My Account
You don't have the ability to post right now...
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 10, 2018
3:38
:18
pm
BYU313
Walk-on
I think you can still like a coach
But also think that he probably isn't the best for your program anymore.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
BYU313
Bio page
BYU313
Joined
Oct 10, 2018
Last login
Jan 30, 2024
Total posts
790 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Kalani's replacement
BYU313
10/10/18 12:42pm
Was not happy when Bronco left, still a bronco fan and watch/cheer Virginia/Navy
stealth
10/10/18 12:46pm
Jay Hill, Robert Anae, Ken Niumatalolo, Darrell Bevell, Lance Anderson, Ed Lamb
4mack
10/10/18 12:46pm
I don't rule out Ed Lamb in the future but he should be crossed off for now.
Randall Toomey
10/10/18 12:49pm
So, 2005 would you have crossed Bronco off the list?
CougarThug
10/10/18 5:28pm
No, Bronco's defenses were fun to watch and performed well when he was under
Randall Toomey
10/10/18 5:35pm
Is Lamb LDS? I thought he wasn't.
displacedute
10/10/18 5:30pm
He is not.
demon_llama
10/10/18 8:02pm
Ed Lamb can't even get the right number of players on the field.
byubyu
10/10/18 12:52pm
truth. and more than once this year
kansascougar
10/10/18 12:53pm
Of all we've seen from our coaches over the last season and a half
Randall Toomey
10/10/18 12:54pm
I doubt Niumatalolo will be eager to come back for another interview
Byu_1988
10/10/18 1:33pm
I 100% agree with Anae.
BYU313
10/10/18 1:45pm
Not a popular thing to say on CB but I agree. I have been saying Anae would be
pappabear246
10/10/18 8:58pm
Ed Lamb isn’t a member of the Church. So they’d have to change the rule
mitchwhite221
10/10/18 2:37pm
I thought he was a convert ...but i could be wrong
4mack
10/10/18 2:39pm
Not a member.
Cougstreak
10/10/18 2:41pm
He’s not a member but his wife is
SouthernBlueBlood
10/10/18 2:41pm
first female head coach? and then have ed lamb telling her what to do
Powerbait DPM studnt
10/10/18 3:31pm
Ed Lamb isn't a member
CharlottesvilleCoug
10/10/18 7:47pm
Darrell Bevell after Andy Reid turns us down...but ya gotta try
Borg
10/10/18 12:48pm
If we get Nelsons support than anything is realistic
BYU313
10/10/18 1:10pm
If you are looking for realistic and experienced candidates they are in very
mudpupper
10/10/18 12:49pm
No Jay Hill?
Randall Toomey
10/10/18 12:49pm
I think the only realistic options are Jay Hill, Ken Niumatalolo, or UVA assit.
Richbyu
10/10/18 12:51pm
I guess if you throw Peterson in then Hill would be a candidate as well
mudpupper
10/10/18 12:51pm
Here is Jay Hill's record as a HC:
Richbyu
10/10/18 12:53pm
I think Bevell is realistic at the moment, he doesn't have a job and won't have
pinolero
10/10/18 12:59pm
^^^This, this, and this. Agree on all 3.
BYUHgrad
10/11/18 5:59pm
Kelly Poppinga could be an option eventually. He is Co-DC at UVA
Jericho
10/10/18 1:13pm
Yeah I can get behind that
BYU313
10/10/18 1:14pm
It would be nice to see him get some experience and success away from Bronco
mudpupper
10/10/18 1:15pm
I'd like him to stay and coach under Bronco for a long time if possible
Jericho
10/10/18 1:20pm
I'd rather he branches out and experiences more.
Lip Gallagher
10/10/18 5:59pm
He will have plenty of time for that. He was just elevated to DC this year
Jericho
10/10/18 6:07pm
You said a long time. That's not what we want.
Lip Gallagher
10/10/18 6:29pm
Yup, I'd rather he spend more time as DC under Bronco than any other
Jericho
10/10/18 6:33pm
A short while. "Under" Bronco can be deceiving.
Lip Gallagher
10/11/18 4:26pm
You could easily make the same argument that that's the reason he
Jericho
10/11/18 4:33pm
How? Where's the benefit? Are you saying the argument is that he needs
Lip Gallagher
10/11/18 4:57pm
TLDR, just responding to your subject line, so he can get more knowledge
Jericho
10/11/18 5:23pm
Too lazy didn't read? For sure. My concept was real and simple as well.
Lip Gallagher
10/11/18 7:58pm
Apologies
Jericho
10/11/18 8:14pm
Or you're just stubborn and won't consider anything else as a slight possibility
Lip Gallagher
10/11/18 8:18pm
Or maybe I have played your game before and I think it is just boring...
Jericho
10/11/18 11:25pm
MY game? Your game is an obsession with Bronco.
Lip Gallagher
10/12/18 5:50pm
TBDR
Jericho
10/12/18 7:01pm
I really like Ken or even Anae.
BYU313
10/10/18 1:17pm
Being Poly may be a small advantage, but winning is the best advantage.
Return of the Yeti
10/10/18 2:10pm
Agreed
BYU313
10/10/18 2:49pm
<< Deleted >>
Return of the Yeti
10/10/18 2:12pm
Utah pretty much has Stanford figured out... I don't know about Lance Anderson
EEcougar
10/10/18 12:53pm
He has me intrigued right now. I'm trying to learn more about him.
mudpupper
10/10/18 12:57pm
A very good recruiter. Would probably hand the reigns to Grimes and manage the D
BYUHgrad
10/11/18 11:19pm
This whole question shows the predicament that the BYU AD has with regards to
mudpupper
10/10/18 12:55pm
Do we have to run the option if Ken comes?
BYU313
10/10/18 1:42pm
How many more years of 100+ ranked offenses until fans are okay with the option?
BYU Fan
10/10/18 4:39pm
This is why Holmoe shoud have fought to keep Bronco
Coogar2
10/10/18 7:55pm
Why? So they could at best just stay exactly as they were, and potentially
Lip Gallagher
10/11/18 4:32pm
Disagree. A change was needed...for both parties involved.
BYUHgrad
10/11/18 11:20pm
If Kalani ends season 9-3 8-4 7-5 I say keep him because he’s not getting fired. Even if he loses to Utah
SouthernBlueBlood
10/10/18 12:59pm
Any of those gets us a bowl bid, so does the outcome of that game matter to you?
BYU313
10/10/18 1:14pm
No
SouthernBlueBlood
10/10/18 1:21pm
I agree with 8-4 or 9-3 but 7-5 seems a little lacking
BYU313
10/10/18 1:38pm
I shouldn’t say I don’t care but BYU won’t change at that record
SouthernBlueBlood
10/10/18 1:45pm
Dennis Pitta
roarcougar84
10/10/18 1:10pm
What if BYU stuns Boise on the smurf turf, but we still lose to Utah?
The Lone Star Cougar
10/10/18 1:10pm
If he wins the bowl game after that then no.
BYU313
10/10/18 1:12pm
There is no likely replacement available that I would consider an upgrade
CougarCanuck76
10/10/18 1:14pm
That's sad, but I'm worried it's true
BYU313
10/10/18 1:15pm
Bevell. We need offense really bad.
mwcoug
10/10/18 1:30pm
He's a pro. Do we want pro-style?
TailgateU
10/10/18 1:35pm
Well my first choice will always be Mike Leach, but that's even more of a
mwcoug
10/10/18 1:38pm
I would love it if we got Leach.
Orem58thBall
10/10/18 1:57pm
Agreed on both accounts
BYU313
10/10/18 2:00pm
Maybe not a seismic shift. Who are his ministering bros? Get on it!
TailgateU
10/10/18 7:08pm
I once read on the board that Steve Sarkisian could be a possibility.
Powerbait DPM studnt
10/10/18 1:48pm
I thought he wasn't a member?
BYU313
10/10/18 1:50pm
He's not a member.
The Lone Star Cougar
10/10/18 1:53pm
Curious on the views of KW as a successor?
Cougstreak
10/10/18 1:55pm
If he helps us become better than Utah...
Powerbait DPM studnt
10/10/18 1:56pm
KW is not a great coach, he is better than Sitake though
BYU313
10/10/18 1:59pm
<< Deleted >>
trjohnson007
10/10/18 2:21pm
RE: KW is a great coach! UU was 1 win over CO away from PAC Champ Game in 15.
BYU313
10/10/18 2:44pm
He is a good coach and I think he’s a solid option
D.T. Survivor
10/10/18 9:10pm
I dislike this post for so many reasons but am too tired to elaborate. You just
Nagurski
10/10/18 2:11pm
...ok
BYU313
10/10/18 2:54pm
what if you went after Morgan Scalley? a HC job might persuade him to come here
Return of the Yeti
10/10/18 2:13pm
I think that's a possibility
BYU313
10/10/18 3:39pm
You love Bronco, but expect KS to beat Utah? That doesn't make sense.
Bostonblue
10/10/18 2:16pm
Come again?
Nagurski
10/10/18 2:18pm
sorry. I meant to respond to the OP. I've moved it now.
Bostonblue
10/10/18 2:25pm
Let me clarify
BYU313
10/10/18 2:41pm
So, you didn't like Bronco. Got it.
Bostonblue
10/10/18 3:27pm
I think you can still like a coach
BYU313
10/10/18 3:38pm
Ken Nuimatalolo will be the next BYU head coach.
GeraldGarner
10/10/18 3:12pm
Add it that I think he will be vested
cougswin
10/10/18 3:22pm
I heard that he only had to stick with navy for a few more years to get his
Powerbait DPM studnt
10/10/18 3:35pm
Ya, Kenny's coming, after turning down byu the first time, because he wants
Bluegoogles
10/10/18 4:48pm
Depends...
CougarThug
10/10/18 6:11pm
I hope you are right. He would be my favorite candidate
BYU313
10/10/18 3:26pm
Nah
shakarocks
10/10/18 3:56pm
I would love if he would come as HC but let an OC run the offense completely.
crack
10/10/18 4:22pm
So you are saying we have a chance...Bevell
Cougarpride
10/10/18 4:30pm
I love to laugh at all the "fire Kalani" crowd as they don't have a clue who
Bluegoogles
10/10/18 4:43pm
When at BYU, I wrote a paper arguing that Bronco should not be fired.
Powerbait DPM studnt
10/10/18 4:53pm
Did you discuss in your paper that Bronco wasn’t actually fired but
Traveshamockery
10/10/18 4:56pm
this was in 2015, so before he left... maybe it was my paper that drove him away
Powerbait DPM studnt
10/10/18 5:17pm
noone cares, but here's the paper i wrote
Powerbait DPM studnt
10/10/18 5:24pm
No I agree with you
BYU313
10/10/18 5:21pm
#justfirekalani. #crowtonwasbetter
Coogar2
10/10/18 8:01pm
What is the polar opposite for POTD? That is what this is.
UNHuskerCoug
10/10/18 4:53pm
Why do you say that?
BYU313
10/10/18 5:23pm
I say that because we are in no need of replacing
UNHuskerCoug
10/10/18 6:43pm
Ok I can respect that.
BYU313
10/10/18 11:10pm
I happen to believe that old saying, It’s not the Xs and Os,
UNHuskerCoug
10/11/18 9:32am
I can't argue with anything in that secoond paragraph, except about our RB's
BYU313
10/11/18 1:08pm
Nebraska has fired three coaches in the last 5 years and is now
deljdc
10/10/18 4:57pm
So are there really no good options for BYU?
BYU313
10/10/18 5:25pm
There is no silver bullet.
deljdc
10/11/18 6:57am
Do we need a silver bullet to beat Utah state?
BYU313
10/11/18 1:12pm
The gap between BYU and Utah State has not been very big
deljdc
10/12/18 7:22am
Do you think that gap is smaller becuase USU is better? or BYU is worse?
BYU313
10/12/18 11:02am
The question is not directed at me, but it is both.
Cougstreak
10/12/18 11:40am
Yeah that's what I would say too. Which I think could be attributted to coaching
BYU313
10/12/18 6:55pm
I see it as both
deljdc
10/12/18 7:33pm
While I liked Anae’s Offensive production, I don’t think he has the temperament
Bryceo19
10/10/18 5:03pm
Here's every member coach that I know of (head, coordinator, position, FCS, etc)
displacedute
10/10/18 5:59pm
Wow thank you, that is an awesome list. This is exactly what I wanted
BYU313
10/10/18 6:05pm
For solid head coaches, it’s a very short supply
D.T. Survivor
10/10/18 6:47pm
Yeah Gary Patterson is not of the schools faith which I believe is a requirement
BallisLife
10/10/18 7:03pm
He is a member.
Cougstreak
10/10/18 8:17pm
Ever hear of Ty Freakin’ Detmer?
UMWolverine
10/10/18 7:59pm
You're right, he's a candidate.
displacedute
10/11/18 10:42am
Being a member isn't the only criteria, as they must be a card carrying member
Bluegoogles
10/11/18 7:46am
Yes, I know.
displacedute
10/11/18 10:42am
That is a very good list
kimdaddy35
10/11/18 12:25pm
Thanks.
displacedute
10/11/18 12:31pm
I don’t hear Mike Leach’s name mentioned as a realistic option
D.T. Survivor
10/10/18 6:48pm
PAC$$>BYU $ and I believe he has to be living a higher mormon law than he does
BallisLife
10/10/18 7:04pm
Haha, you mean like Giving up the booze?
pappabear246
10/11/18 10:41am
You say “realistic option” and wonder why he is not included?
Cougstreak
10/10/18 8:15pm
What box doesn’t he check? Latter Day Saint, great HC experience,
D.T. Survivor
10/10/18 10:54pm
Yet, not realistic. No way he comes to BYU, not a fit for both parties.
Cougstreak
10/11/18 4:03am
I would give my right arm to get Leach as
pappabear246
10/11/18 10:39am
haha, beat Wisconsin on the road... then 2 weeks later people want him fired
Hill4Heisman
10/10/18 7:00pm
Getting dominated in Lavell Edwards Stadium by Utah State will do that
BeardedSpock
10/10/18 7:50pm
Yep. I wanted Kalani fired before and after Wisky
Coogar2
10/10/18 8:02pm
To be fair I only want him fired at the end of the season
BYU313
10/10/18 10:08pm
I think Jay Hill is likely the best option
BYU Fan
10/12/18 11:08am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad