My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 20, 2019
6:58
:45
pm
bluecougar1985
Playmaker
Because you can’t call a timeout and then challenge without another timeout.
I’ve seen a team lose 2 timeouts at once doing that.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
bluecougar1985
Bio page
bluecougar1985
Joined
Dec 10, 2015
Last login
Jun 4, 2024
Total posts
15,764 (1,587 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
So much bad officiating on one series
BigYfan
10/20/19 6:39pm
I don’t get the angst over the timeout issue
BYU Fan
10/20/19 6:49pm
Kalani was pissed about that. Game clock didnt start until 7 seconds on the play
rggee
10/20/19 6:52pm
Because you can’t call a timeout and then challenge without another timeout.
bluecougar1985
10/20/19 6:58pm
It's not really fair to say its 4th down to force a timeout but then change the
rggee
10/20/19 7:00pm
I never saw them call it 4th down, every indication was they were calling for a
bluecougar1985
10/20/19 7:04pm
They definitely didnt wave the clock to stop until Boise called TO
rggee
10/20/19 7:07pm
We can split hairs on stuff like this all day, but the fact is they incorrectly
bluecougar1985
10/20/19 7:18pm
And then gave them a favorable spot based on "inconclusive" evidence.
ochobeeguy
10/20/19 7:22pm
He didnt make the 35. Simple geometry means that's 4th down if you start at the
rggee
10/20/19 7:25pm
If the lines are all painted straight. Isn't that why you have chains?
ochobeeguy
10/20/19 7:37pm
Just think that one through. How do the chain gang know where to start?
All-American
10/20/19 7:54pm
This is covered in the written rules. No matter where it actually starts, or
Lance71
10/20/19 8:33pm
Have you ever been on the field to see the lines? They are definitely not perfectly straight
YIsForBrigham
10/20/19 9:47pm
I trust the lines more than the chain gang.
All-American
10/21/19 11:27am
You shouldn’t. The chains are much more accurate
YIsForBrigham
10/21/19 2:27pm
Why bother bringing chains out to measure at all, if they can just eyeball it?
All-American
10/21/19 2:31pm
According to the initial spot he made the 35. There was no replay
StalwartBraveTrue
10/20/19 11:59pm
No he didnt.
rggee
10/21/19 5:35am
I dont agree.
rggee
10/20/19 7:24pm
And I dont agree with the sign that says 50 is the speed limit.
bluecougar1985
10/20/19 7:26pm
I agree!
rggee
10/20/19 7:30pm
It seems to me that it is usually one process
BYU Fan
10/20/19 7:31pm
When they challenged the play they did not have any timeouts left
BigYfan
10/20/19 7:06pm
At the end of the day, it really was 4th down and Boise used their final TO.
Corn Pop
10/20/19 7:00pm
Exactly.
rggee
10/20/19 7:01pm
Huh?
RealityCheck
10/20/19 8:41pm
I hated that about the timeout and challenge. I was screaming at the TV saying you need a TO to challenge.
PessimisticCB
10/20/19 9:05pm
They gave the timeout back when they decided to
Vernon Dozier
10/20/19 9:26pm
BSU was able to stop the clock 10 seconds before the officials called for
StalwartBraveTrue
10/21/19 12:11am
^^^^this^^^^
BigYfan
10/21/19 3:32am
I’ll have to rewatch it as I was at the stadium....
Vernon Dozier
10/21/19 7:06am
But if it had been a 1st down, the ref would have stopped the clock immediately.
rggee
10/21/19 5:56am
What are you talking about?
StalwartBraveTrue
10/21/19 11:23am
I know. They called timeout because the refs had it as a 4th down. Then they
rggee
10/21/19 11:25am
Seems to me coaches should be judicious about when they call timeouts.
StalwartBraveTrue
10/21/19 2:20pm
I was surprised when they said Boise was challenging!
NVCougar
10/20/19 10:03pm
Come on, the world isn't against us
StantonMac
10/20/19 10:15pm
I need to amend this slightly...
StantonMac
10/20/19 10:35pm
Wait, if they didn’t challenge it why did they get the timeout back? Too many
bluecougar1985
10/21/19 6:51am
Because they never had to use the timeout.
Vernon Dozier
10/21/19 7:12am
correct they announced that it was a challenge by Boise St and that they got
BigYfan
10/21/19 8:24am
That is really interesting, but then why did the Ref announce that Boise was
NVCougar
10/21/19 10:42am
my amendment ...
NVCougar
10/21/19 10:46am
It's true that the white hat said that Boise State was challenging the ruling
StantonMac
10/21/19 11:41am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad