My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 19, 2017
12:41
:52
pm
Return of the Yeti
Walk-on
I vote yes.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Return of the Yeti
Previous username
Galileo5
Bio page
Return of the Yeti
Joined
Jan 15, 2016
Last login
May 17, 2024
Total posts
1,381 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Playoff expansion proposal
Dissenter
10/19/17 12:32pm
Let the best G5 champ earn an at-large spot. Why do they deserve a guaranteed
Martin Van Nostrand
10/19/17 12:36pm
Based on the system messing them I say they get the one spot. 7 for P5 is enough.
Turnpike Lane
10/19/17 12:38pm
The whole point of my proposal is to get rid of P5/G5.
Dissenter
10/19/17 12:47pm
In that case, no auto-bids. Top 8 are in.
Diablo and Doc
10/19/17 1:56pm
The issue is, left to a committee, the G5 champion would never “earn” a spot
Junior Deputy
10/19/17 12:54pm
I vote yes.
Return of the Yeti
10/19/17 12:41pm
I vote yes too, but P-5 conferences will vote no. Also I have no veto power.
bluehawaiian
10/19/17 12:47pm
They really shouldn't, they'd get 7/8 almost every year
Dissenter
10/19/17 12:48pm
Letting in #13/#18/#25 over their up to 17 higher ranked teams is hard + $s
bluehawaiian
10/19/17 12:58pm
What about when 9-3 Wisconsin wins the Big10?
Dissenter
10/19/17 4:46pm
Out of every proposal I have seen, I think this makes the most sense.
bscores2
10/19/17 12:52pm
It's a good proposal, but expect gamesmanship with G5's getting ranked
Gil Buckman
10/19/17 1:08pm
I would have that 'in the top 25' dependent on the AP top 25 to prevent this
Dissenter
10/19/17 4:47pm
1) it can't expand under the current contract 2) P5 isn't some made up thing it
Nat Gas Man
10/19/17 1:16pm
Definitely wouldn't happen voluntarily, would require legal or congressional act
Gil Buckman
10/19/17 1:18pm
Take the top 8. If a P5 gets three teams in, so be it. If a G5 program
Diablo and Doc
10/19/17 2:00pm
Subjective rankings are not, in any stretch of the imagination, 'fair'
Dissenter
10/19/17 4:48pm
What is fair? Excluding a team that had a great season for some pissant G5
Diablo and Doc
10/20/17 6:05pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad