My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Aug 10, 2022
8:11
:42
pm
byubyu
All-American
Don't plant it. You gotta live next to the guy. And he's probably right about
the roots.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
byubyu
Bio page
byubyu
Joined
Jun 28, 2006
Last login
Jun 16, 2024
Total posts
65,996 (2,915 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
What would you do in this situation? Landscaping neighbor disagreement
Scott_Tenorman
8/10/22 8:10pm
Don't plant it. You gotta live next to the guy. And he's probably right about
byubyu
8/10/22 8:11pm
I imagine a 20' tall tree would spread further than two feet under his driveway
The Dark Knight
8/10/22 8:13pm
I actually underestimated the length. It’s more like 4 feet.
Scott_Tenorman
8/10/22 8:25pm
What kind of tree?
Conan
8/10/22 8:14pm
Chinese Pistache
Scott_Tenorman
8/10/22 8:14pm
Messy tree. No way would I agree to that.
Conan
8/10/22 8:40pm
A quick Google search showed that even though their roots grow down more and less wide, you’re still easily going to
KingDave
8/10/22 9:35pm
Plant two of them. Lions, not sheep.
DieHarder
8/10/22 8:14pm
Is that with the original made in China label? Or false advertising USA label?
NYC and Japan
8/11/22 8:13am
He's right. No way a large tree will not interfere with the driveway.
byuluvr
8/10/22 8:14pm
I lived in a neighborhood where the builder planted trees in a little 2' strip
Skeptical Optimist
8/10/22 8:22pm
He’s wrong. He won’t be liable for it. You will.
Sandstone Cougar
8/10/22 8:14pm
That's a terrible place to plant a tree. You are certain to have issues with
Skeptical Optimist
8/10/22 8:18pm
Aren’t huge tree right next to sidewalks everywhere?
Scott_Tenorman
8/10/22 8:20pm
Yes, and those sidewalks are cracked
Skeptical Optimist
8/10/22 8:22pm
Yep parents house in Bountiful has in park strip. Sidewalk is a hazard now.
Blue for Life
8/10/22 9:01pm
I wouldn’t be happy if I were him. In fact, I’d dig down on my side of the
rivercitycoug
8/10/22 8:19pm
Hypothetical: Would you be willing to sign a contract accepting liability for
whirl
8/10/22 8:20pm
If it cracks his driveway, I would fix his driveway. It won’t
Scott_Tenorman
8/10/22 8:22pm
This isn't an argument you can win. Why are you so anxious to ruin neighbor relations over your idea? Let it go.
Division Bell
8/10/22 8:34pm
you might fix it but will the person who buys your house after you move and the tree is still there
byujag
8/10/22 8:35pm
Would you plant it 2 feet from the foundation of your house? I wouldn't.
Conan
8/10/22 8:40pm
Why do you say it won’t? Have seen it plenty of times. You can’t guarantee it.
Blue for Life
8/10/22 9:02pm
I’ll probably just plant a bush there instead.
Scott_Tenorman
8/10/22 8:24pm
The case law on root intrusion should give a homeowner pause about tree roots
Sandstone Cougar
8/10/22 8:27pm
RE: What would you do in this situation? Landscaping neighbor disagreement
ColdFusion1989
8/10/22 8:31pm
Where is your property line? His driveway is within 2 ft of your property?
Tare
8/10/22 8:32pm
Yes
Scott_Tenorman
8/10/22 8:33pm
He added more driveway, so it’s a foot away from the property line.
Scott_Tenorman
8/10/22 8:34pm
Why would anyone want a tree 2 feet from driveway? Good way to ruin it down
Blue for Life
8/10/22 8:59pm
Don't be a D, don't plant the tree
Peter Venkman
8/10/22 9:05pm
If your serious, I would hire an arborist, they’re pretty inexpensive, to come
BNcoug
8/10/22 10:11pm
Put a Japanese maple in. Roots won’t damage anything
claw
8/10/22 11:27pm
If you need some screening, plant some fine line buckthorn three feet from each
BlackBart
8/10/22 11:42pm
Two feet seems awfully close to a driveway. Difficult to open doors, leaves
Mitty
8/11/22 8:55am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
