That is a very definitive statement. I'm not saying you're wrong, but what

Report problem with this ad

Dec 7, 2017
4:34:16pm

libertycoug 3rd String

makes you so sure?

Report problem with this ad

libertycoug

Bio page: libertycoug
Joined: Aug 19, 2013
Last login: Apr 26, 2024
Total posts: 2,213 (17 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Ben Criddle, if you think that a lack of autonomy is what causing Kalani to have trouble and fail,

Adrielle Semi-Legendary

12/7/17 4:24pm

That is a very definitive statement. I'm not saying you're wrong, but what

libertycoug

12/7/17 4:34pm

Didn't you just recently have a post complaining about BYU's

Lip Gallagher

12/7/17 4:43pm

Is Ben saying KS isn’t making his own calls?

Dr MoBYU

12/7/17 5:02pm

RE: Ben Criddle, if you think that a lack of autonomy is what causing Kalani to

Jizosh

12/7/17 5:46pm

Every opinion matters and I respect Big A's opinion

bcriddle

12/7/17 6:39pm

<< Deleted >>

trjohnson007

12/7/17 8:46pm

Every one of them danced around the truth.

Bonoman

12/7/17 9:00pm

Call me an idiot so you want, but I've come to these conclusions, not because of just my own opinion.

Adrielle

12/8/17 9:29am

Listen to these interviews with two former AD's and the former Director of Compliance that just left BYU

bcriddle

12/7/17 6:30pm

Me Criddle throwing down lol I love it

SL12

12/7/17 6:32pm

Kalani isn't perfect.

Cougarfan777

12/7/17 6:40pm

Let's try to not bring total nonsense into this. I know it's tempting

Lip Gallagher

12/7/17 6:42pm

Lip being Lip.

Cougarfan777

12/7/17 6:46pm

Well I mean seriously, what in that post is even worth responding to.

Lip Gallagher

12/7/17 6:50pm

Those numbers are atrocious. They were better before he got there and better the

Cougarfan777

12/7/17 7:02pm

This is the same short-sighted stuff people said about Heath Schroyer.

Lip Gallagher

12/7/17 7:10pm

Who said that about Heath Schroyer?

pspack41

12/7/17 7:35pm

Seems fair actually to me. They mirror Ty's offensive numbers so...

Shore10

12/7/17 7:43pm

RE: Seems fair actually to me. They mirror Ty's offensive numbers so...

Lip Gallagher

12/7/17 8:15pm

This🖒This 👏👏👏 Truth BOMB!

kahuna

12/8/17 1:39am

"pleads for mercy for Ty." Where have I done this in the last 4 months? I've

Cougarfan777

12/8/17 12:38pm

Proven recruiter, BYU guy and his defense in 2016 was great, but 2017 it was average

bcriddle

12/8/17 12:28am

Word.

Real Men Wear Blue

12/8/17 10:09am

Take my emotion out of it? That sounds like advice someone gave Kalani before

Cougarfan777

12/8/17 1:03pm

Regarding point #1. I'm not sure what to believe about Detmer. But I have a

Lance71

12/7/17 6:46pm

Everyone knows what they say about business and frendships

coug almighty

12/7/17 8:59pm

I think if Kalani had a “do-over” he may have hired differently but

bcriddle

12/8/17 12:38am

Great post

kahuna

12/8/17 1:43am

Huh. An intelligent data driven post.

300BLK

12/8/17 10:30am

Hmm. Every time I see a chart like this I am reminded of this quote by

Monomachos

12/8/17 10:46am

I'm not arguing whether or not Ty Detmer should have been fired.

Adrielle

12/7/17 7:03pm

Criddle no offense because I like your show but

I'mBatman

12/7/17 7:14pm

I should add that my point isn't that byu should fire Sitake

I'mBatman

12/7/17 8:36pm

Tom nor Kalani are above reproach

bcriddle

12/8/17 1:31am

bcriddle

12/8/17 1:23am

Thanks for taking time to respond

I'mBatman

12/8/17 7:51pm

I honestly think the UMass game was the final nail in the coffin for Detmer...

Coug

12/7/17 7:23pm

Agree. Inexcusable on every level. A home loss to UMass.

Real Men Wear Blue

12/8/17 10:15am

If TD was an average OC he wouldn’t have come to byu

CougarBuddy

12/7/17 7:57pm

I believe this is absolutely wrong. And it keeps being repeated. It is not true

SneakerPimp

12/7/17 8:06pm

Settle down there professor sneakerpimp I wasn’t talking about you...

CougarBuddy

12/7/17 9:17pm

And I know some top LDS professors who are happy to stay

Monomachos

12/7/17 10:25pm

Kalani failed to help Ty.

Coogar2

12/7/17 9:09pm

Ty choose the circumstances on his own...

Coug

12/7/17 10:51pm

Ty was offered the QB job and the ability to be retained...

bcriddle

12/8/17 1:24am

I hope he takes it. He’s one of the few individuals in the industry humble enough to do so.

Refugee

12/8/17 7:57am

Offered when he was relieved of oc duties or by the new oc?

CougarBuddy

12/8/17 7:59am

So you know who has been offered/accepted the OC role?

Coug

12/8/17 8:24am

Any thoughts or insights into if he takes it?

morningcalmcougar

12/8/17 9:30am

Did you just give me a homework assignment for CB?

TailgateU

12/8/17 11:00am

Kalani has needed more oversight, mentoring & counseling, not less.

korihor

12/7/17 10:06pm

Meh, I'm gonna take Criddle's insight over yours, which offers zero explanation.

Posting on CougarBoard