Biggest concern I see...all your eggs are in one or two baskets.

Sep 20, 2017
11:37:52am

Fdnman All-American

It takes 2-3 years to develop your starters....if they go down, you are toast. Your Freshman backups can't handle the scheme. At the same time, other team's freshman backup QBs seem to come in and set the world on fire.

Report problem with this ad

Fdnman

Bio page: Fdnman
Joined: Sep 5, 2002
Last login: Apr 28, 2024
Total posts: 33,705 (486 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Lets talk BYU Football - Offense

ALC

9/19/17 7:11pm

Nice post - I've wondered whether a more gradual shift might have been better

Coop

9/19/17 7:26pm

That's always a tough predicament and both ways have their pros and cons.

ALC

9/19/17 7:42pm

"You can't handle the truth!"

CarolinaCoug

9/19/17 7:31pm

Well worth a POTD.

jkccoug

9/19/17 7:38pm

Completely agree!!! Just a little patience maybe all we need.

CougarSIR

9/19/17 8:02pm

I hated the part about how difficult this is for a qb to pick up and that it

BYUfan92

9/19/17 9:07pm

Personally, I like the higher ceiling this scheme has.

DescendentCoug

9/19/17 10:13pm

Does it have a higher ceiling though? The floor seems lower but I'm not sure

BYUfan92

9/19/17 10:54pm

Who cares where the ceiling is if you can't pull yourself up from the floor.

antiyewt

9/20/17 9:07am

Doesn't take years for all, however some never get it

youngbuck

9/20/17 12:40am

I'd rather our scheme adjust to our players than players to the scheme.

doctorthunderpants

9/20/17 10:24am

Give qb one read and code red scramble drill?

youngbuck

9/20/17 1:21pm

Good Post- a few more items

Canusa

9/19/17 8:32pm

Good post. Hopefully Ty can make a couple of adjustments to get things going

Judge Judy

9/19/17 8:32pm

A great defense of continuity in your coaching staff

Brigham

9/19/17 8:48pm

Yes as long as we signs of improvement..which we have if you k ow football

CarolinaCoug

9/19/17 8:53pm

I hope everyone reads this

BYURider

9/19/17 8:48pm

LSU and USC switched 3rd game to spread and had instant offensive success

Bobmarleyjr

9/19/17 8:56pm

If we can borrow their athletes I'm in

ALC

9/19/17 9:03pm

Their athletes weren't using the pro set more effectively and spread req less

Bobmarleyjr

9/19/17 9:04pm

Not according to USCs coach.

jkccoug

9/19/17 9:12pm

He said he wouldn't call it that but other coaches and their QB call it a spread

Bobmarleyjr

9/19/17 9:26pm

Huh? LSU scored 7 pts...that isn't instant success.

CarolinaCoug

9/19/17 9:46pm

I think he means last year although he and I disagree on what a spread is

jkccoug

9/19/17 9:58pm

You'd think they would've learned their lesson from the Doman/Heaps season

Seasider

9/19/17 9:00pm

One thing in common = coach killing qb play

youngbuck

9/20/17 12:35am

Good post, thanks for sharing some of your knowledge and experience.

Zach Morris

9/19/17 9:09pm

BYU's legacy is innovation on offense. I hope Ty sticks to it and realizes his

Unibro

9/19/17 9:25pm

I would love to see it come to fruition as well, but it will require patience.

ALC

9/19/17 9:31pm

You mention the personnel needed to run Ty's system my concern is the type of

franklyvulgar

9/19/17 9:43pm

Fire Detmer and let me run it. I had a perfect season last year on Madden

Cosmo4life

9/19/17 10:50pm

The real difficult thing is that at BYU getting your recruits in place can take

Y2k

9/19/17 11:48pm

I don't think Sitake, Bronco recruits are much different from each other.

franklyvulgar

9/20/17 1:06am

Bronco sure didn't have players decommiting from other Universities like Sitake.

Y2k

9/20/17 9:59pm

They need some JC skill position help this off season....

Bonoman

9/20/17 12:15am

RE: Lets talk BYU Football - Offense

Skysthelimit

9/20/17 12:16am

In general I don't disagree with much of what you said other then QB

youngbuck

9/20/17 12:33am

That explains why Ty appears so frustrated at times talking to Tanner as he...

icecougar

9/20/17 9:01am

This raises pretty big concerns about the defense as well

korihor

9/20/17 8:05am

Great analysis. Spot on. A transition would have been helpful.

Real Men Wear Blue

9/20/17 9:14am

<< Deleted >>

AZ Coug 22

9/20/17 9:16am

will try and put something together on that in a couple of days

ALC

9/20/17 6:48pm

He will never be a breakaway threat?

Denesheo

9/20/17 10:12am

I think he is just suggesting a 250 pound running back isn't going to make his

gww687

9/20/17 10:19am

He's just saying Ula isn't going to run a 4.4 anytime soon.

doctorthunderpants

9/20/17 10:21am

As the two posters said above, he will break some runs

ALC

9/20/17 6:43pm

Awesome post! I agree 100%.

doctorthunderpants

9/20/17 10:19am

Biggest concern I see...all your eggs are in one or two baskets.

Fdnman

9/20/17 11:37am

Holy cow! A level headed, common sense analysis instead of whining about how

Cyclogist

9/20/17 11:54am

I agree this post--assuming the system is sound, I'm for taking the medicine now

Posting on CougarBoard