My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Mar 28, 2017
6:35
:28
pm
GeauxCougs
All-American
Best doesn't equal personal
Top 10. That being said he would be in my top 20 and if I had to pick an all time roster he would be the first receiver on my squad
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Mar 28, 2017 at 6:35:28pm
Message modified by GeauxCougs on Mar 28, 2017 at 6:36:25pm
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
GeauxCougs
Previous username
thewizzard
New username
A Drew Aitch
Bio page
GeauxCougs
Joined
Feb 28, 2007
Last login
Dec 29, 2017
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?
Borg
3/28/17 5:58pm
No Jamaal Williams?
bushy7
3/28/17 5:59pm
I love JSwag....he should be in there...so many
Borg
3/28/17 6:04pm
That's how storied of a program we have.
Cougarfan777
3/28/17 7:14pm
My thoughts too. How can you not have Jamaal?
Skysthelimit
3/29/17 1:11am
Hard to narrow it to 10. I'd include Jswag, Virgil Carter, Chris Farasopolis but
ptcougr
3/29/17 3:36am
My 10 year old built a little Hall of Fame with painter's tape of his favorite
crack
3/28/17 6:01pm
Crap. Just double checked and there was a 4 for Taysom.
crack
3/28/17 6:11pm
In terms of playing career at BYU, Ziggy shouldn't be anywhere near that list. He wasn't even top 10 on his own team
Game Changer
3/28/17 6:02pm
Personal Top 10, for whatever reason. So - - - - - if I want Ziggy, I'll put ZIGGY!
lightmann
3/28/17 6:05pm
Yes! 😎
Borg
3/28/17 6:06pm
Criteria is your own personal reasons
Borg
3/28/17 6:06pm
So you're really asking for 10 favorite BYU football players, not top 10 players of all time?
Game Changer
3/28/17 6:13pm
He did say "your personal" top players
Pistol Shrimp
3/28/17 6:19pm
RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?
byusuvu
3/28/17 6:20pm
Mine
SoCalCoug
3/28/17 6:24pm
Good picks
BrutustheBrash
3/28/17 6:29pm
Awesome!... that's a great Top 10
Borg
3/28/17 6:31pm
If I expanded my list to 20, it might include 4 punters:
SoCalCoug
3/28/17 6:47pm
Matt Payne ... Boise? He choked in that game.
ManicBlue
3/28/17 7:03pm
Seems like MMA Jan Jorgenson ought to make your list based on your criteria
Big Daddy D
3/28/17 11:00pm
RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?
GeauxCougs
3/28/17 6:27pm
Recency Bias list
BrutustheBrash
3/28/17 6:28pm
RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?
Crush4
3/28/17 6:30pm
Austin collie left off most of these lists! Best receiver
diluigifan
3/28/17 6:34pm
Best doesn't equal personal
GeauxCougs
3/28/17 6:35pm
I'd list Kozlowski over Collie on my list - he was far more entertaining
SoCalCoug
3/28/17 6:37pm
Kozlowski was probably the first BYU guy I emulated as a kid.
GeauxCougs
3/28/17 6:40pm
Yeah, I'm not sure anyone would consider him a "technician" like Collie was.
SoCalCoug
3/28/17 6:40pm
Google his yewt
SoCalCoug
3/28/17 6:36pm
Detmer, Staley,Young, Jimmymac,JSwag, Dewey Grey, Tim Mctyre, Austin Collie,
CarolinaCoug
3/28/17 6:40pm
My list in no particular order
ManicBlue
3/28/17 6:45pm
RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?
donnerstag
3/28/17 6:48pm
#1, when I was a kid-Stacey Corley
Mathlete
3/28/17 6:53pm
That Air Force Game. Was at that one
GeauxCougs
3/28/17 7:03pm
RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?
Coop
3/28/17 7:14pm
Itula Milli?
BDAWG
3/28/17 7:17pm
No Sark?
CougarThug
3/28/17 7:19pm
In no particular order, and way more than 10, because they all stand out to me..
So it goes...
3/28/17 7:34pm
With a list that long you probably should have put Chris Smith on it
GeauxCougs
3/28/17 7:45pm
Maybe, He was a very good TE and All-American, but for some reason he doesn't
So it goes...
3/28/17 8:12pm
My list
tcherrin
3/28/17 7:42pm
Jim McMahon, Vai Sikahema, Steve Young, Kyle Morrell,
chilango
3/28/17 8:08pm
Mine (I'm younger than most of you old weirdos):
cougarnerd
3/28/17 8:13pm
Detmer, Staley, Bellini, Payne, White, Leavitt, Van Noy, Koz, Shell, Lewis
Albuq_Coug
3/28/17 8:13pm
Solid list, I don't know who I'd swap, but Max is on mine and Sark
Graig Swame
3/28/17 8:18pm
Very hard to pick Top 10
AF_Puma
3/28/17 8:25pm
Here's mine.
Y'zFan
3/28/17 8:53pm
I have to have Ronney Jenkins on the list
Run-DMT
3/28/17 8:58pm
No Robbie Boscoe?
Jdb84
3/28/17 9:03pm
You tell 'em Mrs. Boscoe!
libertycoug
3/28/17 9:15pm
Personal favorites
libertycoug
3/28/17 9:18pm
Detmer, Hunter the Punter, Jason Buck, Randy Brock, Jamaal Willis,
Logancoug
3/28/17 9:22pm
Curious, why Ryan Hancock?
So it goes...
3/28/17 9:48pm
My favorite backup QB ever, and could throw the ball a mile
Logancoug
3/28/17 9:59pm
Mine....
Adrielle
3/28/17 9:29pm
Wiscougarfan's...
wiscougarfan
3/28/17 10:03pm
In no particular order:
frontrowcougar
3/28/17 10:04pm
Top ten that I've seen play in person
Florwood
3/28/17 11:15pm
Ty detmer, Steve young, McMahon, staley, Jamaal Williams, Austin Collie,
califcougar
3/29/17 12:12am
I had to eliminate ones I really wanted to include to get it down to 12.
Skysthelimit
3/29/17 2:13am
Luke Staley
Redfiretruck
3/29/17 6:04pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad