 9.3 is elite. Ohtani is having a great season. Judge is having a historic Top 25 fWAR season ever.

Sep 30, 2022
10:03:50am

TCuz Disgraced Rules President

And besides Barry Bonds from 2001-2004, all those other Top 25 seasons are from 60-100 years ago. Every single one.

Ted Williams. Mickey Mantle. Babe Ruth. Stan Musial. Rogers Hornsby. Lou Gehrig. Honus Wagner. Ty Cobb. Jimmie Foxx. Aaron Judge.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Sep 30, 2022 at 10:03:50am

Message modified by TCuz on Sep 30, 2022 at 10:06:15am

Report problem with this ad

TCuz

Previous username: TCuz13
Bio page: TCuz
Joined: Mar 1, 2014
Last login: May 23, 2024
Total posts: 58,802 (19,289 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Judge will win the MVP, but Ohtani should get it.

Jdoc

9/30/22 9:49am

Naw man. Judge’s value actually got his team to the playoffs.

Revolution

9/30/22 9:52am

One player doesn’t get a team to the playoffs.

Jdoc

9/30/22 9:55am

one player doesn't = playoffs. In fact I would argue pitchers add more..

ordinary tri guy

9/30/22 9:56am

The playoff and team stuff is irrelevant. You could look to Win Probability Added

TCuz

9/30/22 10:11am

Judge fWAR: 11.0 Ohtani fWAR: 9.3. Not close.

TCuz

9/30/22 9:54am

These are both crazy numbers! Two great players

Mobettah

9/30/22 9:56am

Yes, 9.3 is elite. Ohtani is having a great season. Judge is having a historic Top 25 fWAR season ever.

TCuz

9/30/22 10:03am

Judge has been phenomenal. He is well deserving of the MVP.

Jdoc

9/30/22 10:02am

It’s fun and it’s unbelievable and has been worth less statistically than Judge’s all-time season.

TCuz

9/30/22 10:05am

MVP of an awful team? I guess.

mulletino

9/30/22 9:56am

Happens all of the time in baseball. I do think Judge should win though

Polemic

9/30/22 9:57am

I get what you are saying. Ohtani is having a remarkable year. 15 wins, 2.35 ERA

Posting on CougarBoard