supposedly leaked that mentioned something about them not looking for an LDS candidate, but I think that was likely blown out of proportion as simply meaning they weren't looking to limit themselves to an insider. And fair enough if true. A FB program of USU's size SHOULDN'T limit itself to LDS or instate candidates.
In terms of resume, Maile would've fairly been considered sub-standard candidate as an HC. That was quite likely the main issue why he wasn't up for consideration. Despite the ensuing drama & narratives — & their attempts to make it seem otherwise.