Does Sheide belong in tier 1? Seems more tier 2.

Report problem with this ad

Apr 26, 2017
10:10:26am

Dr T-bone All-American

Report problem with this ad

Dr T-bone

Previous username: taylorgpierce
Bio page: Dr T-bone
Joined: Apr 3, 2011
Last login: May 6, 2024
Total posts: 7,547 (399 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Quarterback Tiers

D.T. Survivor

4/26/17 9:56am

I think most would put Taysom in your Tier 2.

garyfan

4/26/17 9:57am

No. He kept getting hurt before he became great. Then his senior year cemented

chazen

4/26/17 11:44am

Probably fair. But he seems like a sentimental favorite.

garyfan

4/26/17 11:48am

RE: Quarterback Tiers

socorny

4/26/17 9:57am

Max Hall should be in Tier 1.

BYUtka

4/26/17 9:58am

Yup, winningest BYU QB should be in Tier 1.

socorny

4/26/17 10:00am

<< Deleted >>

D.T. Survivor

4/26/17 10:02am

Team accomplishment puts you in top tier of positions?

Lip Gallagher

4/26/17 1:21pm

Great point

D.T. Survivor

4/26/17 10:02am

I always felt that Beck was better than Hall.

Mises

4/26/17 12:27pm

Beck better than Hall.

LoyaltotheRoyal

4/26/17 12:39pm

Hall was undrafted

D.T. Survivor

4/26/17 12:45pm

I agree. Not to mention Hall lucked out on one of the easiest scheduling stretches in modern history

indocoug

4/26/17 12:50pm

I'd put Ryan Hancock in somewhere. Maybe Tier 2.5.

DB Cooper

4/26/17 10:06am

Does Sheide belong in tier 1? Seems more tier 2.

Dr T-bone

4/26/17 10:10am

I would put Bosco in tier 2...he won the Natty, but not in the same category

Nat Gas Man

4/26/17 10:13am

Yeah 5 tiers would make things easier...

D.T. Survivor

4/26/17 10:29am

Just do UHSAA style--Keep making more tiers until everyone is happy

22jrob22

4/26/17 2:39pm

Disagree

BrutustheBrash

4/26/17 12:35pm

I am too young to know much about Sheide

D.T. Survivor

4/26/17 10:24am

Probably need to wait a few years, but I'd at least put Taysom on the same tier

Still Questing

4/26/17 10:12am

Taysom's 2016 season tarnished my thoughts

D.T. Survivor

4/26/17 10:28am

That's fair, but my point is that you're giving Doman too much credit

Still Questing

4/26/17 10:39am

Don't agree.

Cougstreak

4/26/17 3:38pm

Not hard at all to argue with those numbers. No adjustment for SOS? Only 1 yr?

Still Questing

4/26/17 4:04pm

Tier 3: Bud Belnap

84 Grad

4/26/17 10:14am

Quarterback Tears

MormonThug

4/26/17 10:26am

V. Carter in Tier 1 -- a lot of people don't remember how sensational he was. Also -- Max in Tier 1.

lightmann

4/26/17 10:28am

I've heard that about Virgil from several who watched him play

D.T. Survivor

4/26/17 12:49pm

RE: I've heard that about Virgil from several who watched him play

Bullrider

4/26/17 1:51pm

I think you need more tiers

BrutustheBrash

4/26/17 11:13am

Hill>Doman>Walsh

Modiolus

4/26/17 11:14am

Walsh>Hill>Doman

84 Grad

4/26/17 11:20am

Walsh>Doman>Hill

Napoli

4/26/17 11:21am

Walsh< Hill >Doman

Pistol Shrimp

4/26/17 12:56pm

I'd put Doman in tier 3 and Taysom in tier 2.

Nemesis

4/26/17 11:31am

Here's how I would do 5 tiers

BrutustheBrash

4/26/17 11:37am

I like it! In a year, it will be easy for Mangum to pass Nelson

D.T. Survivor

4/26/17 11:59am

I like that, although I might put Beck in your Tier 2 - based on his senior year, though, so maybe Tier 3 works overall

byukirty

4/26/17 12:09pm

Giff is a College Football HOF inductee

Y05

4/26/17 2:54pm

You are correct

BrutustheBrash

4/26/17 3:07pm

John Beck is a Tier 2 and Riley Nelson is a Tier 5. Other than that, its great

YouPuntYouDye

4/26/17 3:48pm

Just curious what your criteria is for QBs to qualify for the different tiers.

Seasider

4/26/17 11:39am

National awards, talent, team ranking, conference championships (when applicable

D.T. Survivor

4/26/17 11:56am

how would they rank if it were just the national awards?

Nat Gas Man

4/26/17 2:41pm

Yeah that is probably giving Doman too much credit

D.T. Survivor

4/26/17 11:54am

RE: Quarterback Tiers

kbufcoug

4/26/17 1:38pm

You need a tier 1b. for Taysom only

Thug Mormons

4/26/17 2:59pm

Tanner at tier 3, but no Christian Stewart?

imcain801

4/26/17 3:20pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad