As long as it is consistent what is the problem?

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 16, 2018
9:50:40am

TNT All-American

As long as it is consistent what is the problem?

Report problem with this ad

TNT

Bio page: TNT
Joined: Dec 19, 2001
Last login: May 31, 2024
Total posts: 235,506 (10,948 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Sagarin's new rating system with last year always weighting so heavily is dumb

RdF3

9/16/18 9:47am

Wait till week 5 or 6 when last year’s results no longer factor in

NorCal_Coug

9/16/18 9:48am

Answered my question

9/16/18 9:49am

He's keeping last year's results as 15% of the rating all year long.

RdF3

9/16/18 9:51am

Wow. Idiotic

9/16/18 9:52am

Especially since last year BYU underperformed to talent substantially

9/16/18 9:52am

It's not idiotic. It makes the model more accurate overall. There will always

molodyets

9/16/18 10:00am

I’ll disagree with you on that slightly

9/16/18 10:25am

You make large assumptions that he didn't consider and test that as well.

molodyets

9/16/18 10:41am

I guess - his process is evolving - he’s said so in interviews this fall

9/16/18 10:45am

It's never perfect. These things are shooting for 75% ish straight up and 53%+

molodyets

9/16/18 10:51am

Sure. no disagreement. I think we can agree on that statement fully

9/16/18 10:59am

When does last year drop off completey

9/16/18 9:49am

2019

BYUinTX

9/16/18 9:59am

<< Deleted >>

Mr. Scoobs

9/16/18 9:49am

As long as it is consistent what is the problem?

TNT

9/16/18 9:50am

I think it's dumb that even in December, 15% of a team's rating will be based

RdF3

9/16/18 9:52am

What do you propose?

TNT

9/16/18 9:53am

Not using it?

9/16/18 9:54am

Dropping off last year's results after week 4 last he used to.

RdF3

9/16/18 9:54am

It does. They back test these things. How do you expect it to perform

molodyets

9/16/18 9:59am

And what's he using a base accuracy off of? The AP top 25? His opinion of how

RdF3

9/16/18 10:10am

On field results of what it predicted vs the outcome.

molodyets

9/16/18 10:12am

It would make sense to do a 5 year average of final ratings.

specsauce

9/16/18 10:08am

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

9/16/18 10:19am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad