Beck put up with Crowton for 2 years, and got through Bronco's first year. That 2006 season was one of the greatest Offenses in BYU history. We were #2 in the nation is offensive efficiency. Plus, we beat Utah that year. He got us back to National Prominence. I will take Beck's Senior year over any of Max's years. Beck should be a tier 1 I think. He was a second round draft pick! Hall was a 7 rounder IIRC.