My Account
Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Aug 22, 2014
6:25
:23
pm
Undefeated
most byu fans don't believe 12-0 would get a playoff spot but a ny6 spot.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Undefeated
Previous username
jdg
Bio page
Undefeated
Joined
Mar 25, 2005
Last login
May 8, 2024
Total posts
7,590 (18 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
CFB Matrix
BRONCOUGAR
8/22/14 3:43pm
8-4 - this is blasphemy
Dr T-bone
8/22/14 3:45pm
8-4 against this schedule would be a disappointment.
newey-west
8/22/14 3:48pm
12-0 we will NOT be in Miami in December.
rggee
8/22/14 3:52pm
"Emphasis on Conference Champions" No way 2 P5 Champs left out of the playoff
DoseOfReality
8/22/14 3:58pm
We would not be in the playoff. We'd be in the Peach/Fiesta/Cotton Bowl.
rggee
8/22/14 4:00pm
There is no way that BYU is making the playoff this year.
newey-west
8/22/14 3:59pm
RE: There is no way that BYU is making the playoff this year.
rggee
8/22/14 4:01pm
Does 12-0 put BYU in the top 10?
newey-west
8/22/14 4:04pm
Absolutely
rggee
8/22/14 4:06pm
There are 12 slots - 4 in the playoff, 2 will be conference based, 1 G5,
rggee
8/22/14 4:08pm
Good catch. I stand corrected.
newey-west
8/22/14 7:45pm
Thats what I was thinking, I think Boise could be a win, also UCF.
BRONCOUGAR
8/22/14 3:49pm
"comparing them to the other 65 Big 5 conference teams" SMOOOOKE!!!!
rggee
8/22/14 3:49pm
He's right and yet so wrong.
lawboy
8/22/14 3:51pm
Beat Houston and lose to VA? Ha!
rggee
8/22/14 3:53pm
Even utah fans would bet over on that. 8-4. Really?
me'a pango cougars
8/22/14 4:08pm
i heard this guy ramble on and on on the CougarCenter podcast
nashty
8/22/14 4:26pm
Plus, how is he evaluating talent?
mogelijk
8/22/14 6:16pm
I have been preaching 9-3. 8-4 is too low.
The Lone Wolf
8/22/14 4:43pm
He predicted 7-5 last year, I believe.
SoCalCoug
8/22/14 4:50pm
So since he said 7-5 and we were 8-4, then we should be at least 9-3 this year
Undefeated
8/22/14 4:58pm
I think BYU gets Boise St. Other than that, I can agree with his thought
BlueForLife
8/22/14 5:23pm
Most important quote from above:
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 5:31pm
most byu fans don't believe 12-0 would get a playoff spot but a ny6 spot.
Undefeated
8/22/14 6:25pm
An undefeated BYU won't get a NY6 spot over a P5 conference runner up
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 6:35pm
(The above was meant as a response to "Undefeated")
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 6:36pm
Strength of schedule won't really even be determined until the end of the season
rggee
8/22/14 6:57pm
The committee's "rankings" will start being being released in October.
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 7:05pm
If we are undefeated and left out I will be shocked and outraged.
rggee
8/22/14 7:15pm
I will be outraged but not shocked.
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 7:18pm
#1: We only lose here to 1 team (2 max) out of the 5 at large spots.
rggee
8/22/14 7:21pm
For instance
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 7:30pm
An undefeated BYU would absolutely be taken over a two loss P5 team.
rggee
8/22/14 7:33pm
Keep drinking the Kool Aid.
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 7:36pm
First we have to actually go undefeated. But if that happens and we are not
rggee
8/22/14 7:39pm
I guess I have more faith in humanity (or just the committee) than you
rggee
8/22/14 7:40pm
Concerning the committee, yes, you do.
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 7:45pm
BYU would definitely have a shot of jumping a 2 win P5 team
Dr T-bone
8/22/14 8:09pm
Your presentation actually makes the opposite case as I see it.
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 8:18pm
If you consider wins only and not losses
Dr T-bone
8/22/14 8:25pm
I wish they would do it that way.
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 8:59pm
I've already hashed this out too many times before with others and have shown
Undefeated
8/22/14 8:06pm
"In certain years"?!?!
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 8:21pm
Why are we !! ?
Undefeated
8/22/14 8:33pm
The crux of the argument
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 8:38pm
sos and win loss record together. not just sos. all 2 loss teams vs an unbeaten
Undefeated
8/22/14 8:42pm
I guess at this point it is simply a matter of disagreement.
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 8:53pm
Guys... think about it.
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 9:04pm
RE: Guys... think about it.
Undefeated
8/22/14 9:27pm
what you fail to consider is
DJROSS
8/22/14 9:32pm
What SOS formulas are you speaking of?
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 9:35pm
CFP will use sos until
DJROSS
8/22/14 9:39pm
Is this your opinion or is there documentation of this?
Samurai Jack
8/22/14 9:46pm
Oh no he didn't
Reedme
8/22/14 8:10pm
He went off recruiting class ratings. BYU has consistently had poor class
CougarPilot
8/22/14 11:04pm
That's my point, once players start playing recruiting class rankings are useles
Reedme
8/23/14 12:04am
Preach on brother...I couldn't agree more.
CougarPilot
8/23/14 10:14pm
bull pucky. And NDs sched isn't really tougher. this year i count 5 difficult
BBLUE76
8/22/14 9:52pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
