Let the best G5 champ earn an at-large spot. Why do they deserve a guaranteed

Oct 19, 2017
12:36:24pm

Martin Van Nostrand Contributor

playoff spot? When is the last time a non-P5 team finished in the top 8? Kellen Moore's Boise St? It's certainly possible but I don't think they deserve it over the 3rd best P5 non-conference champ every single year.

Report problem with this ad

Martin Van Nostrand

Bio page: Martin Van Nostrand
Joined: Aug 25, 2016
Last login: Jun 10, 2024
Total posts: 14,447 (2,512 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Playoff expansion proposal

Dissenter

10/19/17 12:32pm

Let the best G5 champ earn an at-large spot. Why do they deserve a guaranteed

Martin Van Nostrand

10/19/17 12:36pm

Based on the system messing them I say they get the one spot. 7 for P5 is enough.

Turnpike Lane

10/19/17 12:38pm

The whole point of my proposal is to get rid of P5/G5.

Dissenter

10/19/17 12:47pm

In that case, no auto-bids. Top 8 are in.

Diablo and Doc

10/19/17 1:56pm

The issue is, left to a committee, the G5 champion would never “earn” a spot

Junior Deputy

10/19/17 12:54pm

I vote yes.

Return of the Yeti

10/19/17 12:41pm

I vote yes too, but P-5 conferences will vote no. Also I have no veto power.

bluehawaiian

10/19/17 12:47pm

They really shouldn't, they'd get 7/8 almost every year

Dissenter

10/19/17 12:48pm

Letting in #13/#18/#25 over their up to 17 higher ranked teams is hard + $s

bluehawaiian

10/19/17 12:58pm

What about when 9-3 Wisconsin wins the Big10?

Dissenter

10/19/17 4:46pm

Out of every proposal I have seen, I think this makes the most sense.

bscores2

10/19/17 12:52pm

It's a good proposal, but expect gamesmanship with G5's getting ranked

Gil Buckman

10/19/17 1:08pm

I would have that 'in the top 25' dependent on the AP top 25 to prevent this

Dissenter

10/19/17 4:47pm

1) it can't expand under the current contract 2) P5 isn't some made up thing it

Nat Gas Man

10/19/17 1:16pm

Definitely wouldn't happen voluntarily, would require legal or congressional act

Gil Buckman

10/19/17 1:18pm

Take the top 8. If a P5 gets three teams in, so be it. If a G5 program

Diablo and Doc

10/19/17 2:00pm

Subjective rankings are not, in any stretch of the imagination, 'fair'

Dissenter

10/19/17 4:48pm

What is fair? Excluding a team that had a great season for some pissant G5

Posting on CougarBoard