Personal favorites

Report problem with this ad

Mar 28, 2017
9:18:44pm

libertycoug 3rd String

Personal favorites

No order

Payne
Ty
Reno
Jamaal Williams
Staley
Max Hall
Van Noy
Taysom
Chad Lewis
John Beck

Report problem with this ad

libertycoug

Bio page: libertycoug
Joined: Aug 19, 2013
Last login: May 1, 2024
Total posts: 2,216 (18 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?

Borg

3/28/17 5:58pm

No Jamaal Williams?

bushy7

3/28/17 5:59pm

I love JSwag....he should be in there...so many

Borg

3/28/17 6:04pm

That's how storied of a program we have.

Cougarfan777

3/28/17 7:14pm

My thoughts too. How can you not have Jamaal?

Skysthelimit

3/29/17 1:11am

Hard to narrow it to 10. I'd include Jswag, Virgil Carter, Chris Farasopolis but

ptcougr

3/29/17 3:36am

My 10 year old built a little Hall of Fame with painter's tape of his favorite

crack

3/28/17 6:01pm

Crap. Just double checked and there was a 4 for Taysom.

crack

3/28/17 6:11pm

In terms of playing career at BYU, Ziggy shouldn't be anywhere near that list. He wasn't even top 10 on his own team

Game Changer

3/28/17 6:02pm

Personal Top 10, for whatever reason. So - - - - - if I want Ziggy, I'll put ZIGGY!

lightmann

3/28/17 6:05pm

Yes! 😎

Borg

3/28/17 6:06pm

Criteria is your own personal reasons

Borg

3/28/17 6:06pm

So you're really asking for 10 favorite BYU football players, not top 10 players of all time?

Game Changer

3/28/17 6:13pm

He did say "your personal" top players

Pistol Shrimp

3/28/17 6:19pm

RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?

byusuvu

3/28/17 6:20pm

Mine

SoCalCoug

3/28/17 6:24pm

Good picks

BrutustheBrash

3/28/17 6:29pm

Awesome!... that's a great Top 10

Borg

3/28/17 6:31pm

If I expanded my list to 20, it might include 4 punters:

SoCalCoug

3/28/17 6:47pm

Matt Payne ... Boise? He choked in that game.

ManicBlue

3/28/17 7:03pm

Seems like MMA Jan Jorgenson ought to make your list based on your criteria

Big Daddy D

3/28/17 11:00pm

RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?

GeauxCougs

3/28/17 6:27pm

Recency Bias list

BrutustheBrash

3/28/17 6:28pm

RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?

Crush4

3/28/17 6:30pm

Austin collie left off most of these lists! Best receiver

diluigifan

3/28/17 6:34pm

Best doesn't equal personal

GeauxCougs

3/28/17 6:35pm

I'd list Kozlowski over Collie on my list - he was far more entertaining

SoCalCoug

3/28/17 6:37pm

Kozlowski was probably the first BYU guy I emulated as a kid.

GeauxCougs

3/28/17 6:40pm

Yeah, I'm not sure anyone would consider him a "technician" like Collie was.

SoCalCoug

3/28/17 6:40pm

Google his yewt

SoCalCoug

3/28/17 6:36pm

Detmer, Staley,Young, Jimmymac,JSwag, Dewey Grey, Tim Mctyre, Austin Collie,

CarolinaCoug

3/28/17 6:40pm

My list in no particular order

ManicBlue

3/28/17 6:45pm

RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?

donnerstag

3/28/17 6:48pm

#1, when I was a kid-Stacey Corley

Mathlete

3/28/17 6:53pm

That Air Force Game. Was at that one

GeauxCougs

3/28/17 7:03pm

RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?

Coop

3/28/17 7:14pm

Itula Milli?

BDAWG

3/28/17 7:17pm

No Sark?

CougarThug

3/28/17 7:19pm

In no particular order, and way more than 10, because they all stand out to me..

So it goes...

3/28/17 7:34pm

With a list that long you probably should have put Chris Smith on it

GeauxCougs

3/28/17 7:45pm

Maybe, He was a very good TE and All-American, but for some reason he doesn't

So it goes...

3/28/17 8:12pm

My list

tcherrin

3/28/17 7:42pm

Jim McMahon, Vai Sikahema, Steve Young, Kyle Morrell,

chilango

3/28/17 8:08pm

Mine (I'm younger than most of you old weirdos):

cougarnerd

3/28/17 8:13pm

Detmer, Staley, Bellini, Payne, White, Leavitt, Van Noy, Koz, Shell, Lewis

Albuq_Coug

3/28/17 8:13pm

Solid list, I don't know who I'd swap, but Max is on mine and Sark

Graig Swame

3/28/17 8:18pm

Very hard to pick Top 10

AF_Puma

3/28/17 8:25pm

Here's mine.

Y'zFan

3/28/17 8:53pm

I have to have Ronney Jenkins on the list

Run-DMT

3/28/17 8:58pm

No Robbie Boscoe?

Jdb84

3/28/17 9:03pm

You tell 'em Mrs. Boscoe!

libertycoug

3/28/17 9:15pm

Personal favorites

libertycoug

3/28/17 9:18pm

Detmer, Hunter the Punter, Jason Buck, Randy Brock, Jamaal Willis,

Logancoug

3/28/17 9:22pm

Curious, why Ryan Hancock?

So it goes...

3/28/17 9:48pm

My favorite backup QB ever, and could throw the ball a mile

Logancoug

3/28/17 9:59pm

Mine....

Adrielle

3/28/17 9:29pm

Wiscougarfan's...

wiscougarfan

3/28/17 10:03pm

In no particular order:

frontrowcougar

3/28/17 10:04pm

Top ten that I've seen play in person

Florwood

3/28/17 11:15pm

Ty detmer, Steve young, McMahon, staley, Jamaal Williams, Austin Collie,

califcougar

3/29/17 12:12am

I had to eliminate ones I really wanted to include to get it down to 12.

Skysthelimit

3/29/17 2:13am

Luke Staley

Redfiretruck

3/29/17 6:04pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad