dumbest decision ever to burn that whole year just so he could fumble in a bowl

Report problem with this ad

Feb 23, 2017
1:25:37pm

CDV All-American

game.

Report problem with this ad

CDV

Previous username: TheRealBarrySwitzer
Bio page: CDV
Joined: Oct 28, 2011
Last login: Jun 1, 2024
Total posts: 59,584 (27,537 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I sure wish Mangum had redshirted.

rggee

2/23/17 1:01pm

that would change nothing

southernfriedcougar

2/23/17 1:03pm

Why not?

truecoug1

2/23/17 1:05pm

Where have you been? The guy wants to play in the nfl.

southernfriedcougar

2/23/17 1:06pm

Wanting to and being able to are 2 different things.

truecoug1

2/23/17 1:30pm

Agree. Would have been nice to have it just in case. No BYU QB has really had a good enough shot at NFL success to

byuTX

2/23/17 1:56pm

Heaps and Mangum are nothing alike in any way.

southernfriedcougar

2/23/17 2:25pm

I see a ton of similarities, actually....

rggee

2/23/17 2:28pm

Is Tanner closer to Beck and Hall? Those guys couldn't have left early either

truecoug1

2/23/17 2:30pm

Age is a big negative these days.

wilsdad

2/23/17 3:57pm

If he's not good enough to be in the nfl by his Sr year, then I think he will be

palangi

2/23/17 4:04pm

He'd be 26

GhostOf84

2/23/17 1:20pm

He could leave after his Jr. year - the RS would at least give him the option

Ulysses14

2/23/17 1:32pm

But he added experience this year.

ChinoCoug

2/23/17 4:34pm

If you mean the bowl game, then yes

Ulysses14

2/23/17 4:46pm

That's what I meant.

ChinoCoug

2/23/17 4:53pm

other than the insurance policy of having another year...this year was worthless

ag4cougs

2/23/17 5:27pm

I can't believe that penalty stole his redshirt year.

RyneK

2/23/17 1:04pm

Where is that written?

BertoChavez

2/23/17 1:14pm

It's been discussed and proven ad nauseam on CB.

AndyDwyer

2/23/17 1:20pm

It's not, you're being had

GhostOf84

2/23/17 1:22pm

We were all had. That's the saddest part of this all.

RyneK

2/23/17 1:25pm

Mangum himself tweeted that he would not red shirt

qom

2/23/17 4:26pm

AFTER the penalty in the Utah game.

AndyDwyer

2/23/17 4:34pm

So, you're ASSUMING that he wanted to redshirt

qom

2/23/17 11:50pm

If we hadn't needed him in the bowl game I would agree

Jericho

2/23/17 1:04pm

You don't lose a year for one game (see Squally). It was the penalty that doomed

RyneK

2/23/17 1:04pm

dumbest decision ever to burn that whole year just so he could fumble in a bowl

CDV

2/23/17 1:25pm

I hope you are not serious.

BYUinTX

2/23/17 1:42pm

Shirley he is not.

cheezedawg

2/23/17 2:09pm

I am serious, and don't call me shirley.

Frank Drebin

2/23/17 4:46pm

Not me. I'd been fine if we almost never red-shirted anyone.

Born2Fish

2/23/17 3:01pm

RE: I sure wish Mangum had redshirted.

Cookiecoug

2/23/17 5:36pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad