Not perfect, but its better than independence fool's gold.

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 24, 2015
3:42:22pm

Josef K All-American

Not perfect, but its better than independence fool's gold.

I'd get rid of Utah State and Air Force and add UNLV in the west. In the East I would get rid of Northern Illinois or ECU.

I'm amazed how many people view independence as a huge step forward over this. The step forward exists in the minds of a few BYU fans...that's it.

Report problem with this ad

Josef K

Previous username: UCB Coug
New username: Jay Kay
Bio page: Josef K
Joined: Jan 12, 2011
Last login: Jun 9, 2020
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Would you join this conference?

cougarmikey

11/24/15 2:57pm

Yes.

SandYFan

11/24/15 2:58pm

RE: No. I would not join any...

11/24/15 3:54pm

Yeah....That would be a mistake. That conference would be terrible.

HasRo24

11/24/15 4:10pm

Ingenious idea: let's cherry pick the best of those teams & steal their #1 bowl

Station42

11/24/15 4:55pm

I prefer independence over that.

Lance71

11/24/15 3:00pm

No

Sea Chicken

11/24/15 3:00pm

BYU can schedule all of those teams now as an independent

mwcoug

11/24/15 3:01pm

CCG, maybe better bowl tie-ins, & chance at CFP?

WhyaskY?

11/24/15 3:14pm

Won't give us better bowls or chance at CFP than independence

mwcoug

11/24/15 3:24pm

It absolutely improves our chances for an NY6 bowl

SJS

11/24/15 3:26pm

Improves chances for NY6. Decreases chances for a playoff spot.

Lance71

11/24/15 3:28pm

There's no going back

BaYoU

11/24/15 3:01pm

Prefer Indy over having a conference with a team in San Diego, Hartford and Central Florida. But if it's a Power

HarlemCoug

11/24/15 3:03pm

Honestly, if we add 3 P5 teams and 1 cupcake to that schedule, it wouldn't be

11/24/15 3:03pm

But it would FEEL like a step backward to me.

11/24/15 3:05pm

If we played Utah, 1 other PAC, and 2 others from SEC/B1G/ACC/Big12

SJS

11/24/15 3:25pm

Joining the conference is easy. Getting the $10m+/team/yr TV contract is hard.

11/24/15 3:05pm

You lost me at Utah State.

Walter Bellhaven

11/24/15 3:05pm

Add UNLV and Army

Revolution

11/24/15 3:06pm

Why Army?

Walter Bellhaven

11/24/15 3:13pm

I'd like to see all of the D1 service academies in one conference.

Revolution

11/25/15 4:13am

Would screw up our SOS every season. Need to focus on P5 and playoff inclusion.

Walter Bellhaven

11/25/15 7:51am

In this hypothetical, IMO we'd end up playing Army like every 5 years.

Revolution

11/25/15 7:55am

AAC won't do that (cut some of their existing schools), but we could do somethin

SJS

11/24/15 3:06pm

No

Lifi

11/24/15 3:07pm

No

BYUMizzou

11/24/15 3:07pm

No usu or niu

ayfan

11/24/15 3:08pm

As long as we have an ESPN deal no.

mudpupper

11/24/15 3:08pm

No way. No how. Not going to happen.

2FarGone

11/24/15 3:09pm

It's hypothetical...clearly not going to happen or a possibility in reality.

cougarmikey

11/24/15 3:17pm

No, not tempting at all

Dr T-bone

11/24/15 3:11pm

No

Steven Koren

11/24/15 3:11pm

Yuck.

11/24/15 3:29pm

Not perfect, but its better than independence fool's gold.

Josef K

11/24/15 3:42pm

No.

CMuehle

11/24/15 3:47pm

That'll be considered P5 as soon as MWC and AAC are considered P5.

11/24/15 3:48pm

Yuk - 16 team WAC 2.0 (orphan mediocrity reloaded)

Jomo

11/24/15 3:57pm

Nope

Florwood

11/24/15 3:59pm

no

2239Yfan

11/24/15 4:13pm

Join a conference with the hatefull Aztecs? Meh. Better be some good perks.

Count Cougar

11/24/15 4:17pm

I would not.

11/24/15 4:22pm

Keep the AAC mostly as is, just add a western scheduling division

boscatar

11/24/15 4:39pm

Is this the love child of the AAC and 1996 WAC?

Steven Koren

11/24/15 4:53pm

That conference would get the NY6 9/10 years

yfootball

11/24/15 7:32pm

Scratch Utah State and Northern Illinois ...

Modiolus

11/24/15 4:48pm

NO! As mentioned BYU can already schedule these schools

Cougarpride

11/24/15 4:49pm

AAC.2 is also a no go.

IronPotato

11/24/15 4:53pm

Nope. No point unless P5

jkccoug

11/24/15 5:01pm

Yuck. And all the bureaucracy that comes with a conference.

Dr MoBYU

11/24/15 5:06pm

Preference is no conference unless it is a great conference. What you presented

RealityCheckedCougr

11/24/15 5:27pm

Only if there were 8 conference games

I'mBatman

11/24/15 5:46pm

The East would be an awesome basketball conference.

BYUCPA

11/24/15 5:58pm

No

11/24/15 6:12pm

No

ChocolateReadingMom

11/24/15 6:19pm

Only if that conference would have the same access to the NY6 bowls as the P5.

Kerbouchard

11/24/15 6:22pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad