Yes, but...

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 20, 2017
7:03:32pm

insidebyu Walk-on

Yes, but...

...what is the prize?

Personally, I think NY6 would be awesome, but I can concede that maybe it's not what it used to be. But if that's not what we're playing for, what exactly are we playing for? exposure? This whole "exposure" thing would be a lot more compelling if we were winning big games.

Report problem with this ad

insidebyu

Bio page: insidebyu
Joined: Jun 24, 2010
Last login: Nov 11, 2017
Total posts: 543 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Is that Jason Buck on Criddle right now? Respect him, but completely disagree.

PJMort

9/20/17 3:35pm

If you disagree strongly it's Buck

NachoCougar

9/20/17 3:39pm

New Mexico was a legit sellout in '06 when a MWC title was on the line

CaliWG

9/20/17 3:39pm

I don't think independence and attendance are correlated though. Attendance

RdF3

9/20/17 3:41pm

except 45 mins north of LES...

icecougar

9/20/17 3:43pm

And even our "sparsely" attended games draw more people. They'd

gwalker

9/20/17 3:44pm

Our worst attendance since 2003 would sell out their stadium.

jkccoug

9/20/17 3:45pm

Would they?

Brigham

9/20/17 3:58pm

The fact that Chris hill doesn't really want to expand tells me he doesn't

SUAVO

9/20/17 4:01pm

Their games against SUU and North Dakota aren't exactly

gwalker

9/20/17 4:06pm

Great being the operative word

jkccoug

9/20/17 3:44pm

P5 conference...bad argument

BYUSwoop

9/20/17 7:30pm

That was because we were 9-2 and fun to watch

jkccoug

9/20/17 3:43pm

2006? The year we went 11-2 and were ranked? Had TCU and Utah in the conference?

PJMort

9/20/17 3:48pm

You mean 8-5 Utah? Or #25 TCU? Those weren't the same TCU & Utah teams as '08-10

CaliWG

9/20/17 4:08pm

Yes I mean UTAH and TCU. Does it really matter that Utah went 8-5?

PJMort

9/20/17 4:27pm

He's talkin out his butt, I'm convinced. Doesn't care about BYU's success 1 iota

mantis mutu

9/20/17 3:40pm

Plus I think it would hurt recruiting

fan_byu

9/20/17 3:40pm

Recruiting has been worse since we left the MWC.

Turbine

9/20/17 3:48pm

Since Utah started recruiting against us with a P5 label you mean

jkccoug

9/20/17 3:53pm

BYU doesn't go head to head with Utah near enough to make the difference.

Turbine

9/20/17 3:54pm

Do you follow recruiting...we go head to head for most Poly recruits.

BYUSwoop

9/20/17 7:34pm

It's not utah hurting you

BigT801

9/20/17 4:06pm

Maybe so. But still a function of Utah going to P12 IMO.

jkccoug

9/20/17 5:17pm

I think it is though! I don't have time

BigT801

9/20/17 6:33pm

No I agree with you. Its common for teams to recruit harder in their conference

jkccoug

9/20/17 7:16pm

Gotcha

BigT801

9/20/17 8:57pm

The whole NY6 thing might be in question anyway. If in 2025 when the P5

Nat Gas Man

9/20/17 3:44pm

I've seen the "just win" mantra on CB since Indy was announced...

Zach Morris

9/20/17 3:45pm

BYU has some of the most unbalanced schedules in CF. So hard to "just win".

Turbine

9/20/17 3:49pm

Exactly. BYU's version of independence is a recipe for

Zach Morris

9/20/17 3:52pm

I know TH is in between a rock and hard place.....

Bonoman

9/20/17 4:41pm

Also struggling to get garbage P5 wins (AZ, MSU, MSU etc)

Cougstreak

9/20/17 5:14pm

Same mantra at every team. Hopefully BYU figures it out.

PJMort

9/20/17 3:53pm

I think he's dead wrong. Living in the past. Uncle Rico to a T.

indojoe

9/20/17 3:52pm

He has turned to the Yewt side. Wore UofU gear to the Rivavly game.

BYUtka

9/20/17 4:00pm

Seriously? I don't want to believe that about anyone I have respect for.

panguitch

9/20/17 5:46pm

That is what was reported. I didn't personally see it.

BYUtka

9/20/17 5:53pm

I saw him. Just liked like a grey shirt. No byu or utah stuff

SUAVO

9/20/17 6:45pm

He stood 20 feet from our seats most of the game. No Ute gear that I could see

5150man

9/20/17 6:07pm

BYU football has made it clear that independence > G5. That position minimizes

MaxxPower

9/20/17 4:53pm

NO NO NO NO never go back to a G5 conference.....

BYU Grounds

9/20/17 5:09pm

TRUE TRUE TRUE ^^^^^

Coogar2

9/20/17 5:58pm

Bingo

BYUSwoop

9/20/17 7:32pm

Agree! G5ers are non-Cougs at heart

HowardH

9/21/17 12:06am

So playing UNM, UNLV and Wyoming is a bigger draw for fans and recruits than

Coogar2

9/20/17 5:57pm

Yes, but...

insidebyu

9/20/17 7:03pm

To play freaking awesome teams and beat them; Not sister's of the poor conferenc

BYUSwoop

9/20/17 7:33pm

He is spot on.

kosmokramer

9/20/17 9:44pm

He is a narcissist with very little between the ears

Backcountry

9/20/17 10:33pm

Simmer down

9/21/17 2:05am

I'm good

Backcountry

9/21/17 4:21am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad