Luckily we're able to have differing opinions here on CB, right?

Report problem with this ad

Nov 20, 2017
8:27:39am

ByuMba90 All-American

Report problem with this ad

ByuMba90

New username: StarMan
Bio page: ByuMba90
Joined: Jan 15, 2001
Last login: Feb 6, 2018
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I'm fine with fans that want a new OC. Just realize that it is a 100% certainty

rcbyufan

11/20/17 7:01am

Roderick’s track record is actually much better.

Dangerous

11/20/17 7:03am

No doubt. I just think the ceiling is higher with Detmer.

rcbyufan

11/20/17 7:08am

The floor certainly is lower

Turbine

11/20/17 7:25am

Sadly you can’t know that, it can always be worse

Pretorian

11/20/17 11:34am

Based on results, i am right so far.

Turbine

11/20/17 11:44am

You have no results for Roderick at BYU so you have no idea.

Pretorian

11/20/17 6:01pm

The problem is there is no evidence to back up that opinion

Left Shark Coug

11/20/17 7:28am

There’s no evidence to backup most blue goggle opinions.

Gerald-DeGroot

11/20/17 11:29am

Then why not retain him as a QB coach to learn?

coug719

11/20/17 8:32am

He may not want to take a demotion

Return of the Yeti

11/20/17 12:34pm

If Roderick is such a hot OC, how come he is unemployed?

cougarnw

11/20/17 8:25am

He's still getting a paycheck from Utah. Why take a job yet?

thebruce

11/20/17 8:30am

Because in the coaching world having a year or more not in coaching is a huge

airwolf

11/20/17 10:44am

What makes you think that? A large majority of college assistants are on 1-year

JamesWestfall

11/20/17 10:48am

How do you know this? Most assistants don't have long term contracts

Yunit

11/20/17 1:08pm

You want Detmer over Roderick???

ColumbusCoug

11/20/17 7:06am

I think you're being shortsighted.

rcbyufan

11/20/17 7:09am

Would anyone else in history be given more benefit of the doubt?

blackandblue

11/20/17 7:12am

Shortsighted? This is college football not the stock market.

ColumbusCoug

11/20/17 7:13am

Roderick for OC and Detmer for QB coach? maybe Koy Detmer for QB coach assistant

powerbait

11/20/17 7:36am

You're really that confident in your ability to assess blame for offensive woes?

Mises

11/20/17 10:21am

I'm at a point where I don't care who the new OC is. Problems are much bigger

thebruce

11/20/17 7:07am

This is where I am. I think it is obvious, too.

2FarGone

11/20/17 7:18am

Bruce you are spot on

Coogar2

11/20/17 7:27am

I'm getting there too. I was thinking things were headed in the right direction before UMASS.

Refugee

11/20/17 7:40am

After ONE bad year?

RaggaeCoug

11/20/17 8:35am

This is more then just a bad year

jes2332

11/20/17 8:41am

It's so much more than just "one bad year"

GOR

11/20/17 8:42am

Yes. He tanked byu football and aside from the results this year he doesn't

thebruce

11/20/17 8:49am

I'd take Rodericks track record over Ty's all day.

Blueto

11/20/17 7:11am

I'm not sold on Roderick. His offenses at the U were anything but specatular...

ByuMba90

11/20/17 8:26am

The problem is you are comparing Roderick under Whitt. What will it be like under Kalani?

Rhino84

11/20/17 10:00am

If Utah scored against Cal, then Roderick would still have a job.

slowhiteguy

11/20/17 7:13am

If sitake hires Roderick, he is no lavell.

idacoug

11/20/17 7:13am

Yuck.

Mister P

11/20/17 7:14am

If that’s the kind of hire KS would make, then we don’t want him as our HC.

Left Shark Coug

11/20/17 7:21am

It’s also the kind of hire the athletic department and the university would hire

Polecat

11/20/17 8:05am

Roderick would be an undeniable upgrade to Detmer

Hoax

11/20/17 7:30am

Luckily we're able to have differing opinions here on CB, right?

ByuMba90

11/20/17 8:27am

Not me. I’d take Roderick any day over what we have now.

VegasCoug83

11/20/17 8:31am

I'll take it.

dYrtbYkerYder

11/20/17 8:39am

9 people are either brain dead or related to Detmer.

Ash

11/20/17 8:49am

Yes let's see what roderick will do with Wallin Joe amd hifo drop every other ba

CarolinaCoug

11/21/17 4:23am

Then it'd be a 100% certainty that fan support

JerryAtric

11/20/17 9:38am

Not 100%, Kalani might want his brother Weber St. OC Fesi Sitake

BYU Folsom Fan

11/20/17 10:09am

Oh great. Nepotism is always the correct answer.

LV Mike

11/20/17 2:01pm

He has less experience at OC than Detmer...

Posting on CougarBoard