The better programs have the better starred recruits IN GENERAL. So yes....

Report problem with this ad

Sep 25, 2016
2:32:54pm

JmThms Walk-on

..in general, trust the stars.

Report problem with this ad

JmThms

Bio page: JmThms
Joined: Jul 4, 2012
Last login: Dec 19, 2020
Total posts: 13,784 (11 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Our 2017 recruiting looks terrible early on.

Pimpin4Paradise

9/25/16 11:08am

Just let TNT know when it is acceptable to panic

TNT

9/25/16 11:10am

Start panicking now

byuluvr

9/25/16 11:19am

As soon as TNT tells everyone why or how he thinks panicking will help

BYUCoug11

9/25/16 11:39am

RE: Just let TNT know when it is acceptable to panic

COACHdrn

9/25/16 9:39pm

McChesney is undervalued imo. But yes that is not a highly regarded list.

PapaBill

9/25/16 11:23am

I have been tempted to do this every time we are assured that there's going to

Freddie Cougar

9/25/16 11:24am

2018 looks pretty good so far though. 8 recruits. 6 with 3 stars early on, and

cougaman

9/25/16 11:41am

It will pick up.

southernfriedcougar

9/25/16 12:23pm

Let's hope

The Dangler

9/25/16 1:31pm

Look how many flips and near flips they managed in just a few weeks.

southernfriedcougar

9/25/16 1:50pm

Not sure about Alden Tofa

BaseballCoug

9/25/16 6:07pm

Words from his mouth are pretty telling

southernfriedcougar

9/25/16 6:11pm

You can't say something like that without including a link or a quote.

cougaman

9/25/16 6:23pm

Boo

southernfriedcougar

9/25/16 6:39pm

Thanks. Oregon not looking good this year, and they want to fire their HC right

cougaman

9/25/16 6:58pm

Glad to hear that. Words are better

BaseballCoug

9/25/16 8:22pm

A local kid on a visit with other recruits to a U of U home game.

southernfriedcougar

9/25/16 8:28pm

He wasn't posing for a pic. He was on the field, excited, flashing the U ...

BaseballCoug

9/25/16 9:21pm

All I said was that he was with other recruits on a visit to THEIR place.

southernfriedcougar

9/25/16 9:32pm

I'm agreeing with you, recruits do weird stuff

BaseballCoug

9/25/16 10:40pm

Also something to consider, don't a lot of the really good recruits tend to wait

Harrison0Yfan

9/25/16 7:42pm

Fautea to Ore St

jrj84105

9/25/16 8:44pm

Yes, and it's lame. But what makes you say they're not in play for Katoa?

southernfriedcougar

9/25/16 9:01pm

which Katoa, the RB that signed with Oregon state out of AF?

pegushin

9/26/16 5:24am

2017. Tayler Katoa. 4 star athlete (LB)

southernfriedcougar

9/26/16 9:21am

ok thanks, if we were talking the RB I know he would like to possibly transfer

pegushin

9/26/16 11:18am

Never trust star rankings! Star fruad is a real thing

Kama'aina

9/25/16 12:27pm

Some are overrated and some are underrated, but it's not wrong.

Pimpin4Paradise

9/25/16 12:46pm

The better programs have the better starred recruits IN GENERAL. So yes....

JmThms

9/25/16 2:32pm

Some concerns there

The Dangler

9/25/16 1:28pm

I'll be honest - I think the Langi offer might be due

tcherrin

9/25/16 5:16pm

Anyone good coming home from a mission?

Chicago Cougar fan

9/25/16 1:35pm

Fuga is back and red shirting, I think

I'mBatman

9/25/16 2:02pm

Some promising Dline from last years class as well, that will be here in 2018.

cougaman

9/25/16 2:15pm

Isaiah Nacua

JKLCoug

9/25/16 8:59pm

not for a few years. Went on a mission this spring

cougaman

9/25/16 9:16pm

That kid's gonna really be pee'in off P5 coaches by his Sr year!

mantis mutu

9/26/16 1:51am

Isn't it more common these days for the big time recruits to wait until later in the recruiting cycle? Isn't lot like

HarlemCoug

9/25/16 1:42pm

Stock up on Hanshaw, Buchanan, Bywater, Baker, and McChesney. All could gain a

wiscougarfan

9/25/16 2:02pm

As high as 35! That is depressing.

Diablo and Doc

9/25/16 4:38pm

Not in year 1. Huge jump. Ill take it.

Turnpike Lane

9/25/16 5:15pm

Are you kidding? You do not follow BYU recruiting closely. 35 would be amazing for us

YIsForBrigham

9/25/16 5:52pm

Purely playing devils advocate here. If we recruit consistently at the 60-80

Chicago Cougar fan

9/25/16 5:56pm

It means the recruiting rankings do not accurately grade the typical BYU recruit

YIsForBrigham

9/25/16 6:10pm

Especially with as many early recruits as BYU has had over the years.

cougaman

9/25/16 6:22pm

And that's why it's depressing.

Diablo and Doc

9/25/16 6:00pm

In what world is that depressing?

southernfriedcougar

9/25/16 6:06pm

There are a few programs like BYU in the 60-80 range that consistent overperform

wiscougarfan

9/25/16 9:27pm

I guess another thing I didn't think about is highly ranked recruits will come

Chicago Cougar fan

9/25/16 9:30pm

Baker isn't playing this year, injured

Heinz57

9/25/16 7:02pm

So far, status quo, all BM-type recruits.

ag4cougs

9/25/16 4:37pm

Isn't it true a lot of top re recruites commit later in the process?

ZooBlue

9/25/16 5:34pm

It does seem this way. Many like to do the stupid hat "ceremony" and make

Duke Silver

9/25/16 9:51pm

Yes, but BYU almost never gets hat ceremony type kids

wiscougarfan

9/25/16 9:58pm

Correct, but there's still plenty 3 and 4 star kids who wait til after doing all

Duke Silver

9/25/16 10:06pm

Makes sense...

ZooBlue

9/26/16 10:07am

Who have we missed on?

sandiegocgrfan

9/25/16 7:20pm

Higher rated recruits generally do not commit early...

CoachSpeak

9/25/16 8:31pm

RE: Higher rated recruits generally do not commit early...

wcj99

9/25/16 9:53pm

I've made a list but haven't posted it publically yet. Nearly 1/3 of the kids

wiscougarfan

9/25/16 10:02pm

Also I hate comparing us to Utah....

CoachSpeak

9/25/16 8:46pm

Crap, with that kind of recruiting we'll start 1-3....

byucougarsbig12

9/25/16 9:00pm

Until yewtah starts losing in the pac, we will play second fiddle and wont turn the tide.

indocoug

9/25/16 9:16pm

This time around everyone might be waiting on B12 news.

ditch

9/25/16 10:07pm

I like that they are at least trying to improve the TE position

CougarsFanSince80s

9/25/16 11:08pm

Alls you need is a 4 star in there and it'll pretty much mirror a typical Mendenhall class...

ocmyhome

9/25/16 11:17pm

In terms of stars, maybe--but not in terms of parity.

mantis mutu

9/26/16 1:39am

3 to consider: Hanshaw will be a star as either a TE or DE. Great athlete there.

Posting on CougarBoard