My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Nov 20, 2017
10:00
:01
am
Rhino84
All-American
The problem is you are comparing Roderick under Whitt. What will it be like under Kalani?
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Rhino84
Bio page
Rhino84
Joined
Aug 19, 2010
Last login
Jun 15, 2024
Total posts
5,850 (414 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
I'm fine with fans that want a new OC. Just realize that it is a 100% certainty
rcbyufan
11/20/17 7:01am
Roderick’s track record is actually much better.
Dangerous
11/20/17 7:03am
No doubt. I just think the ceiling is higher with Detmer.
rcbyufan
11/20/17 7:08am
The floor certainly is lower
Turbine
11/20/17 7:25am
Sadly you can’t know that, it can always be worse
Pretorian
11/20/17 11:34am
Based on results, i am right so far.
Turbine
11/20/17 11:44am
You have no results for Roderick at BYU so you have no idea.
Pretorian
11/20/17 6:01pm
The problem is there is no evidence to back up that opinion
Left Shark Coug
11/20/17 7:28am
There’s no evidence to backup most blue goggle opinions.
Gerald-DeGroot
11/20/17 11:29am
Then why not retain him as a QB coach to learn?
coug719
11/20/17 8:32am
He may not want to take a demotion
Return of the Yeti
11/20/17 12:34pm
If Roderick is such a hot OC, how come he is unemployed?
cougarnw
11/20/17 8:25am
He's still getting a paycheck from Utah. Why take a job yet?
thebruce
11/20/17 8:30am
Because in the coaching world having a year or more not in coaching is a huge
airwolf
11/20/17 10:44am
What makes you think that? A large majority of college assistants are on 1-year
JamesWestfall
11/20/17 10:48am
How do you know this? Most assistants don't have long term contracts
Yunit
11/20/17 1:08pm
You want Detmer over Roderick???
ColumbusCoug
11/20/17 7:06am
I think you're being shortsighted.
rcbyufan
11/20/17 7:09am
Would anyone else in history be given more benefit of the doubt?
blackandblue
11/20/17 7:12am
Shortsighted? This is college football not the stock market.
ColumbusCoug
11/20/17 7:13am
Roderick for OC and Detmer for QB coach? maybe Koy Detmer for QB coach assistant
powerbait
11/20/17 7:36am
You're really that confident in your ability to assess blame for offensive woes?
Mises
11/20/17 10:21am
I'm at a point where I don't care who the new OC is. Problems are much bigger
thebruce
11/20/17 7:07am
This is where I am. I think it is obvious, too.
2FarGone
11/20/17 7:18am
Bruce you are spot on
Coogar2
11/20/17 7:27am
I'm getting there too. I was thinking things were headed in the right direction before UMASS.
Refugee
11/20/17 7:40am
After ONE bad year?
RaggaeCoug
11/20/17 8:35am
This is more then just a bad year
jes2332
11/20/17 8:41am
It's so much more than just "one bad year"
GOR
11/20/17 8:42am
Yes. He tanked byu football and aside from the results this year he doesn't
thebruce
11/20/17 8:49am
I'd take Rodericks track record over Ty's all day.
Blueto
11/20/17 7:11am
I'm not sold on Roderick. His offenses at the U were anything but specatular...
ByuMba90
11/20/17 8:26am
The problem is you are comparing Roderick under Whitt. What will it be like under Kalani?
Rhino84
11/20/17 10:00am
If Utah scored against Cal, then Roderick would still have a job.
slowhiteguy
11/20/17 7:13am
If sitake hires Roderick, he is no lavell.
idacoug
11/20/17 7:13am
Yuck.
Mister P
11/20/17 7:14am
If that’s the kind of hire KS would make, then we don’t want him as our HC.
Left Shark Coug
11/20/17 7:21am
It’s also the kind of hire the athletic department and the university would hire
Polecat
11/20/17 8:05am
Roderick would be an undeniable upgrade to Detmer
Hoax
11/20/17 7:30am
Luckily we're able to have differing opinions here on CB, right?
ByuMba90
11/20/17 8:27am
Not me. I’d take Roderick any day over what we have now.
VegasCoug83
11/20/17 8:31am
I'll take it.
dYrtbYkerYder
11/20/17 8:39am
9 people are either brain dead or related to Detmer.
Ash
11/20/17 8:49am
Yes let's see what roderick will do with Wallin Joe amd hifo drop every other ba
CarolinaCoug
11/21/17 4:23am
Then it'd be a 100% certainty that fan support
JerryAtric
11/20/17 9:38am
Not 100%, Kalani might want his brother Weber St. OC Fesi Sitake
BYU Folsom Fan
11/20/17 10:09am
Oh great. Nepotism is always the correct answer.
LV Mike
11/20/17 2:01pm
He has less experience at OC than Detmer...
g$
11/20/17 2:10pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
