They’ve gone way downhill. It’s fine, but shouldn’t be the answer anymore.

Report problem with this ad

May 25, 2023
6:37:15pm

TCuz Coastal Elite

I agree with this review and my opinions are objectively correct.

The New York Times

Peter Luger Used to Sizzle. Now It Sputters. (Published 2019)

The famed restaurant, which once defined the New York steakhouse experience, has lost its way.

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/29/dining/peter-luger-review-pete-wells.html

Report problem with this ad

TCuz

Previous username: TCuz13
Bio page: TCuz
Joined: Mar 1, 2014
Last login: May 21, 2024
Total posts: 58,762 (19,270 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

What’s the best steakhouse you’ve ever been to?

CougarHut Alpha Male

5/25/23 6:05pm

Bones, Atlanta

Kelbob

5/25/23 6:07pm

I had a killer filet mignon this last Tuesday Paul Martin's in Scottsdale.

Blue Golfer

5/25/23 6:07pm

<< Deleted >>

JimmyZ

5/25/23 6:08pm

We found their cream corn recipe online and it is now the go-to side for our Thanksgiving Dinner

Bonoman

5/25/23 6:59pm

<< Deleted >>

JimmyZ

5/25/23 7:15pm

Prove it

CosmosMeow

5/25/23 8:11pm

Was there the day they opened. In town on a business trip. Amazing place

BR549

5/25/23 9:37pm

Yes Yes Yes

TheHop

5/26/23 7:05am

The Star in Elko. But I’ve heard it’s gone downhill since the last time I was

Millhouse

5/25/23 6:10pm

Probably Manny’s in Minneapolis

Duke Silver

5/25/23 6:10pm

<< Deleted >>

ArcticKat

5/25/23 6:57pm

Osteria Vecchio Cancello

Ted Lasso

5/25/23 6:11pm

There’s probably 400 places in Texas alone better than that place.

WDaddy

5/25/23 6:16pm

I've never been to a Texas steakhouse. I look forward to it one day.

Ted Lasso

5/25/23 6:17pm

<< Deleted >>

JimmyZ

5/25/23 6:19pm

My dad's house.

Turn and Cough

5/25/23 6:11pm

There is a better alternative to every Pappas restaurant. Go to vic & anthonys

NarfUte

5/25/23 6:11pm

They look really incredible but I’ll be in DFW

CougarHut

5/25/23 6:13pm

You're not going to be disappointed by Pappas- for DFW I really like Chamberlain

NarfUte

5/25/23 6:26pm

Um I have to change my plans. Im staying at the galleria. It’s right down the street!

CougarHut

5/25/23 6:28pm

Prime 54 in Miami

Beggar

5/25/23 6:11pm

Texas Roadhouse

RSL

5/25/23 6:12pm

Cash or check only.

TCuz

5/25/23 6:15pm

Really the best of the inexpensive nationwide chains

LevZloi

5/25/23 6:57pm

I'm partial to Sundance Steakhouse in Palo Alto. Sure, there may be some that beat it, but it's really great

slappy

5/25/23 6:13pm

Morton's in Honolulu or Capital Grill in DC

panacablue

5/25/23 6:13pm

Outback is up there

Big12Yfan

5/25/23 6:15pm

Club 33

Idacoug

5/25/23 6:15pm

RE: Club 33

WDaddy

5/25/23 6:19pm

Deleted

PhilPete

5/25/23 6:35pm

Ruth’s Chris. At least that’s what I’ve heard.

BlooCoog

5/25/23 6:16pm

Quality Meats, NYC near Central Park. Heavenly.it was a CB recommend.

Nakedbootleg

5/25/23 6:17pm

The Metropolitan Grill - Seattle (The Met)

Saxa

5/25/23 6:18pm

Anything my dad throws on the bbq beats everything else every time

niqmadu

5/25/23 6:18pm

BBQ? Yeah, I can tell already that the steak sucks.

WDaddy

5/25/23 6:24pm

Clown comment. Niqmadu is extremely qualified and knowledgeable on the topic of

Turn and Cough

5/25/23 7:01pm

The man knows beef…. Not sure what exactly you know.

niqmadu

5/25/23 7:30pm

"on the bbq???" Do you mean, "on the grill?" Not a strong start......

Supercoug

5/25/23 8:02pm

Peter Luger. Medium rare porterhouse for the win!

byuwahoo

5/25/23 6:19pm

This is the correct answer

A Man in Full

5/25/23 6:30pm

They’ve gone way downhill. It’s fine, but shouldn’t be the answer anymore.

TCuz

5/25/23 6:37pm

In sad to hear it. I had is few times back in 2002 and it was amazing

scottpete

5/25/23 6:46pm

It may not be the best in 2023, but it was the best. So it is the correct answer

byuwahoo

5/27/23 5:59am

A5 Kobe steak at New York Grill atop the park hyatt tokyo

coug16

5/25/23 6:20pm

Probably Flemmings

Traveshamockery

5/25/23 6:20pm

Outback Steakhouse or Applebee’s

Mr. Rumsfield

5/25/23 6:21pm

Pappas Steakhouse is really good. You’ll enjoy it.

WDaddy

5/25/23 6:22pm

The steakhouse at Zermatt in Midway.

NumbersGuy

5/25/23 6:23pm

Brenner’s on the Bayou or Vic & Anthony’s (both in Houston)

Odysseus

5/25/23 6:31pm

very good

Supercoug

5/25/23 8:03pm

Shanahan’s.

Hawk in the 303

5/25/23 6:34pm

My own grill

PhilPete

5/25/23 6:43pm

Elway's in Denver was really good.

John Doe

5/25/23 6:43pm

RE: What’s the best steakhouse you’ve ever been to?

trubluman

5/25/23 6:45pm

Firebird Rocky Mountain Grill

Sam's Dad

5/25/23 6:49pm

Charles Mulligan's Steakhouse

IceCreamButt

5/25/23 6:51pm

RIP

Nakedbootleg

5/25/23 10:32pm

I haven’t been to very nice ones. Capital Grille on Broadway and Fleming’s in SLC are the best I’ve eaten at.

scootsy

5/25/23 6:53pm

Las Lilas in Buenos Aires or a steak house in Jerusalem I can’t recall the name

jollaksentie

5/25/23 6:54pm

Berns Steakhouse - Tampa Bay

Bonoman

5/25/23 6:56pm

Three Forks - Dallas also very good.

Bonoman

5/25/23 6:57pm

Hands down

BR549

5/25/23 9:38pm

Same.

sakar12

5/26/23 12:46am

Pappas Bros is probably the best ribeye I’ve ever had in my life.

Supercoug

5/25/23 7:01pm

My favs.... Hawksmoor (UK), Keens (NYC), Strip Steak (Vegas) (I think Capital Grille is the best restaurant in Utah).

HarlemCoug

5/25/23 7:07pm

Here's a cool video about Hawksmoor in NYC. Go eat there if you can. You're welcome.

HarlemCoug

5/25/23 8:26pm

Kirby's, DFW area.

Forzaitalia

5/25/23 7:20pm

Eddie Martini’s in MKE

Littlerich

5/25/23 7:26pm

Jocko's in nipomo, ca

supertux

5/25/23 7:26pm

Ringside in Portland was good. Maybe Michael Jordan's was the best I've been

Born2Fish

5/25/23 7:30pm

Golden Corral..

BYU Grounds

5/25/23 7:38pm

Gibson's in Chicago

byujag

5/25/23 7:51pm

Michael Jordan’s Steak House in Chicago is one of the best I’ve had.

dreamer

5/25/23 7:56pm

It is very good. Shared a Tomahawk steak with 2 others there. My favorite is likely Bazaar Meat in Las Vegas. The steak

specsauce

5/25/23 8:47pm

Rosebud in Chicago

xgbs

5/25/23 9:05pm

Pappas Bros is great. Chicago Chop House, Gallaghers, Bohanan's top my list.

ray ray

5/25/23 11:28pm

Fogo de Chao in Baltimore

robin

5/25/23 11:39pm

Chicago Chop House (about 12 years ago)

Peter Luger Used to Sizzle. Now It Sputters. (Published 2019)

Posting on CougarBoard