My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Sep 11, 2017
2:51
:51
pm
displacedute
All-American
RE: Yes you did. Like usual.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
displacedute
Bio page
displacedute
Joined
May 30, 2005
Last login
May 17, 2024
Total posts
10,953 (29 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Kyle implying the targeting call was iffy. Thoughts?
The Board Genius
9/11/17 2:31pm
It didn't just stand, the booth confirmed it
v1k0u6
9/11/17 2:31pm
exactly... it was textbook leading with the head...
1984coug
9/11/17 2:32pm
the crown of his helmet literally followed Mangum's to the ground.
SpiffCoug
9/11/17 2:48pm
That's funny. I agree it's a stupid call the way it is written to begin with
Bob Vance
9/11/17 2:32pm
That's exactly what Kyle said.
TFL
9/11/17 2:37pm
QB slide, led with his head, impact took off QB's helmet - easy call
LV Mike
9/11/17 2:32pm
It was the easiest targeting call I have seen, ever.
RexIdaCoug
9/11/17 2:38pm
Loser.
Ocho Cuatro
9/11/17 2:32pm
What did he last year about the one on BYU?
wapiti
9/11/17 2:33pm
Hate to see his idea of a legit one, especially given the Kai one last year.
soupie
9/11/17 2:33pm
was the definition of targeting. even utah fans have to agree that was
johnnycarson
9/11/17 2:33pm
I was just glad it was a Utah guy who got flagged so we don't have to hear
Tricky
9/11/17 2:45pm
I thought it was a good call after watching the replay. Tanner slid late, but
Rise as Utes
9/11/17 2:48pm
From what I recall, flag came in late. He was probably initially called simply
CougBlu
9/11/17 2:56pm
On TV it looked like his arm knocked it off at first and I was upset with the
Rise as Utes
9/11/17 3:00pm
Yeah. I had several Utes around me at the game. Very few complained aNd even
CougBlu
9/11/17 3:02pm
If he hadn't targeted him with his helmet he probably just slides right over top
Lance71
9/11/17 5:47pm
Live I didn't think it was a penalty, but on the replay it clearly was with how
Scratch
9/11/17 3:21pm
He's an idiot.
Mr. Scoobs
9/11/17 2:33pm
A toxic, petty person driven by hate
Carlos E. Queso
9/11/17 2:56pm
what sucks is they lost their leading tackler and we still didn't move the ball
johnnycarson
9/11/17 2:33pm
That's the dirtiest play I've seen in this game in 5+ years.
Lance71
9/11/17 2:33pm
I don't think it was intentional to the head (though this doesn't matter). It
4mack
9/11/17 2:35pm
I usually have a problem with most of these calls
BradioHead
9/11/17 2:35pm
Since it happened in the first half, he can play next game.
enigomo
9/11/17 2:50pm
It looked like there wasn't actual helmet to helmet contact, but the defensive player definitely lowered his helmet and
LilToney
9/11/17 2:36pm
You're wrong, the only thing that hit Tanner's helmet was the defender's helmet.
Lance71
9/11/17 5:49pm
Are sure. I'm pretty certain I didn't see contact. Granted, I've only seen the replay the few times they showed it at
LilToney
9/11/17 5:57pm
Pretty sure. They showed repeatedly in slo-mo while waiting...
Eddie
9/11/17 6:22pm
Legit call; rule is iffy.
byujdmba
9/11/17 2:36pm
Even without the targeting, he was pile-driving a sliding QB
cougarmeister
9/11/17 2:37pm
Seriously. Mangum was sliding feet-first, and the guy dove head-first into his helmet. The replays were awful. Textbook
Smack'sWife
9/11/17 2:50pm
Let me guess, he was making this face:
Triggerhappybunny
9/11/17 2:38pm
RE: Kyle implying the targeting call was iffy. Thoughts?
JAGA97
9/11/17 2:39pm
There was nothing iffy about it. Led with crown of helmet.
Turnpike Lane
9/11/17 2:40pm
The biggest iffy call was to not call the ball contacting the Ute player on the
Littlerich
9/11/17 2:40pm
Didn't touch him, and if it had, he was pushed to the ball (so it doesn't count)
displacedute
9/11/17 2:50pm
Show me the rule that it doesn't count if pushed into.
CosmoK
9/11/17 3:18pm
We were debating this at the game
BYU Fan
9/11/17 3:20pm
Looked it up. Rule 6.4, it seems.
CosmoK
9/11/17 3:23pm
Ok, that explains it
Littlerich
9/11/17 3:37pm
Yeah, I've seen that called a few times.
cougarstolz
9/11/17 3:37pm
I couldn't see conclusive evidence that the punt hit the player
BYU Fan
9/11/17 2:51pm
To answer your question, no Kyle is not good at thoughts.
Caboom
9/11/17 2:42pm
That was probably the most obvious targeting penalty ever. A sliding QB and you lower the crown of your head to make
SuperTank
9/11/17 2:44pm
Didn't he say it was definitely targeting as the rule defines it?
displacedute
9/11/17 2:45pm
Yes you did. Like usual.
The Board Genius
9/11/17 2:47pm
RE: Yes you did. Like usual.
displacedute
9/11/17 2:51pm
Not difficult. Just lift helmet don't lead with the crown. Hanneman need to
rcbyufan
9/11/17 2:49pm
Uh, when the QB is sliding, there is NOTHING a defender can do. A slide is
ByuMba90
9/11/17 2:51pm
The targeting plays I hate
BradioHead
9/11/17 2:51pm
He needs to rewatch it.
Eddie
9/11/17 3:56pm
I don't think that's what he was implying.
dut99002
9/11/17 2:47pm
Ha, even Hans just now called Kyle out just a little.
The Board Genius
9/11/17 2:49pm
It seems like Kyle's players have always enjoyed hitting a sliding QB
BYU Fan
9/11/17 2:52pm
He also said today that Sunia was already committed at the start of the slide.
Dwight Schr-UTE
9/11/17 2:57pm
Whit doesn't do "reasonable"
Carlos E. Queso
9/11/17 3:01pm
It was statuatory targeting; intention doesn't (and shouldn't) matter
ColoSpgs
9/11/17 2:48pm
Hillary, Comey and the FBI disagree about intent.
ByuMba90
9/11/17 2:52pm
I actually think mangum is 18 or older.
Virginia Ute
9/11/17 2:53pm
I thought it was pretty clear cut targeting. He lowered his head obviously
Virginia Ute
9/11/17 2:52pm
This is what I was thinking.
Eddie
9/11/17 3:50pm
It was. Not like he was sliding or his helmet came off or anything.
TRUE_BLUE_COUGY
9/11/17 3:24pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad