My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Sep 11, 2017
3:23
:22
pm
CosmoK
All-American
Looked it up. Rule 6.4, it seems.
"A player blocked by an opponent into a free kick is not, while in bounds, deemed to have touched the ball."
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
CosmoK
New username
Madam Pattirini
Bio page
CosmoK
Joined
Jun 21, 2003
Last login
Jul 28, 2021
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Kyle implying the targeting call was iffy. Thoughts?
The Board Genius
9/11/17 2:31pm
It didn't just stand, the booth confirmed it
v1k0u6
9/11/17 2:31pm
exactly... it was textbook leading with the head...
1984coug
9/11/17 2:32pm
the crown of his helmet literally followed Mangum's to the ground.
SpiffCoug
9/11/17 2:48pm
That's funny. I agree it's a stupid call the way it is written to begin with
Bob Vance
9/11/17 2:32pm
That's exactly what Kyle said.
TFL
9/11/17 2:37pm
QB slide, led with his head, impact took off QB's helmet - easy call
LV Mike
9/11/17 2:32pm
It was the easiest targeting call I have seen, ever.
RexIdaCoug
9/11/17 2:38pm
Loser.
Ocho Cuatro
9/11/17 2:32pm
What did he last year about the one on BYU?
wapiti
9/11/17 2:33pm
Hate to see his idea of a legit one, especially given the Kai one last year.
soupie
9/11/17 2:33pm
was the definition of targeting. even utah fans have to agree that was
johnnycarson
9/11/17 2:33pm
I was just glad it was a Utah guy who got flagged so we don't have to hear
Tricky
9/11/17 2:45pm
I thought it was a good call after watching the replay. Tanner slid late, but
Rise as Utes
9/11/17 2:48pm
From what I recall, flag came in late. He was probably initially called simply
CougBlu
9/11/17 2:56pm
On TV it looked like his arm knocked it off at first and I was upset with the
Rise as Utes
9/11/17 3:00pm
Yeah. I had several Utes around me at the game. Very few complained aNd even
CougBlu
9/11/17 3:02pm
If he hadn't targeted him with his helmet he probably just slides right over top
Lance71
9/11/17 5:47pm
Live I didn't think it was a penalty, but on the replay it clearly was with how
Scratch
9/11/17 3:21pm
He's an idiot.
Mr. Scoobs
9/11/17 2:33pm
A toxic, petty person driven by hate
Carlos E. Queso
9/11/17 2:56pm
what sucks is they lost their leading tackler and we still didn't move the ball
johnnycarson
9/11/17 2:33pm
That's the dirtiest play I've seen in this game in 5+ years.
Lance71
9/11/17 2:33pm
I don't think it was intentional to the head (though this doesn't matter). It
4mack
9/11/17 2:35pm
I usually have a problem with most of these calls
BradioHead
9/11/17 2:35pm
Since it happened in the first half, he can play next game.
enigomo
9/11/17 2:50pm
It looked like there wasn't actual helmet to helmet contact, but the defensive player definitely lowered his helmet and
LilToney
9/11/17 2:36pm
You're wrong, the only thing that hit Tanner's helmet was the defender's helmet.
Lance71
9/11/17 5:49pm
Are sure. I'm pretty certain I didn't see contact. Granted, I've only seen the replay the few times they showed it at
LilToney
9/11/17 5:57pm
Pretty sure. They showed repeatedly in slo-mo while waiting...
Eddie
9/11/17 6:22pm
Legit call; rule is iffy.
byujdmba
9/11/17 2:36pm
Even without the targeting, he was pile-driving a sliding QB
cougarmeister
9/11/17 2:37pm
Seriously. Mangum was sliding feet-first, and the guy dove head-first into his helmet. The replays were awful. Textbook
Smack'sWife
9/11/17 2:50pm
Let me guess, he was making this face:
Triggerhappybunny
9/11/17 2:38pm
RE: Kyle implying the targeting call was iffy. Thoughts?
JAGA97
9/11/17 2:39pm
There was nothing iffy about it. Led with crown of helmet.
Turnpike Lane
9/11/17 2:40pm
The biggest iffy call was to not call the ball contacting the Ute player on the
Littlerich
9/11/17 2:40pm
Didn't touch him, and if it had, he was pushed to the ball (so it doesn't count)
displacedute
9/11/17 2:50pm
Show me the rule that it doesn't count if pushed into.
CosmoK
9/11/17 3:18pm
We were debating this at the game
BYU Fan
9/11/17 3:20pm
Looked it up. Rule 6.4, it seems.
CosmoK
9/11/17 3:23pm
Ok, that explains it
Littlerich
9/11/17 3:37pm
Yeah, I've seen that called a few times.
cougarstolz
9/11/17 3:37pm
I couldn't see conclusive evidence that the punt hit the player
BYU Fan
9/11/17 2:51pm
To answer your question, no Kyle is not good at thoughts.
Caboom
9/11/17 2:42pm
That was probably the most obvious targeting penalty ever. A sliding QB and you lower the crown of your head to make
SuperTank
9/11/17 2:44pm
Didn't he say it was definitely targeting as the rule defines it?
displacedute
9/11/17 2:45pm
Yes you did. Like usual.
The Board Genius
9/11/17 2:47pm
RE: Yes you did. Like usual.
displacedute
9/11/17 2:51pm
Not difficult. Just lift helmet don't lead with the crown. Hanneman need to
rcbyufan
9/11/17 2:49pm
Uh, when the QB is sliding, there is NOTHING a defender can do. A slide is
ByuMba90
9/11/17 2:51pm
The targeting plays I hate
BradioHead
9/11/17 2:51pm
He needs to rewatch it.
Eddie
9/11/17 3:56pm
I don't think that's what he was implying.
dut99002
9/11/17 2:47pm
Ha, even Hans just now called Kyle out just a little.
The Board Genius
9/11/17 2:49pm
It seems like Kyle's players have always enjoyed hitting a sliding QB
BYU Fan
9/11/17 2:52pm
He also said today that Sunia was already committed at the start of the slide.
Dwight Schr-UTE
9/11/17 2:57pm
Whit doesn't do "reasonable"
Carlos E. Queso
9/11/17 3:01pm
It was statuatory targeting; intention doesn't (and shouldn't) matter
ColoSpgs
9/11/17 2:48pm
Hillary, Comey and the FBI disagree about intent.
ByuMba90
9/11/17 2:52pm
I actually think mangum is 18 or older.
Virginia Ute
9/11/17 2:53pm
I thought it was pretty clear cut targeting. He lowered his head obviously
Virginia Ute
9/11/17 2:52pm
This is what I was thinking.
Eddie
9/11/17 3:50pm
It was. Not like he was sliding or his helmet came off or anything.
TRUE_BLUE_COUGY
9/11/17 3:24pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad