I don't think having roses is that insecure. Utah has been there before along with 2 other NY bowls. Winning the conference is still a big deal.
Everyone who follows CFB saw Utah beat the Heisman winner and block USC from the CFP. That's a fun story despite Utah losing so many stars to the NFL last year and to injury this year.
Should Caleb and USC not honor his Heisman because they didn't win the CCG or the bowl game? Same thing with Ty.
I don't think it matters bro. I think BYU Fans just cling to every Utah loss like ex mo reddit clings to the 1800s as if each one is the singular defining moment.