My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Apr 8, 2020
5:04
:19
pm
SandYFan
Troublemaker
That's not how that works. I wanted Bronco gone, and I never thought the next
hire was guaranteed to be better than he was.
Maybe if someone wanted Bronco gone AND was a big believer in Sitake, they could be considered to be a poor evaluator of coaching talent.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
SandYFan
Bio page
SandYFan
Joined
Jan 3, 2011
Last login
Oct 21, 2020
Total posts
63,509 (1,537 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Ok- time for a controversial post.
PJMort
4/8/20 3:44pm
People here actually still believe Kalani has a higher ceiling despite having a
Mr. Scoobs
4/8/20 3:48pm
Bronco's floor was 6 wins at BYU, so a technically false statement
donnerstag
4/8/20 3:51pm
2005 finish=55. 2016-2019 finishes = 36, 112, 63, 67.
Mr. Scoobs
4/8/20 3:55pm
There were also 11 less FBS teams in 2005
donnerstag
4/8/20 4:33pm
Fans will never be the experts at objective comparisons.
Mr. Scoobs
4/8/20 4:39pm
That’s true..... Kalani got an extension after mediocrity
wilsdad
4/8/20 7:47pm
Who thinks that? I think KS is in way over his head and the program's tanking
Lifi
4/8/20 4:40pm
Sad face because it looks to be true.
ArcticKat
4/8/20 5:24pm
Silly.
Beetdiggercoug
4/8/20 6:37pm
Doesn’t KS have 2 previous HCs in his staff? He’s not over his head
Pretorian
4/9/20 5:41am
And with all that HC experience we still got Toledo and Hawaii?
ArcticKat
4/9/20 8:25am
Just because kilane is a terrible doesn't mean Bronco was good.
TheWoodman
4/9/20 6:28am
Have you noticed what Bronco has done at UVA?
Pretorian
4/9/20 8:02am
While Bronco is a very good coach, I think it was time for him to move on
mudpupper
4/8/20 3:51pm
Oh, nice dodge padawan- did you think BYU needed a new/better coach?
PJMort
4/8/20 3:57pm
I did. I'll own it. Bronco is fine, and if he's the best we can ever hope to do,
SandYFan
4/8/20 4:02pm
He’s not and it’s not even debatable. LaVell Edwards was.
ataylor
4/8/20 4:05pm
I mean for the future. I've been repeatedly told that Bronco is the best we
SandYFan
4/8/20 4:13pm
If your coach is winning 9-10 games per year, forcing him out is a bad idea.
PJMort
4/8/20 4:14pm
Well, 8-9 is more accurate. And the talent he was recruiting was consistently
SandYFan
4/8/20 4:16pm
And yet he still won 8-9 games with that "declining" talent.
TheLoneCougar
4/8/20 4:19pm
And zero special seasons since 2009. I would like more.
SandYFan
4/8/20 4:24pm
KS hasn't provided ANY special seasons thus far. Bronco is lightyears ahead of KS, but I think this is more a BYU issue.
TheLoneCougar
4/9/20 7:33am
Problem is most are not equally demanding of Kalani.
Mr. Scoobs
4/8/20 4:20pm
Like I said- those people should sit this one out.
PJMort
4/8/20 4:24pm
Some people get it.
Goatnapper'96
4/8/20 4:27pm
it is currently a disaster
Deleted
4/8/20 4:29pm
How some were discontent with Bronco yet somehow we apologize for Kalani
mudpupper
4/8/20 7:24pm
Bronco got owned in the rivalry game
MarylandFan
4/9/20 5:59am
Bronco is a Taysom hill injury (or two) away from the special season everyone
Pretorian
4/9/20 5:46am
Same story for many teams years in year out
MarylandFan
4/9/20 6:01am
What matters more than what I thought is Bronco thought BYU needed a new coach.
Art Director
4/9/20 9:46am
They didn’t knock the ball out of the park but blundered?
Pretorian
4/9/20 5:43am
Annnnnd.......?
Borg
4/8/20 4:02pm
That’s all. 😉
PJMort
4/8/20 4:08pm
That's not how that works. I wanted Bronco gone, and I never thought the next
SandYFan
4/8/20 5:04pm
Nope. You were wrong. Sorry. Flagrant 2. You must go sunbathe like Jake at Pepp.
PJMort
4/8/20 5:38pm
<< Deleted >>
Gerald-DeGroot
4/8/20 6:01pm
It was time for Bronco to move on. He has proven he’s a good coach though.
Gerald-DeGroot
4/8/20 6:03pm
Bronco needed to leave, but mant of us didn't want Sitake. Proving we are good
oldrugger
4/8/20 6:39pm
RE: Bronco needed to leave, but mant of us didn't want Sitake. Proving we are
africacoug
4/8/20 6:54pm
Lol....exactly!!!
Ygrad
4/8/20 8:03pm
Never saw a good candidate, but a new staff, none of which had ever coaches the
oldrugger
4/9/20 1:25am
It doesn't prove anything unless you can prove who you did want was actually
Lip Gallagher
4/8/20 10:27pm
i didn't want Bronco to go but I am sure he was sick of the fans that were ...
BYU Grounds
4/8/20 7:12pm
i really liked Bronco
kiyoshige
4/8/20 7:28pm
I am dumb who is DS?
BYU Grounds
4/8/20 7:36pm
Derik Stevenson
kiyoshige
4/8/20 7:44pm
Hopefully you're joking about DS
kooogar
4/8/20 8:25pm
Spot on mort!! Sit out on coaching comments, period!
Ygrad
4/8/20 8:05pm
PJMort to 1/2 of CB:
Coug Man in Florida
4/8/20 8:52pm
I never wanted to move on from Bronco, and I am very skeptical of this coaching
cougaman
4/8/20 9:02pm
Agreed, never wanted Bronco gone either, but not a fan of current coaches.
here's to hoping
4/9/20 7:58am
I was ok with Bronco leaving on his own, which he did. I didn't Kalani near the top of any list to replace Bronco.
SpiffCoug
4/8/20 9:05pm
Nice to have an occasional post from the silent majority. Thank you
MaxxPower
4/8/20 10:14pm
I doubt that the "silent majority" is enamored with the worst coach in 50 years
reddead
4/9/20 9:00am
Were you born in 2005?
Lip Gallagher
4/9/20 10:05am
<< Deleted >>
Abe Froman
4/8/20 11:00pm
Same goes for the Tanner over Taysom whiners. Their QB opinion is invalid.
dYrtbYkerYder
4/8/20 11:04pm
How many of you thought we would never be able to hire a good coach again in Bball?
HighHorse
4/9/20 6:18am
Good point. Make Pope the football coach.
ArcticKat
4/9/20 8:23am
What about those of us who wanted Bronco gone, but didn't want Sitake?
reddead
4/9/20 8:57am
How some CBers react when faced with clear facts that they were wrong.
PJMort
4/9/20 12:08pm
Sorry, but it’s not a binary world. There are more than two coaches out there
zerome4sooners
4/9/20 2:34pm
Again, who did you want instead?
PJMort
4/9/20 5:54pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad