Why do you think that?

Report problem with this ad

Oct 11, 2017
2:51:58pm

DirtyWater All-American

Report problem with this ad

DirtyWater

Bio page: DirtyWater
Joined: Aug 29, 2005
Last login: May 3, 2024
Total posts: 27,741 (798 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I realize Koy Detmer had a bad outing against USU; however, I am still a bit

LV Mike

10/11/17 1:44pm

It wasn't just the game. He hasn't really ever looked good in practice either.

dYrtbYkerYder

10/11/17 1:44pm

I watched a practice in which he looked good.

DirtyWater

10/11/17 1:46pm

I have watched a ton of practices and scrimmages

BigYfan

10/11/17 2:28pm

He's looked good in past spring games, even with limited game reps in 2015

gmj81

10/11/17 1:51pm

couldn't disagree more. he looked terrible in the spring games.

Bostonblue

10/11/17 1:55pm

He actually was giving Beau a run for his money last spring

shakarocks

10/11/17 5:06pm

He threw a beautiful pass to Trinnaman vs. USU, and led BYU to a TD called back

LV Mike

10/11/17 1:56pm

I've thrown beautiful passes in Turkey Bowls. Doesn't mean I should be BYU's QB.

dYrtbYkerYder

10/11/17 2:08pm

Koy's wasn't in a turkey bowl.

DirtyWater

10/11/17 2:12pm

Silly comment.

Cougstreak

10/11/17 6:16pm

I'm sorry, but you're wrong.

SWP

10/11/17 7:00pm

No sure if it is reverse nepotism or what. I agree.

coug almighty

10/11/17 1:45pm

I think the same. Treat the kid fairly. If he's the next man up, let him play.

DirtyWater

10/11/17 1:46pm

And I'm surprised Koy Detmer was the 2nd string QB going into the USU game

Belboz

10/11/17 1:55pm

He has the least upside of the quarterbacks in the stable

donnerstag

10/11/17 1:56pm

How do you know that? Have you ever read Lavell's account of meeting Ty?

DirtyWater

10/11/17 2:05pm

He's smaller than Ty

donnerstag

10/11/17 3:06pm

guess we're all more worried about the downside at this point. we have yet

Cougarclaw

10/11/17 2:10pm

Pretty sure there is a floor. And we're there. It literally can't get worse.

DirtyWater

10/11/17 2:12pm

six games left that includes San Jose State and UNLV - it can get worse

RugbyBYU

10/11/17 6:24pm

There is straight up something weird going on here

youngbuck

10/11/17 1:58pm

I think Kalani may have told Ty not to play Koy anymore.

dYrtbYkerYder

10/11/17 2:45pm

Why do you think that?

DirtyWater

10/11/17 2:51pm

At this point I am not inclined to believe Kilani has 'told' detmer anything.

coug almighty

10/11/17 4:33pm

Disagree. Go listen to the BSU postgame. KS says something like, "In hindsight

thecthdox

10/11/17 5:12pm

IRC he said something about tanner needing to be 90% to start this week,

coug almighty

10/11/17 8:56pm

I thought so too.... hmm....

Borg

10/11/17 2:03pm

Painfully obvious? First off Tanner led a great early drive TD

GhostofPostersPast

10/11/17 2:12pm

I'd say it became painfully obvious by the end of the first half. I would

LV Mike

10/11/17 3:07pm

Agreed on pulling Mangum

GhostofPostersPast

10/13/17 11:33am

I guess I have to disagree here.

CMuehle

10/11/17 2:14pm

Koy Detmer QB rating vs. USU: 2.9, Critch QB rating vs. BSU: 2.1

HawkeyeCoug

10/11/17 2:16pm

I'll answer with a question...

Accipiter

10/11/17 2:43pm

Not much "development" for Critchlow in last game by taking four snaps.

LV Mike

10/11/17 3:08pm

It sounds like the development goals were met.

Accipiter

10/11/17 3:19pm

Great point!

Cougstreak

10/11/17 6:16pm

Koy was awful! You are right though, Critchlow

Cougar4life123

10/11/17 2:45pm

Please keep playing Koy.

LuvMyAggies

10/11/17 3:14pm

It seems painfully obvious to me that all the credit Koy got from coaches in the

Lance71

10/11/17 3:32pm

Personnel decisions have been really, really awful this year

GOR

10/11/17 3:35pm

I don't think Critchlow was supposed to only get 4 attempts

donnerstag

10/11/17 3:39pm

Read somewhere that Koy got dinged up in the USU game. Not sure on the details.

ManicBlue

10/11/17 4:04pm

If you mean the USU game, that would make sense. But, it's strange to me that

LV Mike

10/11/17 4:48pm

Oh right ... fixed

ManicBlue

10/11/17 7:38pm

Because JoeC can be better than a healthy TM. KD would be a stop-gap.

kapcreations

10/11/17 4:53pm

Is it not very possible, even likely that they deemed Critchlow a better player

BYUfan92

10/11/17 5:02pm

lol Wait, you think he deserves preferential treatment due to being related?

Lip Gallagher

10/11/17 5:18pm

Did I suggest he get preferential treatment?

LV Mike

10/11/17 5:21pm

Yes

Lip Gallagher

10/11/17 5:56pm

No he didn't. I'm not in Detmer being a D1 QB camp but I had the same questions

coug10278

10/11/17 6:39pm

Yes he did.

Lip Gallagher

10/11/17 7:47pm

Now you're putting words in his mouth...nothing said about being treated

coug10278

10/11/17 8:40pm

Please read the OP again carefully. You will perhaps then see in context that

LV Mike

10/12/17 8:16am

Get real. He is not a D1 QB. He’s only on the team because his uncle is TFD.

mm73

10/11/17 5:34pm

TFD. Well played. Love it.

LuvMyAggies

10/12/17 11:30am

Sitake seems like he doesn't give people much time before having a meltdown

Heath Squashwell

10/11/17 6:21pm

And yet Canada still gets way too many carries - which I don't understand

LV Mike

10/11/17 6:56pm

Canada has proven carry after carry that he’s really good at getting stuffed

Heath Squashwell

10/12/17 6:56am

I think Kalani’s worrying about next yr. If Tanner can’t figure it out, Beau

Posting on CougarBoard