My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Dec 3, 2021
6:18
:23
pm
Y05
All-American
McMahon's records started falling just a couple years after he left.
Detmer's lasted over a decade.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Y05
Previous username
Yz1
Bio page
Y05
Joined
Feb 16, 2010
Last login
Oct 31, 2024
Total posts
22,063 (569 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Wow, Jaren
mjmill
All-American
12/3/21 1:35pm
Good data. I'd like to see best season, regardless of class year.
snowbird
12/3/21 1:37pm
Found it. 30th overall. That puts him around 2014 Christian Stewart efficiency,
snowbird
12/3/21 1:39pm
Nice. McMahon was a cheat code. 176 is an absurd number for a 1st yr starter.
d-coug
12/3/21 1:38pm
McMahon didn’t have DB blitzes and LBs couldn’t really cover
Bobmarleyjr
12/3/21 2:24pm
If it was so simple, QBs from McMahon’s era @ other schools would have similar #
reddead
12/3/21 6:04pm
McMahon's records started falling just a couple years after he left.
Y05
12/3/21 6:18pm
We're talking about pass efficiency, not records. Did other QBs match his eff %?
reddead
12/3/21 9:01pm
How would it be so simple when most teams didn’t know or want to pass?
Bobmarleyjr
12/3/21 11:51pm
In 1980, McMahon was 3.3 standard deviations above the mean for passer rating.
Spiff
12/3/21 8:01pm
My point was teams were geared for run stopping. Almost 0 rush ends etc
Bobmarleyjr
12/3/21 11:52pm
Sorry. I didn't realize your argument was meant to diminish his accomplishments. My bad. I'll move along. Enjoy.
Spiff
12/4/21 8:26am
Baylor Romney was triple that, fwiw.
DieHarder
12/3/21 1:40pm
Baylor’s QB rating was 450? You sure you’re looking at right stat?
gww687
12/3/21 2:32pm
Reminds me of this gem
Jericho
12/3/21 1:42pm
Speaking of which, what happened to Lip Gallagher?
DieHarder
12/3/21 1:45pm
Did he ever make it back to his couch after driving to Hruska's Kolaches?
icecougar
12/3/21 1:50pm
He's started BMing people corrections to their posts instead of posting replys
Kajdin
12/3/21 1:53pm
Gives me a *thumbs down* or *eye roll* every now & again.
SinkingQuffa
12/3/21 3:31pm
You’ve held on to that this whole time?
ColonelMustard
12/3/21 5:17pm
I wish I could show you the boardmails that followed
Jericho
12/3/21 6:33pm
That thread is a trip. People hyped for Dinklemann. 2016 feels like forever ago
Hotlanta
12/3/21 7:54pm
He’s been good, but I will point out that there has been significant inflation in passing efficiency over the years
Odysseus
12/3/21 1:42pm
150
Big12Yfan
12/3/21 1:49pm
I’d rather have $1 in 1982 than $1 in 2021. A 150 rating doesn’t get you as much today as it did 40 years ago
Odysseus
12/3/21 1:51pm
It gets you 10-2 and in the discussion for a NY6
Big12Yfan
12/3/21 2:11pm
RE: It gets you 10-2 and in the discussion for a NY6
Odysseus
12/3/21 3:33pm
Name one QB from BYU in the 80s with a 140 passing efficiency
Big12Yfan
12/3/21 3:46pm
I’m not sure what you are arguing. I pointed out why comparing passer ratings across eras doesn’t tell us much. To
Odysseus
12/3/21 4:08pm
They aren’t changing the formula to inflate stats for current players
Big12Yfan
12/3/21 4:51pm
It got us 6-6 in 1993 and 10-2 this year. Reverse inflation I'd say.
Y05
12/3/21 4:43pm
I guess we could talk about how many wins each QB had in their first season as a starter
Odysseus
12/3/21 5:46pm
For example, Young’s rating in ‘82 put him at #6 in the country while Hall’s is outside the top 20
Odysseus
12/3/21 1:50pm
Gets me excited to see how much better he will be next season with...
icecougar
12/3/21 1:45pm
So, he's a John Walsh, but with legs. I like it
Bob Vance
12/3/21 1:46pm
Not a bad thing, since Walsh was pretty good
Mabuhay Coug
12/3/21 2:51pm
Now imagine him against Troy, Liberty, UMASS and South Alabama instead of
Big12Yfan
12/3/21 1:51pm
Impressive, Jaren…going to be an all time great if he stays on this pace!
BlooCoog
12/3/21 2:20pm
Great list of players!
Mabuhay Coug
12/3/21 2:50pm
yeah but he underthrows on long passes
All-American
12/3/21 2:52pm
That nullified interception last game kept him just over John Walsh.
Bee Chunder
12/3/21 3:01pm
What about QBR? It Factors in running. Jaren and Taysom would be higher.
Scott_Tenorman
12/3/21 3:35pm
<< Deleted >>
Bald Eagle
12/3/21 3:37pm
LOL. Why is Wilson 79 on the list? 1st year starter, SMH.
Y05
12/3/21 4:46pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad