I really hope he has the stuff of a good HC to him. He definitely has a TON to

Dec 17, 2017
10:56:11am

mantis mutu All-American

learn, though. If it weren't for the Grimes hire, I was all about BYU biting the bullet, eating salaries, & begging Anae to come back & rescue us.

mutu.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Dec 17, 2017 at 10:56:11am

Message modified by mantis mutu on Dec 17, 2017 at 11:01:26am

Report problem with this ad

mantis mutu

Bio page: mantis mutu
Joined: Jul 4, 2005
Last login: May 17, 2018
Total posts: 36,378 (883 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I missed the Kaho de-committ but this IMO underscores

BigYfan

12/17/17 10:15am

Our average class since 2002 when these sites started has been in the mid 60s.

molodyets

12/17/17 10:16am

Doing a job one year early

BigYfan

12/17/17 10:24am

You think they would suddenly sign if we got a new coach in right now? Who

molodyets

12/17/17 10:37am

Maybe Jim Harbaugh or Urban Meyer

BrutustheBrash

12/17/17 10:44am

No, you missed my point

BigYfan

12/17/17 12:24pm

Because there was one year that was bad and the captain addressed the problem.

molodyets

12/17/17 1:00pm

😂

BigYfan

12/17/17 1:31pm

It is yet to be determined if he fixed it, but he addressed it.

molodyets

12/17/17 1:38pm

Addressing one of many problems

BigYfan

12/17/17 1:46pm

Lets see what happens the next few months with recruiting before we make any

cougaman

12/17/17 10:20am

2016 had several players in the NFL this year

BigYfan

12/17/17 10:25am

I agree, but it was 1 bad year. BYU can't afford, literally, to fire a coach

cougaman

12/17/17 10:41am

So Sitake isn't a great recruiter, like he was touted to be.

acougfan

12/17/17 10:20am

Cuz he can't sell a lie? He's obviously a very good recruiter. He'll rebound.

mantis mutu

12/17/17 10:38am

I want him to be a great recruiter and am hoping that he can be, but there

acougfan

12/17/17 10:45am

You realize he's got on roster now (that he owes NOTHING to the previous staff)

mantis mutu

12/17/17 10:50am

True about the turd and the turd is of his making unfortunately- I really do

acougfan

12/17/17 10:52am

I really hope he has the stuff of a good HC to him. He definitely has a TON to

mantis mutu

12/17/17 10:56am

Even with Bronco’s consistent success he wasn’t able to recruit above average

Duke Silver

12/17/17 10:43am

Agree mostly. But his recruiting edge still matters a ton. I think he'll shore

mantis mutu

12/17/17 10:54am

This is a reflection of scheme.

wilsdad

12/17/17 10:20am

Switching to a 4-3 is a mistake. Need to go back to 3-4

Jericho

12/17/17 10:27am

Agreed. It is just easier to recruit OLB & scheme for pressure

CaliWG

12/17/17 10:38am

I think Kalani thought he could recruit 4-3 DL

displacedute

12/17/17 10:43am

I think we should be multiple in that area. Like in 2016.

Turnpike Lane

12/17/17 10:45am

I heard the same atgument about switching to the 3-4. People complained we

SoCalCoug

12/17/17 10:45am

If that's true, these coaches are not wise

BigYfan

12/17/17 10:29am

I agree with you completely.

wilsdad

12/17/17 12:26pm

I think it's 10% on scheme, tops. LBs still play a big role in our D.

mantis mutu

12/17/17 10:47am

It will be interesting to see.

wilsdad

12/17/17 12:24pm

This year we'll have all the talent at both LB & DL to go as far as possible

mantis mutu

12/17/17 1:19pm

Disagree. First off losing Kaho has nothing to do with running the

LEHI cougar

12/17/17 10:49am

There'll be DL who come for a 4-3 but not a 3-4

Cashmeousside

12/17/17 12:12pm

<< Deleted >>

East1999

12/17/17 11:00am

It's nothing to do with hate, I'm sure he's a nice guy

BigYfan

12/17/17 12:27pm

Sitake has had some high profile transfers not reflected in rankings

D.T. Survivor

12/17/17 12:32pm

^^^this and they are finally going to get to play in 2018. BigYfan is

CougarCrazyfromAZ

12/17/17 2:00pm

Ula, Hoge, Vaka, Kirby, Empey, Folau, Tukuafu, this can’t be understated.

Reasonable1

12/17/17 4:22pm

Kafentzis was a big recruit out of high school and has been valuable too

D.T. Survivor

12/17/17 7:16pm

A bit deceiving when not accounting for xfers

BYU '80

12/17/17 2:11pm

Lol, this class was not set up to be a top 30 class. BYU would basically have to

BigBrotherUte

12/17/17 2:15pm

The fact that we had a lot of high profile guys committed is a great sign!

Reasonable1

12/17/17 4:32pm

If they can't get the most of our our current talent, I don't have much hope for

Jericho

12/17/17 4:46pm

Agreed. There are many important skills needed for a coach to succeed.

Reasonable1

12/17/17 4:52pm

This is not an objective argument

qom

12/17/17 5:25pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad