My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Nov 20, 2014
9:44
:08
pm
icecougar
we'll never know...
and we'll waste another year hoping that doing the same thing will miraculously deliver different results.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
icecougar
Bio page
icecougar
Joined
Apr 17, 2006
Last login
Jun 16, 2024
Total posts
40,893 (338 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
So, at what point is it Bronco's fault BYU is not excelling?
lawboy
11/20/14 1:57pm
Many never will question Bronco. They'll blame BYU for being BYU.
Grit for Brains
11/20/14 2:01pm
I often get that label, even though I do think he is responsible for some of it
binghammer
11/20/14 2:04pm
He should not get fired after this year, but
lawboy
11/20/14 2:13pm
I just look at the point he had all of his recruits and his coaches...
kotacoug
11/20/14 2:01pm
As a coach...
Heinz57
11/20/14 2:01pm
I think Bronco has done a good job of playing the chess game and...
icecougar
11/20/14 8:24pm
I want to know what people think changed from 2009 to 2010 with Bronco
binghammer
11/20/14 2:03pm
Defense is giving it a run for its money this year
CoopDizz
11/20/14 2:05pm
I think we could have been 10-0 potentially if Taysom were 100%
binghammer
11/20/14 2:07pm
Same goes for a D with Ziggy, KVN, Kav, and Tree
CoopDizz
11/20/14 2:08pm
Yeah, add in 4 guys who were either captains or PRO's on D, sure
binghammer
11/20/14 2:10pm
What does that have to do with the OP?
CoopDizz
11/20/14 2:20pm
I disagree, I think it is everything
binghammer
11/20/14 2:23pm
That's not even a response to what I said
CoopDizz
11/20/14 2:24pm
I didn't read your entire post. Just the second line.
binghammer
11/20/14 2:29pm
Boise St scored 55 pts
icecougar
11/20/14 9:24pm
Buck stops with the Bronco
Heinz57
11/20/14 2:07pm
I agree, but only because he is the only one the admin has any control over
binghammer
11/20/14 2:08pm
We are talking football, not administrative
Heinz57
11/20/14 2:12pm
I agree, I just don't think a head coach has as much control over the team
binghammer
11/20/14 2:13pm
If that is the case...
Heinz57
11/20/14 2:15pm
lol, no, don't try and change the subject
binghammer
11/20/14 2:26pm
What's the subject...
Smoke Monster
11/20/14 2:37pm
Fine with 500k...
Heinz57
11/20/14 3:07pm
No, that 25% counts for 25%, it can be a big difference
binghammer
11/20/14 3:32pm
LOL... but 25% is still 25%...
Smoke Monster
11/20/14 3:41pm
I didn't...
Heinz57
11/20/14 3:06pm
It has been 5 years of mediocre results. Next year is likely another 6-8 win
Mikey
11/20/14 2:21pm
I wouldn't call the last 5 years mediocre, even this year BYU is rated in the
binghammer
11/20/14 2:28pm
Well, obviously we have different standards, which is why we have a different
Mikey
11/20/14 2:35pm
Based upon program expectations set by Bronco himself, they're mediocre
lawboy
11/20/14 2:47pm
The fact that we are having this conversation over the record we have this year
binghammer
11/20/14 3:33pm
And with that is also...
Heinz57
11/20/14 4:38pm
I choose "dump"
Mikey
11/20/14 4:40pm
This is why Bronco will be safe here for a long while...because long term
sundance
11/20/14 5:39pm
This is incorrect. Bronco has taken extreme heat this season, and so has the
CalGTR
11/20/14 5:48pm
and don't continually repeat the same mistakes over and over...
icecougar
11/20/14 9:28pm
2010 is when Bronco and crew decided to go with a two QB system that is still
wabluecoug
11/20/14 2:07pm
Recruiting
lawboy
11/20/14 2:07pm
I don't agree, I think recruiting has been pretty good
binghammer
11/20/14 2:12pm
Recruiting has been fine everywhere except the lines
CoopDizz
11/20/14 2:23pm
Whitt has had a similar problem recruiting and developing the QB position...
icecougar
11/20/14 9:20pm
Go sit at the Wilk for an hour and think about what you just wrote. Just look at
ToasterChive
11/20/14 2:05pm
it's ALWAYS up to the millionaire in the mix to take charge, to take
Tsisquan
11/20/14 2:15pm
Are we really arguing over who is responsible for the performance of the team?
CalGTR
11/20/14 2:30pm
The discussion is a bit more nuanced.
lawboy
11/20/14 2:38pm
Ah, but that's not what you asked. You've now exposed your agenda.
CalGTR
11/20/14 2:59pm
First off, I have no agenda.
lawboy
11/20/14 3:54pm
Well, you said a lot of things, didn't you? Notice that the question you posted,
CalGTR
11/20/14 5:03pm
You're being obtuse
lawboy
11/20/14 6:47pm
Not being obtuse, I just don't accept the underlying premise of your question.
CalGTR
11/20/14 11:26pm
Wow, you sure read a lot between the lines and I would argue
sah22
11/20/14 9:02pm
I think we have two attorneys duking it out on CB. Go Lawboy!
BYUTE59
11/20/14 7:26pm
Martzens recruiting success one of the few bright spots the past couple of year
Bonoman
11/20/14 2:49pm
You can blame Bronco for
CasualFan
11/20/14 2:39pm
Where were Doug Scovil and Norm Chow OCs before they got the BYU job?
CoopDizz
11/20/14 2:45pm
What was BYU when those guys were hired?
CasualFan
11/20/14 2:47pm
It's an argument built on hot air and nothing more - faulty as all get out
CoopDizz
11/20/14 2:48pm
Chow was also a long-time QB coach
CasualFan
11/20/14 2:52pm
I'm saying BYU should hire the best guy for the job
CoopDizz
11/20/14 2:56pm
Ok. perhaps I should be more clear
CasualFan
11/20/14 2:58pm
You definitely want someone who has shown in some way that he can handle it
CoopDizz
11/20/14 3:18pm
right. Example: Anae vs Doman
icecougar
11/21/14 2:08pm
Scovil started coaching in the early 50's and coached in the NFL before BYU...
icecougar
11/20/14 9:40pm
Read all the way to the end of the conversation before you respond
CoopDizz
11/21/14 8:04am
yes, it's confusing...
icecougar
11/21/14 2:26pm
It's hard to credit Bronco for Taysom Hill when even he admits he fell to BYU.
Mantis Mutu
11/20/14 2:47pm
Yeah, but he didn't fall to Utah or UCLA or
CasualFan
11/20/14 2:50pm
After a 2 yr mish, I'm not sure he was high enough on anyone's radar
Mantis Mutu
11/20/14 2:56pm
Did he come because it was BYU, or because of Bronco
HawkeyeCoug
11/20/14 3:29pm
likely because it was BYU, same as with Harvey Langi...
icecougar
11/20/14 9:42pm
Bronco is failing at developing and preparing the team IMO
Jeffe
11/20/14 3:48pm
Guessing with next years schedule ....
bluegato
11/20/14 4:25pm
we'll never know...
icecougar
11/20/14 9:44pm
At a minimum, when his team's consisted of his own recruits.
Real Men Wear Blue
11/20/14 4:54pm
RE: 8-4 against last year's schedule was respectable. If Bronco is so bad, in
Coogar2
11/20/14 6:14pm
If things really go south like they did when Crowton was HC
CougarsFanSince80s
11/20/14 10:20pm
sorry this post was meant to be in reply to the original poster
CougarsFanSince80s
11/20/14 10:33pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad