Well, since they rated him high, yes.

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 24, 2023
10:15:09am

All-American All-American

Well, since they rated him high, yes.

Report problem with this ad

All-American

Previous username: all_american01
Bio page: All-American
Joined: Sep 5, 2001
Last login: Mar 25, 2023
Total posts: 13,795 (43 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Heckard gets that 4 ⭐️ rating

Jan 24, 10:13am

So we're going all in with their ability to rate transfers? BYU is up to 33rd in the transfer portal rankings

Indy Coug

Jan 24, 10:14am

Well, since they rated him high, yes.

Jan 24, 10:15am

This is the way

rcbyufan

Jan 24, 10:23am

Way more college tape to rate transfers

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

Jan 24, 10:33am

And they still haven't even rated Fitzgerald. He's gotta be a 3-star.

mjmill

Jan 24, 10:38am

Bagnah, Lapuaho, and Cravens don’t count towards transfer ratings yet either

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

Jan 24, 11:00am

The amount of data makes it much easier to evaluate accurately

Jan 24, 10:38am

Curious if that #33 rating is just for players transferring in, or if it also

StantonMac

Jan 24, 10:54am

They still miss on their fair share.

slatecoug

Jan 24, 11:07am

guy seems like a real baller... so happy he chose us...

HarlemCoug

Jan 24, 10:16am

You know what this reminds me of? NFL free agency

Big12Yfan

Jan 24, 10:22am

BYU made it out just in time.

kccougar

Jan 24, 10:29am

Where are all the dudes complaining about getting an FCS DB?

Mjolnir

Jan 24, 10:37am

I did initially. I'll eat that crow if he balls out in 2023.

Jan 24, 10:38am

Hope he's a great player for us. Couldn't care less about star ratings. All

Adwight

Jan 24, 10:38am

When BYU gets a committed athlete to get a 4th star AFTER they commit

Jan 24, 10:39am

Not until they actually do anything worthwhile on the field. I think of guys

Adwight

Jan 24, 11:31am

A couple things. 4*+ athletes overwhelmingly contribute more on the field

Jan 24, 11:44am

The better recruiting ranking wins 75% of games. We already overachieve.

FieroCoug

Jan 24, 12:54pm

Cool info, but I think Slovis should be a 4* for sure. Underrated

AntiSNOT

Jan 24, 10:39am

When you consider that Keenan Pili was given a 4 star rating, I'd Slovis should also have received a 4 star rating.

slatecoug

Jan 24, 11:33am

Slovis is essentially a 4*. 3* ranges from 79-89.5- Slovis is 89, so as close..

Das_Countach

Jan 24, 1:02pm

But, but . . . our two 4 stars are not from P4 programs.

CrimWalCoug

Jan 24, 10:41am

Are we now caring about transfer ratings?

kimdaddy35

Jan 24, 3:11pm

They affect class ranking overall, so yeah. And you are concerned about recruits

Jan 24, 3:15pm

I love recruiting. Transfer portal guys are not the same. For one everyone already knows who they are. For another, they

kimdaddy35

Jan 24, 3:34pm

When you evaluate an incoming HS class do you subtract the graduating seniors?

kccougar

Jan 24, 3:50pm

Transfer Portal is the new recruiting. Prob more accurate ratings, less misses

Das_Countach

Jan 24, 3:58pm

Heck are came out of High School in 2017 as a 2*

Stalwartbob

Jan 24, 4:16pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad