I hope you are not serious.

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Feb 23, 2017
1:42:01pm

BYUinTX All-American

I hope you are not serious.

Report problem with this ad

BYUinTX

Previous username: cougarmae
Bio page: BYUinTX
Joined: Sep 7, 2004
Last login: Jun 7, 2024
Total posts: 4,959 (277 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I sure wish Mangum had redshirted.

rggee

2/23/17 1:01pm

that would change nothing

southernfriedcougar

2/23/17 1:03pm

Why not?

truecoug1

2/23/17 1:05pm

Where have you been? The guy wants to play in the nfl.

southernfriedcougar

2/23/17 1:06pm

Wanting to and being able to are 2 different things.

truecoug1

2/23/17 1:30pm

Agree. Would have been nice to have it just in case. No BYU QB has really had a good enough shot at NFL success to

byuTX

2/23/17 1:56pm

Heaps and Mangum are nothing alike in any way.

southernfriedcougar

2/23/17 2:25pm

I see a ton of similarities, actually....

rggee

2/23/17 2:28pm

Is Tanner closer to Beck and Hall? Those guys couldn't have left early either

truecoug1

2/23/17 2:30pm

Age is a big negative these days.

wilsdad

2/23/17 3:57pm

If he's not good enough to be in the nfl by his Sr year, then I think he will be

palangi

2/23/17 4:04pm

He'd be 26

GhostOf84

2/23/17 1:20pm

He could leave after his Jr. year - the RS would at least give him the option

Ulysses14

2/23/17 1:32pm

But he added experience this year.

ChinoCoug

2/23/17 4:34pm

If you mean the bowl game, then yes

Ulysses14

2/23/17 4:46pm

That's what I meant.

ChinoCoug

2/23/17 4:53pm

other than the insurance policy of having another year...this year was worthless

ag4cougs

2/23/17 5:27pm

I can't believe that penalty stole his redshirt year.

RyneK

2/23/17 1:04pm

Where is that written?

BertoChavez

2/23/17 1:14pm

It's been discussed and proven ad nauseam on CB.

AndyDwyer

2/23/17 1:20pm

It's not, you're being had

GhostOf84

2/23/17 1:22pm

We were all had. That's the saddest part of this all.

RyneK

2/23/17 1:25pm

Mangum himself tweeted that he would not red shirt

qom

2/23/17 4:26pm

AFTER the penalty in the Utah game.

AndyDwyer

2/23/17 4:34pm

So, you're ASSUMING that he wanted to redshirt

qom

2/23/17 11:50pm

If we hadn't needed him in the bowl game I would agree

Jericho

2/23/17 1:04pm

You don't lose a year for one game (see Squally). It was the penalty that doomed

RyneK

2/23/17 1:04pm

dumbest decision ever to burn that whole year just so he could fumble in a bowl

CDV

2/23/17 1:25pm

I hope you are not serious.

BYUinTX

2/23/17 1:42pm

Shirley he is not.

cheezedawg

2/23/17 2:09pm

I am serious, and don't call me shirley.

2/23/17 4:46pm

Not me. I'd been fine if we almost never red-shirted anyone.

Born2Fish

2/23/17 3:01pm

RE: I sure wish Mangum had redshirted.

Cookiecoug

2/23/17 5:36pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad