Manning had more talent around him imo.

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 22, 2017
7:30:33pm

spugeddy24 All-American

Manning had more talent around him imo.

Not as good of coaching but better WR's and RB's for sure. And SB's have to matter.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jan 22, 2017 at 7:30:33pm

Message modified by spugeddy24 on Jan 22, 2017 at 7:31:02pm

Report problem with this ad

spugeddy24

Bio page: spugeddy24
Joined: Aug 10, 2009
Last login: May 5, 2024
Total posts: 78,548 (27,702 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Nobody does more with less than Brady does. It's part of why he's the GOAT.

spugeddy24

1/22/17 7:15pm

Hey they could be called the Brady Bunch

TNT

1/22/17 7:18pm

Except hes paired with the GOAT in coaching, Belichick

1/22/17 7:18pm

less what? problems? dead weight? scrubs?

Bgash

1/22/17 7:20pm

How difficult is it to pass to open receivers?

Busiturtle

1/22/17 7:22pm

I still doubt the Steelers know Chris Hogan wears #15 and

Busiturtle

1/22/17 7:24pm

Belichick is the most important factor. Brady definitely #2. Does exactly what

Game Changer

1/22/17 7:26pm

So who would you say is GOAT at qb.

spugeddy24

1/22/17 7:28pm

Manning.

byujacob

1/22/17 7:29pm

Manning had more talent around him imo.

spugeddy24

1/22/17 7:30pm

and played indoors almost his whole career.

VACOUGFAN

1/22/17 7:31pm

Disagree. While I like Brady more, manning was forced to play differently because of the lack of talent on the team.

macaroni

1/22/17 8:39pm

Im as big a Manning homer as there is, but Brady is GOAT

1/22/17 7:31pm

Lest we forget that Brady is still writing his story. Manning is not.

boss

1/22/17 7:34pm

Also let's not forget that the NFL didn't just start existing in the late '90s.

Game Changer

1/22/17 8:07pm

Brady is GOAT

1/22/17 7:30pm

1 & 1a

VACOUGFAN

1/22/17 7:29pm

also not debatable. he's the GOAT. he still has to make the plays and he's been

VACOUGFAN

1/22/17 7:30pm

His accomplishments are similar to Bradshaw and Montana, guys who won a ton of

Game Changer

1/22/17 8:03pm

Bradshaw is enormously overrated

spugeddy24

1/22/17 8:17pm

who also played their entire careers pre free agency which meant they had

VACOUGFAN

1/22/17 8:38pm

I disagree. They're both equally as important and completely necessary.

Machiavelli

1/22/17 7:50pm

Except we have seen Brady removed from the equation and Pats keep winning.

Game Changer

1/22/17 7:58pm

Yeah they won a few games w/o Brady, but they were NOWHERE near as good as they

Machiavelli

1/22/17 8:16pm

and they didn't make the playoffs did they...

VACOUGFAN

1/22/17 8:40pm

Is it the QB or the coach? We don't know. Remember BB was a failure in Cleveland.

macaroni

1/22/17 8:41pm

Lots of coaches struggle in the first few years. Look at Chuck Noll, Bill Walsh

Game Changer

1/22/17 8:50pm

the question to always ask is it the QB, or is it the coach? there is almost always debate. Gibbs is really the only guy

macaroni

1/22/17 10:48pm

Many have much less than Brady, like for example Rodgers. Check out these NFL

chilango

1/22/17 7:46pm

Pats defense this year = fewest points allowed by any team since 2013

Game Changer

1/22/17 8:11pm

Exactly.

chilango

1/22/17 8:21pm

He's good, but he'd not be my first pick.

Jeffacka

1/22/17 7:50pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad