My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 28, 2020
11:51
:01
am
bruincoug
Truly Addicted User
Paige, Gibson, Ryan, Hubble, Feller, Marichal ...
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
bruincoug
Bio page
bruincoug
Joined
Mar 20, 2003
Last login
May 28, 2024
Total posts
11,420 (498 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
So, is Clayton Kershaw now the greatest Pitcher of all time?
JOPE
Resident Golf Fanatic
10/28/20 11:34am
Post season performance this year stepped up.
Dr MoBYU
10/28/20 11:36am
I still go with Koufax, short career and all
AZ Coug
10/28/20 11:36am
Koufax, 12 seasons 2.76 ERA 2400 strikeouts
JOPE
10/28/20 11:50am
They are close in ERA and Ks. I think these numbers separate the two
AZ Coug
10/28/20 4:37pm
In my opinion, he should be sainted. Best Jewish/non-Jewish pitcher of all time.
baldcougar
10/28/20 11:52am
He is #34 on all time list, 1st among active players
Colorado
10/28/20 11:38am
He’s the number one starter pitcher in ERA in the live ball era
JOPE
10/28/20 11:40am
Being in the NL his whole career sure helps that, though.
JDBlue
10/28/20 11:43am
His ERA is also the lowest when you adjust for ballpark and league average
JOPE
10/28/20 11:46am
Being in the weak NL West compared to the AL East day in and day out matters too
JDBlue
10/28/20 11:48am
I'm in a small minority. Greatest for me is Nolan Ryan. Childhood hero.
gangbusters
10/28/20 11:38am
Career era 3.19, on much less rest, ~5400 Inn, ~5700 K, most no-hitters.
bruincoug
10/28/20 12:04pm
Great but not greatest. This WS he got his playoff winning percentage over 50%.
endy
10/28/20 11:38am
Definitely in the conversation with Koufax, Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez,
Jdoc
10/28/20 11:38am
...and Bob Gibson.
Hawk in the 303
10/28/20 11:48am
Yes
Jdoc
10/28/20 12:45pm
Paige, Gibson, Ryan, Hubble, Feller, Marichal ...
bruincoug
10/28/20 11:51am
...and Tom Seaver.
Hawk in the 303
10/28/20 11:52am
I think Pedro is the GOAT (Pedro was a Dodger too, so we still have the GOAT!)
BoiseBlue
10/28/20 11:55am
One more world series win with him winning 2 games in that WS then yes.
DazeofBlue
10/28/20 11:41am
Definitely Top 10. Maybe top 5. Top 3 lefty for sure.
shimmy
10/28/20 11:43am
I'd say top 5 for sure but still behind Koufax and Johnson at least.
scall
10/28/20 11:46am
No, but if he plays well another 4-5 years or more, top 5 or 10 I think.
bruincoug
10/28/20 11:47am
I agree that continued longevity will help his argument
JOPE
10/28/20 11:55am
Those stats are great but he also will never be able to shake the rep of choking
cougarblue
10/28/20 11:47am
Disagree
bruincoug
10/28/20 11:48am
That statement is ridiculous
JOPE
10/28/20 11:54am
From Sportscasting.com
cougarblue
10/28/20 12:27pm
Maddux
Freeagent12
10/28/20 11:52am
He’s a good choice, it’s tough to argue against Greg Maddux
JOPE
10/28/20 11:55am
He was great, but from overlapping era, I put Ryan, then Maddux, then Johnson
bruincoug
10/28/20 12:12pm
Nolan Ryan! Come on, Man!
doctorcoug
10/28/20 1:39pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
