Seems like MMA Jan Jorgenson ought to make your list based on your criteria

Report problem with this ad

Mar 28, 2017
11:00:55pm

Big Daddy D All-American

Report problem with this ad

Big Daddy D

Bio page: Big Daddy D
Joined: Jul 3, 2003
Last login: May 16, 2024
Total posts: 39,415 (3,722 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?

Borg

3/28/17 5:58pm

No Jamaal Williams?

bushy7

3/28/17 5:59pm

I love JSwag....he should be in there...so many

Borg

3/28/17 6:04pm

That's how storied of a program we have.

Cougarfan777

3/28/17 7:14pm

My thoughts too. How can you not have Jamaal?

Skysthelimit

3/29/17 1:11am

Hard to narrow it to 10. I'd include Jswag, Virgil Carter, Chris Farasopolis but

ptcougr

3/29/17 3:36am

My 10 year old built a little Hall of Fame with painter's tape of his favorite

crack

3/28/17 6:01pm

Crap. Just double checked and there was a 4 for Taysom.

crack

3/28/17 6:11pm

In terms of playing career at BYU, Ziggy shouldn't be anywhere near that list. He wasn't even top 10 on his own team

Game Changer

3/28/17 6:02pm

Personal Top 10, for whatever reason. So - - - - - if I want Ziggy, I'll put ZIGGY!

lightmann

3/28/17 6:05pm

Yes! 😎

Borg

3/28/17 6:06pm

Criteria is your own personal reasons

Borg

3/28/17 6:06pm

So you're really asking for 10 favorite BYU football players, not top 10 players of all time?

Game Changer

3/28/17 6:13pm

He did say "your personal" top players

Pistol Shrimp

3/28/17 6:19pm

RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?

byusuvu

3/28/17 6:20pm

Mine

SoCalCoug

3/28/17 6:24pm

Good picks

BrutustheBrash

3/28/17 6:29pm

Awesome!... that's a great Top 10

Borg

3/28/17 6:31pm

If I expanded my list to 20, it might include 4 punters:

SoCalCoug

3/28/17 6:47pm

Matt Payne ... Boise? He choked in that game.

ManicBlue

3/28/17 7:03pm

Seems like MMA Jan Jorgenson ought to make your list based on your criteria

Big Daddy D

3/28/17 11:00pm

RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?

GeauxCougs

3/28/17 6:27pm

Recency Bias list

BrutustheBrash

3/28/17 6:28pm

RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?

Crush4

3/28/17 6:30pm

Austin collie left off most of these lists! Best receiver

diluigifan

3/28/17 6:34pm

Best doesn't equal personal

GeauxCougs

3/28/17 6:35pm

I'd list Kozlowski over Collie on my list - he was far more entertaining

SoCalCoug

3/28/17 6:37pm

Kozlowski was probably the first BYU guy I emulated as a kid.

GeauxCougs

3/28/17 6:40pm

Yeah, I'm not sure anyone would consider him a "technician" like Collie was.

SoCalCoug

3/28/17 6:40pm

Google his yewt

SoCalCoug

3/28/17 6:36pm

Detmer, Staley,Young, Jimmymac,JSwag, Dewey Grey, Tim Mctyre, Austin Collie,

CarolinaCoug

3/28/17 6:40pm

My list in no particular order

ManicBlue

3/28/17 6:45pm

RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?

donnerstag

3/28/17 6:48pm

#1, when I was a kid-Stacey Corley

Mathlete

3/28/17 6:53pm

That Air Force Game. Was at that one

GeauxCougs

3/28/17 7:03pm

RE: Who are your personal Top 10 BYU football players of all time?

Coop

3/28/17 7:14pm

Itula Milli?

BDAWG

3/28/17 7:17pm

No Sark?

CougarThug

3/28/17 7:19pm

In no particular order, and way more than 10, because they all stand out to me..

So it goes...

3/28/17 7:34pm

With a list that long you probably should have put Chris Smith on it

GeauxCougs

3/28/17 7:45pm

Maybe, He was a very good TE and All-American, but for some reason he doesn't

So it goes...

3/28/17 8:12pm

My list

tcherrin

3/28/17 7:42pm

Jim McMahon, Vai Sikahema, Steve Young, Kyle Morrell,

chilango

3/28/17 8:08pm

Mine (I'm younger than most of you old weirdos):

cougarnerd

3/28/17 8:13pm

Detmer, Staley, Bellini, Payne, White, Leavitt, Van Noy, Koz, Shell, Lewis

Albuq_Coug

3/28/17 8:13pm

Solid list, I don't know who I'd swap, but Max is on mine and Sark

Graig Swame

3/28/17 8:18pm

Very hard to pick Top 10

AF_Puma

3/28/17 8:25pm

Here's mine.

Y'zFan

3/28/17 8:53pm

I have to have Ronney Jenkins on the list

Run-DMT

3/28/17 8:58pm

No Robbie Boscoe?

Jdb84

3/28/17 9:03pm

You tell 'em Mrs. Boscoe!

libertycoug

3/28/17 9:15pm

Personal favorites

libertycoug

3/28/17 9:18pm

Detmer, Hunter the Punter, Jason Buck, Randy Brock, Jamaal Willis,

Logancoug

3/28/17 9:22pm

Curious, why Ryan Hancock?

So it goes...

3/28/17 9:48pm

My favorite backup QB ever, and could throw the ball a mile

Logancoug

3/28/17 9:59pm

Mine....

Adrielle

3/28/17 9:29pm

Wiscougarfan's...

wiscougarfan

3/28/17 10:03pm

In no particular order:

frontrowcougar

3/28/17 10:04pm

Top ten that I've seen play in person

Florwood

3/28/17 11:15pm

Ty detmer, Steve young, McMahon, staley, Jamaal Williams, Austin Collie,

califcougar

3/29/17 12:12am

I had to eliminate ones I really wanted to include to get it down to 12.

Skysthelimit

3/29/17 2:13am

Luke Staley

Redfiretruck

3/29/17 6:04pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad