My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Aug 23, 2014
7:36
:19
pm
BYUFam1
The committee vote itself is a poll
It is not the ones we are used to from the past but it is still a poll.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
BYUFam1
Bio page
BYUFam1
Joined
Jul 6, 2010
Last login
Apr 27, 2024
Total posts
25,225 (246 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
I gotta believe we'd get the G5 autobid if we're ranked higher than
Jersey hunter
8/23/14 11:52am
We have no autobid whatsover. We could be 3rd in the country and UCF could
LiveCoug
8/23/14 11:53am
We go undefeated and we are in. Nothing has changed for us.
Bluedomination
8/23/14 11:56am
We go undefeated and we are possibly in. Nothing has changed for us.
LiveCoug
8/23/14 11:58am
No way they keep an undefeated team out. No way.
Bluedomination
8/23/14 12:53pm
You sure about that? We may very well make it, but we have NO GUARANTEE at all
LiveCoug
8/23/14 12:58pm
The highest ranked teams are guaranteed
Coog4Life
8/23/14 2:10pm
BYU's only guarantee is if they are ranked 1 or 2. That's it.
LiveCoug
8/23/14 2:11pm
3,4 also guaranteed....sorry
Coog4Life
8/23/14 2:19pm
Well, sure if the committee says that BYU is 1,2,3 or 4.
LiveCoug
8/23/14 2:27pm
In 2014, committee #5 would also guarantee a spot
Coog4Life
8/23/14 2:47pm
^^^ truth ^^^
nashty
8/23/14 6:24pm
I believe that was the BCS criteria.
Samurai Jack
8/23/14 2:58pm
Do you think this is the days of the BCS 1 vs 2 only?
BYUFam1
8/23/14 7:30pm
you really think the committee will rank a 12-0 byu team lower than 10?
nashty
8/23/14 3:35pm
I absolutely do. Once again, CB needs to divorce the concept of ranking
Samurai Jack
8/23/14 4:27pm
And record is the third major criteria
scott715
8/23/14 7:12pm
Yet they claimed they don't intend to use any analytics like the BCS
BYUFam1
8/23/14 7:34pm
SOS isn't going to be calculated
Samurai Jack
8/24/14 9:05am
Then why all the fear of "perceived" do you even know what the 13 people
BYUFam1
8/24/14 10:44am
11 of the 13 members of the committee
Samurai Jack
8/24/14 4:30pm
Yes you are at a loss, loss of enjoyment of the game, loss of fanhood...
BYUFam1
8/24/14 5:08pm
Both times Utah went undefeated they were ranked outside of top 4 prior to bowl.
DoseOfReality
8/23/14 1:53pm
Very true, and... that was then, this is now.
Samurai Jack
8/23/14 5:54pm
The committee vote itself is a poll
BYUFam1
8/23/14 7:36pm
Agreed. We go to a New Year's Day bowl, but no G5 teams in playoff
Coogar2
8/23/14 6:45pm
That's just for playoffs - what about New Years Bowl games?
Jersey hunter
8/23/14 11:59am
No guarantees whatsoever. BYU and Army have worst access to the NY6 bowls.
rainorsnow
8/23/14 12:23pm
So the rule makers have gone out of their way to intentionally
Jersey hunter
8/23/14 11:57am
no, he is wrong
Coog4Life
8/23/14 12:45pm
Link to that guarantee? You are wrong. We MAY be in, sure, but there is
LiveCoug
8/23/14 12:48pm
TNT hates to agree with the mods but there it is
TNT
8/23/14 1:21pm
Read the cf playoff website
Coog4Life
8/23/14 2:08pm
Here are some links
BYUFam1
8/23/14 7:38pm
Yes they have. The P5 conferences are sealing off the money vault.
Samurai Jack
8/23/14 1:26pm
You do realize that going forward all conferences get more money even Go5
BYUFam1
8/23/14 7:39pm
this is incorrect
Coog4Life
8/23/14 12:45pm
Sorry. You are incorrect. LiveCoug is spot on.
Samurai Jack
8/23/14 1:30pm
The top ranked teams are automatically in
Coog4Life
8/23/14 2:09pm
The discussion is about the G5 autobid
Samurai Jack
8/23/14 2:20pm
But based on the original LiveCoug post if we are 3rd in the committees poll
BYUFam1
8/23/14 7:42pm
smh. Yes we do. If committee ranks us #3 we are in CFP
nashty
8/23/14 3:34pm
Almost surely. Sure. We do NOT have any guarantees.
LiveCoug
8/23/14 3:47pm
The only reason I can't state it in absolute terms is because it depends upon
nashty
8/23/14 4:02pm
BYU won't be ranked that high by the committee.
Samurai Jack
8/23/14 4:37pm
Who with a committee ranking of #3 does not have a guarantee?
BYUFam1
8/23/14 7:46pm
If we are 3rd in the selection committee poll we are in the playoffs
BYUFam1
8/23/14 7:29pm
Maybe you could use this post...
BYUFam1
8/23/14 7:32pm
There are no auto bids to the playoffs
PolarisPrime
8/23/14 8:03pm
And that's what I am referring to. OP was asking about G5 autobid.
LiveCoug
8/23/14 8:06pm
Thats a good point, but I don't think that is what he meant to ask.
PolarisPrime
8/23/14 8:14pm
It is true we have no claim to the Go5 auto bid - it is not true that a #5
BYUFam1
8/24/14 12:07am
A #5 in every year would get in
BYUFam1
8/24/14 12:05am
We have to hope Texas, Cal, UVA and UCF win out
jrifkin48
8/23/14 12:26pm
BYU is not eligible for a playoff bid.
Samurai Jack
8/23/14 1:43pm
If we were to go undefeated beating three P5 champions then we wold be good
jrifkin48
8/23/14 2:23pm
IF we were to beat 3 or 4 conference champions on our way to an undefeated
Samurai Jack
8/23/14 2:28pm
It all depends on how the other teams do.
PolarisPrime
8/23/14 8:06pm
Every team is eligible for a playoff bid. The question is "Would the selection
ptcougr
8/23/14 6:58pm
This is only an absolute in the mind of someone with a complex
BYUFam1
8/23/14 7:51pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
