I think 3 is pretty much irrelevant to everyone except the player/coach getting the award.
I'm not anti-conference. I'm just saying that the way other conferences look at BYU is more or less irrelevant; as long as BYU has the support of the playoff selection committee, it doesn't matter who else thinks BYU is good. Likewise, if the selection committee thinks BYU is garbage, the opinons of the ACC/SEC/B1G don't make a difference.