Pretty sure. They showed repeatedly in slo-mo while waiting...

Sep 11, 2017
6:22:06pm

Eddie All-American

...for the results of the official review. It was clearly obvious that the crown of the defender's helmet hit Tanner's helmet. I was clear enough that the TV guys didn't even question the helmet to helmet aspect of the hit.

Report problem with this ad

Eddie

Bio page: Eddie
Joined: Dec 12, 2002
Last login: Jun 14, 2024
Total posts: 44,385 (927 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Kyle implying the targeting call was iffy. Thoughts?

The Board Genius

9/11/17 2:31pm

It didn't just stand, the booth confirmed it

v1k0u6

9/11/17 2:31pm

exactly... it was textbook leading with the head...

1984coug

9/11/17 2:32pm

the crown of his helmet literally followed Mangum's to the ground.

SpiffCoug

9/11/17 2:48pm

That's funny. I agree it's a stupid call the way it is written to begin with

Bob Vance

9/11/17 2:32pm

That's exactly what Kyle said.

TFL

9/11/17 2:37pm

QB slide, led with his head, impact took off QB's helmet - easy call

LV Mike

9/11/17 2:32pm

It was the easiest targeting call I have seen, ever.

RexIdaCoug

9/11/17 2:38pm

Loser.

Ocho Cuatro

9/11/17 2:32pm

What did he last year about the one on BYU?

wapiti

9/11/17 2:33pm

Hate to see his idea of a legit one, especially given the Kai one last year.

soupie

9/11/17 2:33pm

was the definition of targeting. even utah fans have to agree that was

johnnycarson

9/11/17 2:33pm

I was just glad it was a Utah guy who got flagged so we don't have to hear

Tricky

9/11/17 2:45pm

I thought it was a good call after watching the replay. Tanner slid late, but

Rise as Utes

9/11/17 2:48pm

From what I recall, flag came in late. He was probably initially called simply

CougBlu

9/11/17 2:56pm

On TV it looked like his arm knocked it off at first and I was upset with the

Rise as Utes

9/11/17 3:00pm

Yeah. I had several Utes around me at the game. Very few complained aNd even

CougBlu

9/11/17 3:02pm

If he hadn't targeted him with his helmet he probably just slides right over top

Lance71

9/11/17 5:47pm

Live I didn't think it was a penalty, but on the replay it clearly was with how

Scratch

9/11/17 3:21pm

He's an idiot.

Mr. Scoobs

9/11/17 2:33pm

A toxic, petty person driven by hate

Carlos E. Queso

9/11/17 2:56pm

what sucks is they lost their leading tackler and we still didn't move the ball

johnnycarson

9/11/17 2:33pm

That's the dirtiest play I've seen in this game in 5+ years.

Lance71

9/11/17 2:33pm

I don't think it was intentional to the head (though this doesn't matter). It

4mack

9/11/17 2:35pm

I usually have a problem with most of these calls

BradioHead

9/11/17 2:35pm

Since it happened in the first half, he can play next game.

enigomo

9/11/17 2:50pm

It looked like there wasn't actual helmet to helmet contact, but the defensive player definitely lowered his helmet and

LilToney

9/11/17 2:36pm

You're wrong, the only thing that hit Tanner's helmet was the defender's helmet.

Lance71

9/11/17 5:49pm

Are sure. I'm pretty certain I didn't see contact. Granted, I've only seen the replay the few times they showed it at

LilToney

9/11/17 5:57pm

Pretty sure. They showed repeatedly in slo-mo while waiting...

Eddie

9/11/17 6:22pm

Legit call; rule is iffy.

byujdmba

9/11/17 2:36pm

Even without the targeting, he was pile-driving a sliding QB

cougarmeister

9/11/17 2:37pm

Seriously. Mangum was sliding feet-first, and the guy dove head-first into his helmet. The replays were awful. Textbook

Smack'sWife

9/11/17 2:50pm

Let me guess, he was making this face:

Triggerhappybunny

9/11/17 2:38pm

RE: Kyle implying the targeting call was iffy. Thoughts?

JAGA97

9/11/17 2:39pm

There was nothing iffy about it. Led with crown of helmet.

Turnpike Lane

9/11/17 2:40pm

The biggest iffy call was to not call the ball contacting the Ute player on the

Littlerich

9/11/17 2:40pm

Didn't touch him, and if it had, he was pushed to the ball (so it doesn't count)

displacedute

9/11/17 2:50pm

Show me the rule that it doesn't count if pushed into.

CosmoK

9/11/17 3:18pm

We were debating this at the game

BYU Fan

9/11/17 3:20pm

Looked it up. Rule 6.4, it seems.

CosmoK

9/11/17 3:23pm

Ok, that explains it

Littlerich

9/11/17 3:37pm

Yeah, I've seen that called a few times.

cougarstolz

9/11/17 3:37pm

I couldn't see conclusive evidence that the punt hit the player

BYU Fan

9/11/17 2:51pm

To answer your question, no Kyle is not good at thoughts.

Caboom

9/11/17 2:42pm

That was probably the most obvious targeting penalty ever. A sliding QB and you lower the crown of your head to make

SuperTank

9/11/17 2:44pm

Didn't he say it was definitely targeting as the rule defines it?

displacedute

9/11/17 2:45pm

Yes you did. Like usual.

The Board Genius

9/11/17 2:47pm

RE: Yes you did. Like usual.

displacedute

9/11/17 2:51pm

Not difficult. Just lift helmet don't lead with the crown. Hanneman need to

rcbyufan

9/11/17 2:49pm

Uh, when the QB is sliding, there is NOTHING a defender can do. A slide is

ByuMba90

9/11/17 2:51pm

The targeting plays I hate

BradioHead

9/11/17 2:51pm

He needs to rewatch it.

Eddie

9/11/17 3:56pm

I don't think that's what he was implying.

dut99002

9/11/17 2:47pm

Ha, even Hans just now called Kyle out just a little.

The Board Genius

9/11/17 2:49pm

It seems like Kyle's players have always enjoyed hitting a sliding QB

BYU Fan

9/11/17 2:52pm

He also said today that Sunia was already committed at the start of the slide.

Dwight Schr-UTE

9/11/17 2:57pm

Whit doesn't do "reasonable"

Carlos E. Queso

9/11/17 3:01pm

It was statuatory targeting; intention doesn't (and shouldn't) matter

ColoSpgs

9/11/17 2:48pm

Hillary, Comey and the FBI disagree about intent.

ByuMba90

9/11/17 2:52pm

I actually think mangum is 18 or older.

Virginia Ute

9/11/17 2:53pm

I thought it was pretty clear cut targeting. He lowered his head obviously

Virginia Ute

9/11/17 2:52pm

This is what I was thinking.

Eddie

9/11/17 3:50pm

It was. Not like he was sliding or his helmet came off or anything.

Posting on CougarBoard