My Account
Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Apr 24, 2024
8:38
:07
am
Gustav
Truly Addicted User
RE: ...um...are you implying that as a recruit, if not for the money...
Of course that is all hypothetical, but so is your criticism.
Yeah, you're getting at the logic underlying the entire concept of bright-line rules. He broke one. Others did not.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Gustav
Previous username
gustav88
Bio page
Gustav
Joined
Sep 8, 2010
Last login
May 5, 2024
Total posts
49,590 (8,362 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
POLL: Did Reggie Bush deserve to get his Heisman trophy back even though he knowingly broke the rules that existed at the time?
BlooCoug
Apr 24, 8:09am
I once got a ticket and had to go to traffic school for going 76 in a 65. The current speed limit on that stretch of
Pete
Apr 24, 8:11am
Exactly.
BlooCoug
Apr 24, 8:14am
Wasn't that the point of traffic school?
LaserCoug
Apr 24, 8:23am
No...and he didn't cheat. Cheating would be like taking PEDs, not
Avery
Apr 24, 8:13am
I say yes because every school was absolutely doing what he did at the time.
Blueto
Apr 24, 8:14am
How did the SEC take down USC? Evidence, please, no conjecture. I'll wait.
Diablo and Doc
Apr 24, 8:48am
He didn't do anything against the rules to make himself the best player.
Jeffacka
Apr 24, 8:15am
Did he cheat or did USC cheat?
Dr T-bone
Apr 24, 8:16am
Both cheated?
BlooCoug
Apr 24, 8:17am
Yes
valcorger
Apr 24, 8:18am
Not a big fan of the phrasing here
Medute
Apr 24, 8:17am
Enticing him with money to play for an excellent team didn’t benefit him? What
BlooCoug
Apr 24, 8:20am
...um...are you implying that as a recruit, if not for the money...
The Dark Knight
Apr 24, 8:24am
Hard to know. Some good programs don’t have excellent offensive lines. The fact
BlooCoug
Apr 24, 8:27am
sounds like we both have the story wrong. It was hiring a pro agent
The Dark Knight
Apr 24, 9:36am
RE: ...um...are you implying that as a recruit, if not for the money...
Gustav
Apr 24, 8:38am
He was a 5 star athlete recruited by Oregon, Washington, Texas, ND. He’s winning the heisman at any of those schools.
Housemartin
Apr 24, 8:34am
No matter what he was going to play for a top team
Medute
Apr 24, 8:55am
The $ Bush’s family received came from individuals who wanted to be his agents
specialk808
Apr 24, 9:21am
Sounds like a heavier version of Kuzma benefits
Medute
Apr 24, 1:00pm
I have no problem with it. He/USC got busted for doing the same thing schools
Duke Silver
Apr 24, 8:24am
I'd love to see a class action lawsuit against the NCAA and its staff
mobicurious
Apr 24, 8:32am
Absolutely, it’s not like he was taking performance enhancing drugs. he played
A Drew Aitch
Apr 24, 8:38am
I'd like to see equal application of the law, seems like USC and Bush were
Rhubarb
Apr 24, 8:42am
"Other people did it too" is hardly a compelling reason to let an offender off
Gustav
Apr 24, 8:45am
Oh I agree, I'm talking about equal application of the law, NCAA enforces these
Rhubarb
Apr 24, 9:06am
It is if there is unequal application of the law. If the cops are only targeting
Blueto
Apr 24, 9:36am
And you think they were doing that here? If so, based on what?
Gustav
Apr 24, 9:51am
I'll give just one example. Jonny Manziel. He was getting hundreds of thousands
Blueto
Apr 24, 10:03am
What are you suggesting?
Gustav
Apr 24, 10:46am
SEC. Shocked that any BYU fan would on this side of the argument. Dave Rose got
Blueto
Apr 24, 10:54am
I’m fine that he is getting it back, but saying it’s because of the current
gwill
Apr 24, 8:44am
The Astros cheated. Bush did not.
Longseason
Apr 24, 10:19am
Both broke rules of the game. Did USC pay other players ie lineman to help Bush
Ycrazy
Apr 24, 10:27am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad