Doman lead one of the better offenses in the country. Hill had the luxury of a better defense.
Doman best year: Stats: 3,542 yards passing; 456 yards rushing; 64% comp; 33 TDs; 8 INTs; 8 rushing TDs; 8.68 yards per attempt; Season: 12-2, 1st in the MWC, QB rating: 159.7
Hill's best year: best season to this point came as a sophomore when he threw for 2,938 yards and 19 touchdowns (14 ints) while recording 1,344 yards and 10 touchdowns in the running game; QB rating: 118.1
TH may have been more explosive but hard to argue with the numbers. Doman was a much better passer, Hill better runner.