The irony is rather humorous isn't it?

Report problem with this ad

Jan 25, 2015
6:53:31am

ALC

Report problem with this ad

ALC

Bio page: ALC
Joined: Jul 6, 2003
Last login: May 15, 2024
Total posts: 3,786 (12 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

You guys who are criticizing Dave Rose need to shut up.

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

1/24/15 10:17pm

I agree. Gotta love the CB downers

MtnMan

1/24/15 10:19pm

<< Deleted >>

cvd6262

1/24/15 10:24pm

Who is responsible for Worthington being on the team?

dYrtbYkerYder

1/24/15 11:38pm

Completely agree!!!!!!

Cosmo's Kid

1/24/15 10:19pm

I think people are just saying, if you are critisizing Bronco, Rose should not

capo

1/25/15 8:10pm

byu basketball is completely irrelevant right now.

bulletproof

1/24/15 10:19pm

If you're referring to the fact that BYU is no longer in the MWC, that's

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

1/24/15 10:23pm

So you are saying the reason the team is underachieving in the WCC

TNT

1/24/15 10:24pm

No. I'm saying that this team can't play defense, just like every other BYU

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

1/24/15 10:26pm

are you serious?

bulletproof

1/24/15 10:26pm

His team has exactly one bad loss this year and guys like you go nuts.

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

1/24/15 10:29pm

I played bball in college.

bulletproof

1/24/15 10:34pm

Find me an LDS basketball coach with a better record and comparable resume.

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

1/24/15 10:35pm

rose coached at dixie, a juco prior coming to BYU.

bulletproof

1/24/15 10:40pm

bird in the hand is better than two in the bush.

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

1/24/15 10:43pm

no one suggested rose get fired this year

El Joffrey

1/24/15 10:48pm

So everyone is just complaining to make themselves feel better?

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

1/24/15 10:49pm

there are more levels than 1. deserves no criticism and 2. deserves to be fired

El Joffrey

1/24/15 10:52pm

you seem really mad. I hope everything is ok.

bulletproof

1/24/15 10:49pm

not mad, just verbose

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

1/24/15 10:50pm

So which part was the verbose part?

squirrelyearl

1/24/15 11:03pm

I think my point is definitely being expressed with more words than necessary.

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

1/24/15 11:11pm

<< Deleted >>

cvd6262

1/24/15 10:59pm

Even though your analogy is poor,

bulletproof

1/25/15 12:21am

I definitely think he's overrated as a recruiter.

dYrtbYkerYder

1/24/15 11:40pm

You are right. He really isn't a very good coach. Above average. Also, an above

larrybird77

1/25/15 8:53am

I agree... with both... He's the best coach we ever had...

basc-coug

1/24/15 10:26pm

I could not disagree more.

larrybird77

1/25/15 9:14am

Irrelevant - what does that even mean?

kccougar

1/25/15 6:48am

Stan Watts and his national championship would disagree

StantonMac

1/24/15 10:20pm

Rose has a better win % than Watts

Iman23

1/24/15 10:20pm

This is obviously a joke.

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

1/24/15 10:24pm

Watts was the Chair of the U.S. Olympic basketball committee, the President of

Gentleman Stan

1/24/15 11:46pm

Stan the man...Some on here just show their age too often...

Cougarfan777

1/24/15 11:56pm

Why?

PolarisPrime

1/25/15 1:13am

Wrong

Oldcougfan

1/25/15 10:08am

The 60s were iffy.

PolarisPrime

1/25/15 5:10pm

Clearly a great coaching decision to have a huge number of under sized

squirrelyearl

1/24/15 10:20pm

Stan Watts, Frank Arnold and Ladell Anderson were all great coaches.

HighHorse

1/24/15 10:23pm

Danny. I don't know man. But fans can criticize Rose.

Mathew

1/24/15 10:24pm

Really good teams lose to really bad teams every year in basketball.

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

1/24/15 10:27pm

Yeah, but not like we are. And we used to own the Marriott Center. We get worked

Iman23

1/24/15 10:30pm

LOL

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

1/24/15 10:34pm

we aren't even close to being a top 25 team

El Joffrey

1/24/15 10:51pm

Rose lost 4 home conference games his ENTIRE TIME as coach in MWC

Iman23

1/24/15 10:53pm

BYU is 3-3 in their last 6 games.

Mathew

1/24/15 10:38pm

lol. Rose isn't above criticism.

spugeddy24

1/24/15 10:38pm

He has one bad loss. That's hardly justification for criticism. Now, if BYU

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

1/24/15 10:39pm

I'm not criticizing. I just don't think he's above it.

spugeddy24

1/24/15 10:42pm

you don't have to be horrible to get criticism

El Joffrey

1/24/15 10:49pm

and there are 2 bad losses so far this year.

El Joffrey

1/24/15 10:49pm

I think BYU has 4 bad losses. BYU should have beat SDSU and Purdue.

Mathew

1/24/15 10:53pm

One bad loss? Ok, you aint even talkin' straight facts pardner...

Cougarfan777

1/24/15 11:35pm

I love coach rose. His post season success is horrendous.

idacoug

1/24/15 10:50pm

No. You need to shut up.

Y'zFan

1/24/15 10:55pm

Well said.

Iman23

1/24/15 11:02pm

Roger Reid 152-77 (.667) record. BYU also made five NCAA Tournament appearances,

Cougarfan777

1/24/15 11:33pm

Not to take away from Roger's unquestionable coaching strengths, but

Mantis Mutu

1/25/15 3:21am

Reid was a very good Xs and Os coach. I thought he had a grating personality

ALUF 1990

1/25/15 4:17am

Roger go back to your cave

cougswin

1/25/15 6:55am

And left the program in shambles.

Bluforever

1/25/15 9:00am

I would argue the Athletic director left the program in shambles after they

larrybird77

1/25/15 9:23am

you must be kidding. The year Reid was finally fired, they had 1 D1 player

Bluforever

1/25/15 11:51am

Apparently I remembered incorrectly, but also I understand they were

larrybird77

1/25/15 3:54pm

seven freshman on the roster, also lost previous year's scoring leader, Ruffner

Cougarfan777

1/25/15 4:10pm

I'm sorry but this argumentis ridiculous. The reason for so many freshman

Bluforever

1/26/15 11:27am

Ridiculous. Bradley bailed on BYU for the NBA and Roger's whole team was recruit

Cougarfan777

1/25/15 3:52pm

That is CRAZY talk

cougswin

1/25/15 7:36pm

Bradley was a great college player, won a 1st round NCAA game with him

Cougarfan777

1/26/15 12:41am

ESPN was picking BYU 5th the first year Bradley was back from his mission

PolarisPrime

1/26/15 10:43am

If not for the change in the NBA rookie salary cap

PolarisPrime

1/26/15 10:45am

wow ... don't criticize Rose but go ahead on Bronco ? Love your double standard

ManicBlue

1/25/15 1:12am

The irony is rather humorous isn't it?

ALC

1/25/15 6:53am

I've always noted that Dave Rose gets a pass here for losses that would have

BeardedSpock

1/25/15 8:06am

He gets a pass because he gets more games, give Rose 11 games different story.

Cougarfan777

1/26/15 12:44am

Completely agree!

kC Cougar

1/25/15 3:25am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad