I think many of us are looking at Bronco's success at UVA and remembering the good old days in the MWC when he beat up on everyone. We're forgetting the 8-win seasons in independence, Nick Howell's terrible, vanilla defenses, and the program's general lack of direction. I'm not sure that holding on to Bronco was the answer.
At the same time, Sitake was definitely not my first choice as a replacement. In fact, he was pretty far down the list. BYU didn't pick my preferred replacement, so why should I "sit this one out?"